Click here to check the ultimate guide to learn how to leverage your PC and internet to make money online.
The Washington Independent
The Washington Independent

State Dept and Pentagon officials At Odds over Gitmo Detainee Policy

Katharine Tate
Last updated: Jul 31, 2020 | Nov 22, 2008

Contacted in response to my story yesterday about the debate over national security courts, I spoke today to

the former Chief Counsel at the state department focused on detainee issues, who revealed an apparent schism between the State Dept on the one hand, and the Pentagon and executive on the other, when it comes to what to do with the Guantanamo detainees against whom they don’t have any solid evidence.

Vijay Padmanabhan, who left State in August and is now a Visiting Assistant Professor at Cardozo Law School, says that the government’s policy of defending the detention of all of these Guantanamo detainees now being litigated in habeas cases in federal courts is just bad policy. Although the state department supposedly gets to weigh in on such things, it seems that the position of Deputy Secretary of Defense Gordon England, who ultimately decides DOD’s position, has been winning out. (Padmanabhan emphasized that he couldn’t tell me what advice he’d given his client, the State Dept, when he was there, but you could pretty much guess from the views he’s espousing today.)

The case of the five Algerians picked up in Bosnia and ordered freed yesterday by a federal district court is a particularly egregious example of the kind of case the US government ought not to be fighting, Padmanabhan said. “They were never alleged to have gone to Afghanistan or participated in the conflict there in any way.”

Initially, the US said these men had planned to blow up the US embassy in Bosnia. When Bosnian courts decided that there was insufficient evidence to detain them, the US government whisked them off to Guantanamo Bay. Eventually, the US just stopped claiming that they were involved in any plot to blow up a US embassy. But they kept holding them.

“So they came up with this post hoc rationalization, which was that they were intending to go to Afghanistan sometime in the future,” says Padmanabhan. The evidence supporting that was what Judge Leon yesterday called “a thin reed” and totally insufficient to support their continued detention.

“My bigger picture view of these cases is that the government should really be focusing on defending the detentions of the individuals who are the most serious threats to national security that we face. Going to court repeatedly with weak or nonexistent cases against detainees results in a growing public sense that there’s nobody being detained at Guantanamo that should be detained,” he said. “It undermines the world’s understanding of why we hold anybody there at all.”

So why is the US government doing this?

“I think the defense department in particular is rudderless,” said Padmanabhan. “It lacks any real strategic sense with respect to the long-term detention picture. They have never thought, ‘what happens if we lose many of these court cases? What are the long term strategic consequences?’ They just keep fighting them, and then if something bad happens they can blame the court.”

Although the state department is supposed to have some say on these issues, in particular regarding how ongoing litigation affects US public diplomacy, voices like this former senior state department lawyer’s have obviously been drowned out by DOD, and ultimately by the national security council and the president.

We know already about the conflicts between the State Dept and the Pentagon on conduct of the Iraq war; now it seems they’re at odds over how to deal with the hundreds of detainees from the “war on terror” as well.

Katharine Tate | I’m a native of Massachusetts, where I earned bachelor's degrees in Health: Science, Society, and Policy and Sculpture from Brandeis University. I enjoy assisting and inspiring women in all aspects of their lives, and I consider myself a partner in their OB an GYN treatment. I particularly enjoy forming relationships with young women and assisting them in determining their healthcare needs and goals. I love to travel, create metal and fiber art, cook, and spend time outside. Also, I’m fluent in both German and American Sign Language.


Rep. Paul Ryan to deliver SOTU response

Chairman of the House Budget Committee Rep. Paul Ryan (R-Wis.) will deliver the Republican response to the State of the Union Tuesday, according to Mike Allen

Rep. Parker Griffith (R-Ala.)

One of the most conservative Democrats in the House -- a freshman who said he couldn’t support Nancy Pelosi again -- is going to switch over to the GOP. Josh

Rep. Paulsen touts balanced budget constitutional amendment

In a post for the conservative blog True North , U.S. Rep

Rep. Patrick McHenry: Please, Conservatives, Fill Out Your Census Forms!

The conservative congressman from North Carolina, a constant critic of the census -- one of the people who sounded the alarm about politicization when the

Rep. Paulsen, Karl Rove the latest to get ‘glittered’

Rep. Erik Paulsen and former Bush staffer Karl Rove were both showered with glitter at the Midwest Leadership Conference Friday

Rep. Paulsen allies with medical device industry to relax FDA oversight

Source: Flickr; Republicanconference ( On the heels of the Minnesota Independent story last week about U.S. Rep. Erik Paulsen’s cozy financial relationship with the medical device industry, the New York Times reported Tuesday that some health professionals are alarmed by Paulsen’s push to relax Food and Drug Administration (FDA) oversight

Rep. Perlmutter criticizes House measure that would eliminate 800K federal jobs

Congressman Ed Perlmutter today issued a scathing statement criticizing the House of Representatives for passing a spending bill that could put nearly a million federal employees out of work. The Colorado delegation voted strictly on party lines, with all four Republicans voting in favor of the bill and the three Democrats voting in opposition. Perlmutter’s statement: “My number one priority is to get people back to work because that’s the best thing we can do to pay our debt and move forward toward economic stability

Rep. Perlmutter to hold constituent meet-up in grocery store

Colorado Congressman Ed Perlmutter will hold a Government in the Grocery constituent meet-up this evening from 5-7 at the Safeway at 38th and Wadsworth in Wheat Ridge. The address is 3900 Wadsworth. The meeting, where Perlmutter typically sits at a folding table and talks to whomever shows up, is free and open to the public

Rep. Pete Stark Won’t Dignify Constituent by, er, Micturating Upon His Leg

In the tradition of Rep. Barney Frank (D-Mass.), California Democratic Rep. Pete Stark revealed at a recent town hall gathering that there are limits to what

© Copyright 2022 The Washington Independent All Rights Reserved

Terms & Privacy |

Click here to check the ultimate guide to learn how to leverage your PC and internet to make money online.