• News
    • Archive
  • Celebrities
  • Finance
  • Crypto
  • Entertainment
  • Travel
  • Health
  • Others

Supreme Court Nominee Debate Defined by Conservatives

97.6KShares
1.3MViews
Obama-blue-tie.jpg
Obama-blue-tie.jpg

President Barack Obama (WDCpix)

With President Obama’s announcement of his first Supreme Court nominee likely to come as early as this week, liberals and conservatives jockeying for position in the confirmation battle have begun to find their roles. So far, it is conservatives who have generally succeeded in defining the terms of the debate, while liberals have been left to defend against charges of coded language and hidden agendas.

After Justice David Souter announced his retirement on May 1, Obama laid out a broad spectrum of qualities he will seek in his nominee at a press briefing. Among these were “a sharp and independent mind,” “a record of excellence and integrity,” “respect for constitutional values” and “empathy.”

Law.jpg
Law.jpg

COPYRIGHT_WI: Published on https://washingtonindependent.com/43327/supreme-court-nominee-debate-defined-by-conservatives/ by - on 2020-07-31T00:00:00.000Z

Illustration by: Matt Mahurin

Given this range of terms to work with, conservatives quickly settled on “empathy” as the one around which to draw the battle lines, and the others faded from the debate. Obama did not utter the word “empathy” without forethought; he had used the term two years earlier as a senator in discussing Supreme Court nominations. But since his May 1 statement, he has had little control over which of the many criteria he put forth receive attention and which get shunted aside. Conservatives saw a potential political advantage in attacking “empathy,” and liberals have been unable to reframe the debate around other terms that may be more to their benefit.

Sen. Orrin Hatch (R-Utah) led the charge against “empathy.” “[Obama] said that a judge has to be a person of empathy,” Hatch said on ABC’s This Week two days after Obama’s statement. “What does that mean? Usually that’s a code word for an activist judge.”

Since then, Republicans have continued to hammer Obama for his “empathy” criterion. Former George W. Bush senior adviser Karl Rove called it code for a “liberal, activist Supreme Court justice,” and John Yoo, Bush’s head of the Office of Legal Counsel who has since come under scrutiny for his role in authorizing extreme interrogation techniques, cautioned that by nominating “a Great Empathizer,” Obama would “give Senate Republicans yet another opportunity to rally around a unifying issue.” Yet as conservatives set the rhetorical stage for the confirmation battle, liberals active in the judicial process are trying, with little success, to move the debate past “empathy.”

Conservative judicial experts believe the empathy argument is a political winner for Republicans, and they have shaped their talking points accordingly. Gary Marx, executive director of the Judicial Confirmation Network, a conservative organization that promotes “the confirmation of highly qualified individuals to the Supreme Court of the United States,” believes that judicial empathy and adherence to the text of the Constitution are incompatible.

“He said he wants someone who respects the rule of law, and he wants someone with empathy,” Marx said of Obama. “You can’t have it both ways, Barack.”

“Conservatives get a little upset when the president uses the word empathy,” agreed Brian Darling, the director of U.S. Senate relations at the Heritage Foundation and a former counsel to two Republican senators. “The word empathy doesn’t show up in the Constitution.”

While progressives involved in the judicial nomination debate dispute conservatives’ characterization of code words, they appear reluctant to offer new language to redirect the discussion, instead reacting with bewilderment and frustration to conservative attacks.

Goodwin Liu, a Berkeley law professor and the chairman of the board of directors of the American Constitution Society, a liberal legal organization, expressed surprise at the controversy that “empathy,” a positive term, has engendered. “I’m a little baffled by that,” he said. “If it’s a code word, I don’t know what it’s a code word for.”

On another conservative line of attack — judicial activism — liberal experts countered that this label was itself a code.

Bill Yeomans, the legal director of the progressive advocacy group Alliance for Justice, said that the term judicial activism “is sort of thrown out unthinkingly” by conservatives who use it as a proxy for a number of different lines of attack. “It’s a code word,” he said. In its own right, it “doesn’t really mean anything.”

Liu concurred. “Judicial activism is a result that someone doesn’t like,” he said. “That’s it.”

Yeomans and Liu both argued that if activism is measured by a departure from precedent, the conservatives on the bench have been more activist than their liberal counterparts. “By any definition of judicial activism, I think it’s fair to say that the conservatives have been the activists over the past ten years or so,” said Liu.

While the liberal experts took issue with the key terms used by conservatives — or at least their usage of those terms — they shied away from putting forward new catchwords. “I guess I’d want to get away from the concept of code words,” said Yeomans. He wants to see the confirmation hearings focus on intelligence, knowledge of the law, an open mind and a willingness to follow the facts — a reframing that would take the game off of the Republicans’ court.

Conservatives, on the other hand, have a number of catch phrases they want to apply to Supreme Court nominees. “We will continue to be using the metaphor of the neutral umpire,” said Marx, echoing the language used by now-Chief Justice John Roberts in his 2005 confirmation hearing. Marx listed two other qualifications a justice should possess: “judicial restraint” and “not legislating from the bench.”

He also pulled out a Biblical reference to make his point. King Solomon, he said, did not need “empathy” or “compassion” to resolve the famous baby case. “Was that compassionate?” he asked rhetorically. “No, it was wisdom.”

Despite their success in determining which terms have come to dominate the debate, conservatives acknowledge that their purpose may not be so much to block the confirmation of a justice as to score political and perhaps fundraising points for future elections.

Marx says that the confirmation debate will have “three huge implications”: it will educate the American people about the issues, help them understand Obama’s true political philosophy and set the stage for the 2010 U.S. Senate campaigns.

According to Darling, the effects of this battle could extend to 2012 as well. “Whoever this nominee’s going to be,” he said, “if the court moves forward on gay marriage or restricts the Second Amendment or goes forward with another change that’s unpopular among the American public… that’s something that will affect the president’s reelection bid.”

Still, the game is likely to change considerably when Obama announces his nominee. “To be honest, I think this is all noise,” Darling conceded. “It will become completely irrelevant when the nominee is put forth.”

Share: Twitter | Facebook | Linkedin

Recent Articles

  • 10 Headphones For Remote Work To Stay Focused And Productive

    Technology

    10 Headphones For Remote Work To Stay Focused And Productive

    Are you tired of your noisy neighbors, chatty family members, or barking dogs interrupting your work-from-home groove? Well, fear not! We've got just the thing for you - headphones for remote work! Yes, that's right, the perfect solution to drown out the distractions and immerse yourself in your work. But with so many options out there, which ones should you choose?

  • 10 Best Colleges In Washington 2023

    Culture

    10 Best Colleges In Washington 2023

    Best Colleges to study in Washington

  • The Columbian Mosaic In Colonial America

    Culture

    The Columbian Mosaic In Colonial America

    Get to know more about the Columbian mosaic during the Colonial American period.

  • The Consequences Of A Shrunken Atom - The Possibilities

    Science

    The Consequences Of A Shrunken Atom - The Possibilities

    Atoms cannot be reduced in size. Besides, they’re already way too small for the naked eye to be seen; so, why bother? But what if they could still be made 1 percent smaller? What could be the consequences of a shrunken atom in this world?

  • Best Lotion For Jerking Off That Won't Damage Your Skin In 2023

    Health

    Best Lotion For Jerking Off That Won't Damage Your Skin In 2023

    Many people nowadays are looking for the best lotion for jerking off that will enhance their self-pleasure moments while not harming their skin.

  • Angel Number 8888 Meaning - Symbol Of Significant Changes In Life

    Numerology

    Angel Number 8888 Meaning - Symbol Of Significant Changes In Life

    When you see a number over and over again, you may even think that it is just a coincidence. Often, these numbers are sent by the angels to give you a message about ways to live your life and make positive changes. One of these numbers is 8888, which could have special significance for you. The Angel Number 8888 meaning is awareness, strength, and confidence.

  • How to Make Money Investing in Cryptocurrency

    Crypto

    How to Make Money Investing in Cryptocurrency

    Although a number of cryptocurrencies have generated returns of over 10,000% in the prior year alone, the process of making money isn’t as easy as it sounds.

  • When To Sell Crypto? The Must-Knows Of Selling

    Crypto

    When To Sell Crypto? The Must-Knows Of Selling

    You may not be able to get rid of all your irritation, but there are principles you can follow that will make the choice simpler for you and save you from losing all of your money. Extreme poverty is more difficult to deal with than frustration.

  • Level Up Your Cryptocurrency Trading Strategies With DEXTools In 2023

    Crypto

    Level Up Your Cryptocurrency Trading Strategies With DEXTools In 2023

    DEXtools is a pricing data analytics tool that makes navigating decentralized networks easier for traders. The ability to keep track of the current price of tokens is one of the platform's most significant features. Let's get started with Dextools' fundamentals.

  • Money Management - Keep Track Of Your Finances Now

  • Top Frugal Living Tips To Follow In 2023

  • 7 Ways to Make Money on Instagram

  • Raina Patricia - The Wife Of Famous Football Coach Matt Patricia

  • Noah Beck Zodiac Sign