The Washington Independent
The Washington Independent

The International Court of Justice Cases

The International Court of Justice Cases

The international community has been heavily criticized for its failure to intervene during the Rwandan genocide of 1994. Recently, France has been accused of playing an active role in perpetrating the genocide. These allegations include:

Liam Evans
NewsPolitics
Last updated: Mar 12, 2021 | Oct 11, 2011

Table of Contents

Contentious Case: Rwanda v. France

The international community has been heavily criticized for its failure to intervene during the Rwandan genocide of 1994. Recently, France has been accused of playing an active role in perpetuating the genocide. These allegations include:

  • Providing vital military aid and political support to the Hutu regime
  • Arming and training the Interhamwe militias that carried out the genocide
  • Allowing genocide perpetrators to escape or reestablish themselves in safe zones under Operation Turquoise, France’s military intervention designed to stop the genocide
  • Continuing to shield Hutu genocide perpetrators, notably Agathe Habyarimana, widow of then Hutu President Juvenal Habyarimana

France’s active role during the genocide calls into question whether these actions can be punished under the UN Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide. In 2007, the ICJ ruled in a genocide case, Bosnia and Herzegovina v. Serbia and Montenegro, and the precedent set by this decision may have an effect on whether France should be held accountable for its actions.

While the main focus of this case will be on the crime of genocide, France’s actions may have also violated agreements such as the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and the underlying principles of the United Nations Charter. If it is deemed that France’s actions caused the deaths of Rwandan Tutsis, then the human rights of those affected, as protected under the proceeding declarations, have been violated. Furthermore, since French armed forces were sent into Rwanda, the legality of such an intervention can be disputed under the Hague Conventions of 1907 concerning the Laws and Customs of War on Land.

The Court, under contentious jurisdiction, can hear Rwanda’s case against France. Genocide has been a crime that has often gone unpunished. The ICJ in the Bosnia v. Serbia case took a more reserved approach and it will be interesting to how the tests established in the decision apply to France’s actions. Genocide is also a very technical topic, making way for varied opinions and heated debates among delegates.

Advisory Opinion on the Legal Status of Kashmir

The disputed territory of Kashmir is a major point of contention between India and Pakistan and an urgent problem for the international community. Violence, atrocities, and human rights violations occur in the region daily. Following the British withdrawal from the Indian subcontinent in 1947, the region was partitioned to create a Hindu India and a Muslim Pakistan. Kashmir was not ceded to either country and the Maharaja was given the choice to either join India, Pakistan or remain independent. The Maharaja was Hindu, ruling over a predominately Muslim state, and thus he decided to remain independent. These hopes were dashed when Pakistan sent Muslim tribesmen to invade Kashmir. The Maharaja appealed to the Indian government for military assistance and signed an Instrument of Accession, ceding Kashmir to India. Following these actions, India and Pakistan fought their first war over Kashmir.

India referred the conflict to the UN and in a 1948 Resolution, the UN asked Pakistan to remove a bulk of its forces and a plebiscite would be held to the people of Kashmir could decide their fate. Pakistan ignored the UN mandate. A ceasefire was reached in 1949 and a Line of Control was established, dividing Kashmir between the two countries. This line was invaded in 1965 and another conflict broke out but a ceasefire was agreed to that year. In 1971, a third war broke out between India and Pakistan. This war ended with the creation of Bangladesh and the signing of the Simla Accord in 1972. The Simla Accord reinstated the Line of Control and make provisions for the peaceful resolution of the Kashmir conflict through dialogue and bilateral talks. Since then, cross-firing along the Line of Control, nuclear tests by both India and Pakistan, and human rights violations committed by both nations continue to exacerbate the conflict.

Given that the UN has been previously involved in the conflict, the ICJ can issue an advisory opinion on the conflict under referral by the UN. There is a sense of urgency surrounding this conflict for violence continues to erupt in Kashmir. I think this case will show delegates the political consequences that can come with delivering a legal opinion. Kashmir is highly volatile and the Court will have to be extremely careful when issuing legal opinions on the various treaties involved in this conflict, potential resolutions, as well as whether Kashmir can use the right of self-determination.

Liam Evans | Liam Evans is a freelance writer and social media manager who specializes in assisting finance professionals and Fintech entrepreneurs in growing their online audience and attracting more paying customers. Liam worked as a bank teller and virtual assistant for financial firms in the United States and the United Kingdom for six years before beginning her writing career.

Related

Destiny 2 News: In Partnership With Vox Media, Polygon Is A Gaming Website.

It is a first-person shooter video game created by Bungie that is available for free to play exclusively in multiplayer mode on the internet. For the PlayStation 4, Xbox One, and Microsoft Windows platforms, it was first published as a pay-to-play title in 2017.

Fox News Trump: Donald Trump Was The 45th President Of The United States From 2017 To 2021

The Fox News Channel, abbreviated as FNC, is an American international conservative cable television channel headquartered in New York City. It is popularly known as Fox News and is styled in all capitals.

Revolver News: Hub Of Latest Conservative, Populist, Moderate, And Patriotic Liberal News And Analysis

Clan de Banlieue, based in the Dutch port city of Rotterdam, has set its sights on a more fashion-forward approach to streetwear as it expands throughout Europe.

Lifesite News: Canadian Catholic Far-right Anti-Abortion Advocacy And News Website Lifesitenews

LifeSiteNews is a non-profit Internet news service focused on culture, life, and family concerns. It was first released in September of 1997.

Stimulus News Update: All The Latest Information About A Potential Fourth Stimulus Check

A stimulus package is often a government-sponsored economic stimulation initiative. Stimulation is the process of encouraging growth or causing activity in general.

Uscis News: All Updates About Us Citizenship And Immigration Services

Immigration to the United States refers to the worldwide movement of people who are not citizens of the United States who want to live permanently in the country. Throughout most of the United States' history, immigration has been a significant source of population expansion and cultural development.

Whatfinger News: Hub Of Latest Local News

Whatfinger News is a news aggregator that gathers information from a variety of sources. Visitors may read different kinds of material, including opinion pieces and stories about current events.

Wmbf News: Get All The Latest News And Up-to-date Weather Forecasts For Myrtle Beach, Florence, And The Grand Strand In South Carolina With First Alert News

In the United States, WMBF-TV (virtual and UHF digital channel 32) is an NBC-affiliated television station licensed to Myrtle Beach, South Carolina. The station broadcasts to the Grand Strand and Pee Dee regions of South Carolina. Gray Television is the company that owns the station.

Xnxubd 2021 Nvidia: News, Configuration, Updates, Videos

Xnxubd 2021 Nvidia Videos Download: Installation, Configuration, Geforce Experience & New Updates

Exploring the Guidelines for preparing Microsoft Azure AZ-303 Exam Dumps Questions and becoming a Microsoft Architect

The world belongs to those IT experts, who do not only know Microsoft designing but securing the IPs as well. The Microsoft certification let you ace in your IT career. The successful career in IT belongs to the people who are better in implementation of solutions in Microsoft Azure Certification.

Play responsibly online: Consider these tips while playing online ream money games

Recently, the popularity of online games has skyrocketed. In particular, online casino games are loved by people. Online casinos facilitate a massive collection of various games, whether it is a round of poker, waiting for a magical combination on the slot, or the thrill at the roulette table.

© Copyright 2021 The Washington Independent All Rights Reserved

Terms & Privacy | twi.news@washingtonindependent.com