Immigration and Agriculture: The Non-Colbert Debate

By
Friday, September 24, 2010 at 12:19 pm

Today’s Congressional hearing on migrant labor in agriculture wasn’t just about Stephen Colbert. There was also a pretty serious debate over what type of reform is needed to get legal workers — particularly unemployed American workers — into agricultural jobs. Republicans on the committee argued migrant farm workers take jobs away from the unemployed. Of course, it isn’t clear Americans want those jobs anyway.

“America cannot continue to bring in low-skilled guest workers to compete with its most vulnerable citizens: the poor whites, the blacks, and the legal Hispanics,” Carol Swain, a professor at Vanderbilt University, said in her testimony, which was applauded by Republican committee members Steve King (R-Iowa) and Lamar Smith (R-Tex.).

Failure of United Farm Workers of America’s “Take Our Jobs” initiative, admittedly a tongue-in-cheek effort to give farm jobs to Americans, was used as proof of the agricultural industry’s need for migrant labor. “As the campaign of the farm workers has shown, there are some jobs that are not a good fit for people who are unemployed,” Rep. Zoe Lofgren (D-Calif.) said.

The problem is that many agriculture jobs are seasonal, meaning they require workers to move around the country to find work. Migrant farm labor is also difficult and requires long hours at often low pay, with fewer rights than are afforded to other types of laborers. The system is not designed in a way that makes it attractive to American workers, argued Arturo Rodriguez, president of United Farm Workers of America.

“Our society places all the risks and costs associated with a seasonal industry — featuring millions of short-term jobs — on the backs of the workers,” Rodriguez said. “If a worker is injured on the job or stiffed on payday, too often there is no real recourse. Is it any wonder that Americans don’t want these jobs?”

Still, the jobs are critically important to agricultural production in the U.S., said Phil Glaize, who runs Glaize Orchards in Winchester, Va. Without workers, some agricultural production could halt, causing growers to lose crops and shut down. Glaize said the legal method for allowing migrant workers into the country is too slow and argued visa reform is necessary.

“Growers are forced to choose between using the broken H-2A guest-worker program which is bureaucratic, inefficient and downright unreliable, or hire migrant workers who present documents that appear to be ‘good’ but who may or may not be in this country legally,” he said.

Although about two million workers are needed to keep American agriculture running, only 5,000 visas per year are set aside for migrant workers, Lofgren said. Advocates of worker visa reform argue foreign workers should be allowed in the country to help spur growth in certain industries, including agriculture.

The AgJOBS would be one way to enact that reform, if comprehensive immigration reform proves impossible. The bill would allow two million farm workers to work in the U.S. eventually become legal residents.

Follow Elise Foley on Twitter


Comments

33 Comments

Fresh off farm gig, comedian Colbert testifies in House hearing – CNN | News BB
Pingback posted September 24, 2010 @ 12:38 pm

[...] in congressional testimonyBaltimore SunThe Associated Press -FOXNews -The Washington Independentall 753 news [...]


Crop succession requirements in agricultural production planning [An article from: European Journal of Operational Research] | Best Production Books
Pingback posted September 24, 2010 @ 1:00 pm

[...] Immigration and Agriculture: The Non-Colbert Debate « The … [...]


Immigration and Agriculture: The Non-Colbert Debate – The Washington Independent – BIGJUNCTION.INFO
Pingback posted September 24, 2010 @ 1:29 pm

[...] Immigration and Agriculture: The Non-Colbert DebateThe Washington IndependentRepublicans on the committee argued migrant farm workers take jobs away from the unemployed. Of course, it isn't clear Americans want those jobs anyway. …Strange Event: Comedian Testifies About Farming JobsMyStateline.comColbert Stays in Character at Congressional Hearing on Farm JobsNewsHourColbert seriously jokes to Congress about migrant agricultural workUSA TodayCNN -Washington Post -Think Progressall 844 news articles » [...]


Latest Non Surgical Hair Replacement Auctions | Uncategorized | Welcome to the healthy hair beauty supply blog!
Pingback posted September 24, 2010 @ 3:32 pm

[...] Immigration and Agriculture: The Non-Colbert Debate « The … [...]


Immigration and Agriculture: The Non-Colbert Debate « The …
Pingback posted September 24, 2010 @ 4:19 pm

[...] by on September 24, 2010 Hello there! If you are new here, you might want to subscribe to the RSS feed for updates on this topic.Powered by WP Greet Box The AgJOBS would be one way to enact that reform, if comprehensive immigration reform proves impossible. The bill would allow two million farm workers to work in the U.S. eventually become legal residents. … Original post: Immigration and Agriculture: The Non-Colbert Debate « The … [...]


bleditordrew
Comment posted September 24, 2010 @ 5:14 pm

I've just shared this blog and some other great news on Colbert's hearing with the Congressional Subcommittee!

http://bleditor.com/bledit.php?bleditID=14728


Zoe Lofgren
Pingback posted September 24, 2010 @ 6:26 pm

[...] has been a Democratic member of the United States House of. Zoe lofgren reviews, answers and questioZoe Lofgren – Zoe Lofgren (born Sue Lofgren on December 21, 1947, in San Mateo, California), American [...]


Immigration and Agriculture: The Non-Colbert Debate « The … « Cool Immigration
Pingback posted September 24, 2010 @ 9:33 pm

[...] here to see the original: Immigration and Agriculture: The Non-Colbert Debate « The … Comments [...]


Some Hidden Meanings Behind Tarot Readings | New Age Meditation Techniques
Pingback posted September 24, 2010 @ 9:45 pm

[...] Immigration and Agriculture: The Non-Colbert Debate « The … [...]


The Best MLM Company: Yes, It Does Exists | Internet Marketing is Nuts!
Pingback posted September 24, 2010 @ 9:52 pm

[...] Immigration and Agriculture: The Non-Colbert Debate « The … [...]


J_m_randolph
Comment posted September 24, 2010 @ 9:45 pm

Please listern to “Two Pesos Pobres”

A serious song written for our field workers.

http://www.muzlink.com//artist0011517.code


Group ends rooftop protest | Man game
Pingback posted September 24, 2010 @ 11:26 pm

[...] Immigration and Agriculture: The Non-Colbert Debate « The Washington Independent [...]


World Wide News Flash
Trackback posted September 25, 2010 @ 12:33 am

Immigration and Agriculture: The Non-Colbert Debate « The ……

I found your entry interesting do I’ve added a Trackback to it on my weblog :)…


Farm Workers Say “Take Our Jobs” – KERO-TV 23 – BIGJUNCTION.INFO
Pingback posted September 25, 2010 @ 1:30 am

[...] corny reportWashington TimesPrepping for showFOXNews (blog)MyStateline.com -The Washington Independent -Neon Tommyall 1,344 news [...]


US comic gets serious – sort of – on Capitol Hill – AFP – BIGJUNCTION.INFO
Pingback posted September 25, 2010 @ 1:32 am

[...] corny reportWashington TimesStrange Event: Comedian Testifies About Farming JobsMyStateline.comThe Washington Independent -Neon Tommy -USA Todayall 1,347 news [...]


How do they wash colors of hair are good? | Uncategorized | Welcome to the healthy hair beauty supply blog!
Pingback posted September 25, 2010 @ 3:39 am

[...] Immigration and Agriculture: The Non-Colbert Debate « The … [...]


More substance needed North Capitol Street
Pingback posted September 25, 2010 @ 5:46 am

[...] Immigration and Agriculture: The Non-Colbert Debate « The … [...]


Brandi Hitt Investigates: Take Our Jobs – CBS 13 – BIGJUNCTION.INFO
Pingback posted September 25, 2010 @ 8:00 am

[...] Our Jobs"KERO-TV 23Strange Event: Comedian Testifies About Farming JobsMyStateline.comThe Washington Independent -Neon Tommy -CBS Newsall 1,403 news [...]


Immigration and Agriculture: The Non-Colbert Debate « The … | Independent
Pingback posted September 25, 2010 @ 8:28 am

[...] more: Immigration and Agriculture: The Non-Colbert Debate « The … Tags: a-pretty-serious, congressional, debate-over, get-legal, hearing-on-migrant, migrant-labor, [...]


Speaking on Immigrants in Agriculture, Colbert Draws a Crowd to Capitol Hill – Kansas City infoZine – BIGJUNCTION.INFO
Pingback posted September 25, 2010 @ 10:10 am

[...] comic gets serious – sort of – on Capitol HillAFPKERO-TV 23 -MyStateline.com -The Washington Independentall 1,435 news [...]


Mysilverstate.com-Where progressive netizens unite
Trackback posted September 25, 2010 @ 11:51 am

Kennedy-Nixon: Reign of image politics turns 50…

I found your entry interesting do I’ve added a Trackback to it on my weblog :)…


Agriculture Business BioTechology | Agriculture Equipment
Pingback posted September 26, 2010 @ 1:05 am

[...] Immigration and Agriculture: The Non-Colbert Debate « The… [...]


Texans back Arizona-style bill North Capitol Street
Pingback posted September 26, 2010 @ 2:50 am

[...] Immigration and Agriculture: The Non-Colbert Debate « The … [...]


Archery
Trackback posted September 26, 2010 @ 7:50 am

Researching Archery…

I found your entry interesting thus I’ve added a Trackback to it on my weblog :)…


Immigration and Agriculture: The Non-Colbert Debate North Capitol Street
Pingback posted September 26, 2010 @ 6:03 pm

[...] View full post on The Washington Independent [...]


More Immigrants, a Better Economy North Capitol Street
Pingback posted September 26, 2010 @ 10:07 pm

[...] Immigration and Agriculture: The Non-Colbert Debate « The … [...]


Objection to DADT shouldn’t be an excuse to hold hostage critical defense legislation (Sen. … North Capitol Street
Pingback posted September 27, 2010 @ 1:13 am

[...] Immigration and Agriculture: The Non-Colbert Debate « The … [...]


StephenWV
Comment posted October 4, 2010 @ 7:27 pm

The problem with immigration reform is the same problem that occurred with healthcare reform. What comes out is not what is best for the American People. This is not about illegal immigrants, it is about enforcing laws. Guset worker and immigration laws. There is a small minority of guest and illegals working on farms. The majority are engineers, scientists, trade workers(carpenters etc.) and as the Utah document showed – GOVERNMENT WORKERS! Utah times 50 states. These people work for lower wages and benefits than Americans, who would LOVE to have their jobs. Businesses don't have to offer good wages OR offer private healthcare and the profits then go to the fat cats at the top rather than to the workers at the bottom. American jobs should be for Americans. 10 to 20 million guset workers and illegals … 10 million Legal Americans unemployeed … go figure.

This is the fault of the career politicians. But they say they have done nothing to cause this. I agree. They did nothing to enforce the laws and seal the borders. DELIBERATELY!


My Blog Title
Trackback posted October 9, 2010 @ 11:30 pm

Another Title…

If accidents happen, are you prepared? Are you sure you already protected? Worker insurance is a vital protection from theft, property harm and liability. It’s your protection against massive out-of-pocket expenses….


Why Push an Immigration Reform Bill That Won’t Pass? North Capitol Street
Pingback posted October 11, 2010 @ 7:49 pm

[...] little appetite for immigration reform, panning even smaller measures such as the DREAM Act and AgJOBS to help undocumented students and farm workers. The main question, then, is why push a bill that [...]


Exceteevade
Comment posted September 3, 2011 @ 6:28 pm

So I’ve been looking around the net and have come to the conclusion that it’s hard to find someone to do good

SEO Work! It just plain is! But I did stumble upon a gentlmen that really knows his stuff and got my site to a page

rank 3 in one month! He’s great! Check him out I think you will be suprised. Why am I sharing? Because This Forum

KICKS ASS!! Ha ha enough said! Try him out you won’t be dissapointed.

automatic backlink software


4537037
Comment posted September 7, 2011 @ 12:33 pm

4537037 beers on the wall. sck was here


RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.