In Florida, Tea Party Movement Takes on Political Party of the Same Name

June 21, 2010 | Last updated: July 31, 2020

florida tea party 245x143 It isn’t the first time a schism within the Tea Party led conservative activists to question one another’s bona fides.

Back in October, a bitter feud broke out between the Tea Party Patriots and the Tea Party Express, with the former accusing the latter of aligning too closely with the GOP. Then, in March, the Tea Party Express alleged that Scott Ashjian, a self-proclaimed Tea Party candidate for U.S. Senate in Nevada, was a Democratic plant working to get Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.) re-elected.

Now, the stage has moved to Florida, where an Orlando rally this weekend saw Tea Partiers criticizing the Florida Tea Party’s motives.

The rally, organized by Americans for Prosperity, brought together several dozen people to oppose the “big government policies” of Reps. Suzanne Kosmas and Alan Grayson, Florida freshmen on the Republican “hit list” of vulnerable Democratic incumbents. Speakers denounced excessive regulation and government spending, and several reserved special wrath for the Florida Tea Party, which they fear could hurt their side’s chances in November.

The long-simmering dispute between party and movement took on new significance last week as the party entered a spate of new candidates before Friday’s filing deadline. Activists claim the Democratic Party is behind many of the candidates.

Bruce O’Donahue, part of the crowded field of contenders in the Republican primary vying to challenge Grayson for the District 8 congressional seat, held a press conference Thursday in the same location as Saturday’s rally. He condemned the Tea Party and its candidate, Peg Dunmire, who he called a “Grayson stooge.”

Grayson’s response, as quoted by Politico: “All right, you got me. I invented the Tea Party. Sarah Palin is a puppet, and she does whatever I tell her to do.”

By the filing deadline Friday, the party had slated 20 candidates in Florida races.

“While a few Tea Party candidates across the state do have ties to the tea party movement, in the majority of instances, it appears that the Democrats have coordinated a dishonest attempt to hide phony candidates behind the name ‘tea party’ and to confuse voters who may be supportive of the tea party movement, effectively stealing votes from true conservative candidates and injuring the grassroots tea party movement as a whole,” Republican Party of Florida chair and state Rep. John Thrasher said in a statement.

“Despite their beliefs, the black helicopters are not coming to get John Thrasher,” Democrat spokesman Eric Jotkoff shot back in the St. Petersburg Times.

Jason Hoyt, a local radio host who helped establish the Tea Party movement in Orlando, says the party makes a mockery of the movement that shares its name (a fact that is the subject of an ongoing legal battle). He adds that the Tea Party has caused confusion among supporters. ”Everywhere we go, we have to make this disclaimer,” he says.

He says the movement plans to back “constitutional conservatives” in Republican primaries for reasons of both tactics (a united conservative front stands a better chance at winning in November) and principle (the movement believes candidates should be chosen by a popular vote, not selected by a party).

The fact that Fred O’Neal, the party’s one-man executive committee, was once a registered Democrat also raised the suspicions of Tea Partiers, including Dan Fanelli, another candidate in the Republican Primary for Grayson’s seat, who says the party invited him to be its candidate in that race.

Don’t expect Florida to be the last stop for this show.