The Washington Independent
The Washington Independent
DRM: Accepted or Not in the Real World?

DRM: Accepted or Not in the Real World?

Last updated: March 31, 2021 | February 16, 2014 | Thomas Dixon
crypto

Table of Contents

Footnotes

Cory Doctorow, a copyright activist, has written an interesting article about digital rights management in the Guardian’s technology blog. In one interesting paragraph, he writes:

“The DMCA has spread to other territories, thanks to those WIPO treaties. In the UK, we got DMCA-like laws through the EUCD. Canada got them through Bill C-11. Pretty much any place that’s industrialized and wants to trade with the rest of the world has a prohibition on weakening DRM. Many of these laws – including the DMCA – have provisions that supposedly protect legitimate security research, but in practice, these are so narrow and the penalties for DMCA violations are so terrible that no one tries to avail themselves of them.”

Well, there is certainly one place in the world that is “industrialized and wants to trade” and yet, somehow, has yet to enact any laws regarding digital rights management – Israel. And that’s not for lack of pressure. The United States continues to put Israel on its Section 301 Watch List because Israel has yet to ratify and implement the WIPO Copyright Treaty (which contains provisions regarding digital rights management). The OECD has also weighed in on the issue, suggesting that “Israel should weigh the merits of providing protection for technological protection measures and rights management information”. And yet, Israel, usually so sensitive to these issues (see this previous post), has bucked the trend and not enacted any legislation regarding digital rights management.

In 2012, the Ministry of Justice proposed a bill regarding digital rights management, and expressly stated that one of the purposes of the bill was to allow Israel to join the WIPO Copyright Treaty (as well as future treaties that would undoubtedly address DRM issues). The bill never passed.

In September 2013, the Supreme Court of Israel addressed the issue in 5097/11 Telran Communications (1986) Ltd. v Charlton Ltd. in that case, Telran sold cards that allowed consumers to descramble foreign satellite signals, and some customers used those cards to watch the 2006 World Cup games. Charlton asserted that it was the exclusive licensee of the right to broadcast the 2006 World Cup in Israel and that Telran, by selling those cards, had infringed that right.

In its decision, the Court devoted several pages to the issue of digital rights management, and decided that it should not interpret the Copyright Law as implementing digital rights when the Knesset had already weighed in on the issue and decided not to include these in the statute. The Court remanded the case to the District Court to determine whether the plaintiff, despite losing on its copyright claim, could in any event advance claims for unjust enrichment. [4]

And so, here we are, in Israel, with no laws or court decisions prohibiting the circumvention of digital rights management technology (yet).

I wonder if this provides an arbitrage opportunity. In his article, Cory seemed to imply that an international consensus on implementing digital rights management was necessary for those rights to be effective in any jurisdiction. Otherwise (and maybe here I am putting words in Cory’s mouth), any DRM measures could be circumvented legally in one jurisdiction and then imported into another jurisdiction where such circumvention was not legal. So this raises a question: How would the United States or European law react to the circumvention of technological measures that were actually (and legally) performed in Israel?

Footnotes

The Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) is the United States law that (in very brief summary) prohibits the circumvention of technological measures which implement digital rights management.

Being on the watch list doesn’t actually mean that you are in bad company. I count 30 countries on the 2013 watch list, including Canada (!), Italy and Mexico. There are another 10 countries on the priority watch list, and one extra-special super-duper country (Ukraine) with “the most egregious IPR-related acts, policies and practices with the greatest adverse impact on relevant U.S. products, and that are not entering into good faith negotiations or making significant progress in negotiations to provide adequate and effective IPR protection.”

It wasn’t completely clear from Charlton’s terribly drafted contract whether Charlton had exclusive territorial rights in Israel or whether Charlton only had exclusive rights to Hebrew language broadcasts in Israel. It turned out that most of the purchasers of the Telran equipment were Arabic-speakers, and so it was not completely clear whether Charlton had the exclusive rights to the broadcasts that were actually watched by the purchasers of the Telran equipment. You don’t want to hear about how the Court broke its teeth interpreting the contract. My only comment – people should have good lawyers draft their contracts.

The Court cited a commentator that distinguished between a hypothetical situation where a defendant circumvented DRM and charged consumers for viewing the unscrambled broadcast and another hypothetical situation where the defendant sold equipment to circumvent DRM to consumers, and it was the consumers who actually used the equipment to circumvent DRM and watch the broadcasts without payment. In the former case, it may be easier to advance a claim for unjust enrichment.

Thomas Dixon | He creates the ideal marketing experience by connecting online brands with their target audiences. He recently completed a research paper on consumer conversion and took part in a community project on SEO optimization. Thomas is working on his Bachelor of Arts in Communications and plans to intern in an online marketing department soon.

Related

How to File a Complaint Against Coinbase

Coinbase is one of the most popular cryptocurrency exchange platforms because of its convenient and straightforward account registration process. This platform allows you to link your credit card or bank account and transfer funds through any of these mediums.

Beginners Guide to Cryptocurrency

These days, it seems as if you cannot turn on any piece of financial news without hearing about cryptocurrency. Almost overnight, the crypto industry has become absurdly popular, earning investors millions and turning into a brand new financial sector.

Beginners Guide to Cryptocurrency

Best cryptocurrency to invest in 2021

Investing in crypto has never been this convenient. Now that the internet is so powerful, everything else can be done in a click.

Best cryptocurrency to invest in 2021

Are NFTs Worth Your Money?

A virtual artwork has sold for an eye-watering $69 million (£50 million) at Christie's auction site, but the buyer will not receive a statue, painting, or maybe even a print. Instead, they receive an NFT, which is a one-of-a-kind digital token.

Are NFTs Worth Your Money?

EBay open for payment acceptance of bitcoin

EBay CEO says they want to incorporate payment cryptocurrency and how NFTs will be implemented on the website.

EBay open for payment acceptance of bitcoin

Ethereum's market value has surpassed Coca-Cola, Berkshire Hathaway, and Roche since peaking over $300 billion this week

Ethereum's market value has surpassed Coca-Cola, Berkshire Hathaway, and Roche since peaking over $300 billion this week.

Ethereum's market value has surpassed Coca-Cola, Berkshire Hathaway, and Roche since peaking over $300 billion this week

Plenty of wonders: the Gemini exchange now supports dogecoin

Funniest and friendliest coin in the observable space: today we are proud to announce trade and custody support for Dogecoin (DOGE).

Plenty of wonders: the Gemini exchange now supports dogecoin

The price of Ethereum (ETH) has surpassed $3,000 for the first time in history

Shortly after breaching the $2,000-level, ETH is approaching the $3,000-value threshold.

The price of Ethereum (ETH) has surpassed $3,000 for the first time in history

About $440,000 was donated in crypto to support the understanding of autism

Nexo audiences were able to contribute in cryptocurrencies to the "ColorTheSpectrum" stream thanks to funding from the Nexo project.

About $440,000 was donated in crypto to support the understanding of autism

© Copyright 2021 The Washington Independent All Rights Reserved

Terms & Privacy | twi.news@washingtonindependent.com