Despite Recession, Catholic Groups Grant Charitable Funds to Anti-Gay Marriage Initiatives

Tuesday, September 21, 2010 at 4:45 am

A person protests in support of marriage rights for gay couples. (Flickr/Fibonnaci Blue)

When Wall Street collapsed in late 2008, donations to charitable groups and religious organizations quickly plummeted alongside it. The Roman Catholic Diocese of Portland, Maine, reported that the “turmoil in world financial markets and the resulting worldwide recession” had “significantly impacted” its books. In its fiscal year 2009 annual report, the church wrote, “To the extent these revenue shortfalls persist, we will have to reduce programs when some of them are needed most.”

[Congress1] Last year the diocese, true to its word, laid off employees at the Trinity Catholic School and made plans to close two parishes in Lewiston. But it also made the first of several generous — and controversial — new contributions.

In June, the archdiocese made a $100,000 donation to the Amendment 1 campaign to ban gay marriage. By the time the ballot fight was over, it had donated more than $568,000 to the cause. (In November, Maine voters overturned a state law giving gay couples the right to wed.) Now, Catholics across the country are criticizing the Portland diocese for having solicited monetary contributions for the Maine ballot fight, punished organizations that opposed its stance on gay marriage, and for having politicized churchgoers’ charitable giving.

Church Donations Deprive Good Work in Favor of Political Causes

In fiscal year 2009, the Catholic Church of Portland reported millions of dollars in revenue, but still more in costs. Its losses on investments, its costs “attributable to sexual misconduct,” and its sundry upkeep costs combined to represent a loss of over $20 million. When the extent of its political spending became apparent, it didn’t take long for outrage to follow.

“Parishes are being closed, parochial schools are being closed. It’s not just [on account of] staffing issues, like they say, but also financial issues,” says Anne Underwood, Maine resident and founder of Catholics for Marriage Equality. “And I think Catholics were very aware that this is not a wealthy diocese and yet the diocese spent a lot of money on this cause.”

Marc Mutty, an employee of the Portland Diocese who took time off to run the Church’s Ballot Question Committee — which accepted donations from the Church and funneled most of them to — demurred when local papers questioned the Church’s activities at the time. “We believe it is a fundamental issue that speaks to the good of society and the best interests of society and once it is lost, it is lost forever,” he argued. (The Portland Diocese did not return phone call requests yesterday for additional comment.)

That said, not all Catholics agreed with the decision, and many have taken issue with fact that their donations to the Catholic Church might have found their way into campaigns affecting questions at the ballot box. George Burns, a lawyer and a Catholic who opposed Amendment 1, went so far as to set up his own charity for dissatisfied Catholics. “My hope is that ultimately it will be a charity for people like me who were not comfortable with the church’s administration of donated funds,” he explains.

Burns doesn’t question the fact that the Catholic Church has discretion over the use of its funds, but he’s dissatisfied with the level of opacity with which it operated — soliciting and accepting donations from bishops at other dioceses around the country, often unbeknownst to their followers — in funding the gay marriage ban in Maine.

“I thought the use of Catholic charity money from other dioceses sent to Maine to oppose marriage equality was a distortion of the intent of some donors,” he argues. “Do you think someone in New Mexico thought their donation was going to this effort in Maine, as opposed to aiding the sick and feeding the hungry?”

Indeed, in its efforts to raise funds to defeat Maine’s gay marriage law, Portland’s Bishop Richard Malone sent an appeal to other Catholic bishops around the country asking for support. The Philadelphia archdiocese and the Phoenix diocese, Maine campaign finance records revealed, each gave $50,000 to the cause. Dioceses in Newark, St. Louis, and Youngstown, Ohio, contributed $10,000 apiece.

Church spokesmen in Maine and elsewhere deny that the contributions to anti-same sex marriage campaigns came at the expense of other charitable donations, claiming they were drawn instead from special discretionary funds and private donors.

“The money is dedicated revenues that were provided by a donor for causes such as these and money from the collection basket or any of those types of things would never be used,” Marc Mutty explains. Likewise, the diocese in St. Louis released a statement that said their gift came from a fund that “has traditionally been the archbishop’s for discretionary spending, not for formal operations, and is funded by private gifts.”

But such a system — in which a bishop solicits funds from private donors for a specific political cause and then acts as an intermediary in funding it — is raising an equally troubling set of concerns among Catholic groups opposed to the church’s involvement in anti-marriage campaigns.

“Another problem is that if $50,000 is coming from the Catholic Diocese of Phoenix, Arizona, what the bishop could do there is to bring in his high-level donors and ask for a check for the diocese and then bundle the money and launder it as a donation from the church to a campaign,” notes Rev. Dr. Joseph Palacios, board member of Catholics for Equality. “In effect, you’ve got a tax-deductible charitable donation to the church, so it looks good, which is then being turned around and used for political purposes.”

Crackdown on Charitable Organizations that Support Marriage Equality

The Catholic Church’s advocacy against gay marriage does not stop at contributions to campaigns on state ballot measures. It also includes which charitable programs it chooses to support and which to defund. In the wake of Maine’s decision to ban gay marriage, the church has played an active role in revoking funds from worthy charitable organizations because they diverged from church doctrine by joining a coalition to protect marriage equality in the state.

The most notable example involves a program called Homeless Voices for Justice (HVJ), which was asked this spring to return its grant funding to both the local Portland Diocese and the Catholic Campaign for Human Development (CCHD), a national organization that funds antipoverty efforts. HVJ’s parent group, the Preble Street Resource Center, had joined a coalition that opposed Amendment 1.

“This funding, which we have received for 13 years, was used in its entirety to support the work of Homeless Voices for Justice, a grassroots group that works for social change on behalf of people who struggle with homelessness and poverty,” the group wrote in an appeal to Bishop Malone. “The mission and the efforts of Homeless Voices for Justice align so well with those of CCHD that it is terribly disappointing that you have come to this decision to withdraw support for their valiant work.”

Preble Street claimed that, separate from HVJ, it had decided to join the coalition because it had noticed that issues surrounding sexual orientation were the single greatest cause of homelessness among youth in Maine, but the Diocese and the CCHD remained unmoved. Sue Bernard, spokeswoman for the diocese, said the church requires agencies that receive funding to adhere to the teachings of the Catholic Church, and that it had violated the terms of its grant by joining the coalition.

CCHD, for its part, admitted the decision was a hard one, but it claimed that Preble Street’s decision left them no choice but to defund the program. “We liked Homeless Voices a great deal. I felt badly for having to cancel the grant,” said Randy Keesler, a grants specialist for the group. “This was very difficult for us to do.”

CCHD’s crackdown on Preble Street, however, represents not simply an isolated incident but a slow and steady evolution in the national antipoverty group’s philosophy and practices in response to increasing pressure from the Catholic Church hierarchy.

“Campaign for Human Development has been an important incubator for a number of social projects around the country,” notes Palacios, “but there’s been a lot of pressure on them to do a litmus test on social values for the awarding of funds. The first was abortion rights or access to contraception, but now they’ve stepped this up for same sex marriage as well.”

Requirements that charitable groups stay silent on the issue of same-sex marriage are a relatively recent phenomenon. “When the bishops got on board with the constitutional amendment concerning marriage, that’s especially when this whole thing kicked off,” Palacios says. “Then it became a national policy for bishops to go in this direction.”

Indeed, the Catholic Bishops of the United States established CCHD in 1970, giving it the mandate to fund “such projects as voter registration, community organizations, community?run schools, minority?owned cooperatives and credit unions, capital for industrial development and job training programs, and setting up of rural cooperatives.” But it has faced overwhelming pressure since the 1990s to add a growing number of litmus tests for charitable groups hoping to receive funding. The grant application now notes that “organizations that support or promote, for example, capital punishment, abortion, euthanasia, racism, war, discrimination, or same-sex marriage are not eligible for CCHD funding.”

“This is a relatively new trend,” notes Dr. Patrick Edgar, president of the Association for the Rights of Catholics in the Church. “It used to be that CCHD and other charitable organizations were left alone as far as its administration and enforcement of those kind of doctrinal statements, but in recent years the Bishops Conference has gotten more aggressive as far as stifling anything that might indicate that not all Catholics agree on this topic.”

Indeed, in the months that led up to CCHD’s decision to revoke the funding for Preble Street’s Homeless Voices for Justice program, it had come under increasing attacks from conservative elements within the Church for its “permissive” attitude toward funding groups that preached a message of social justice. Last fall, CCHD Bishop Roger Morin was forced to defend his group’s record against threats from a coalition of conservative Catholic groups that pushed for a boycott of CCHD’s collection weekend in November, calling claims that it funded groups with missions contrary to church teachings “outrageous.”

In response to such pressure, Bishop Morin released a memorandum extolling the group’s crackdown on a number of organizations that took stands on propositions in California that were considered contrary to church doctrines.

“The Chinese Progressive Association and Young Workers United, both immigrant workers’ rights groups, had, without the knowledge of the local Archdiocese or CCHD, produced voter guides that took positions on referenda opposed to Catholic teaching on same-sex marriage and, in one case, parental notification and abortion,” the memo read. “As soon as these facts were confirmed, and after consultation with the local Archdiocese, the groups were also defunded.”

When CCHD came under similar pressure this spring from conservative Catholic groups, which once again lambasted its funding of Preble Street as a sign of heresy, the Diocese of Portland made its displeasure known and CCHD quickly revoked the funding for the homelessness program as well.

“The bishop in a state has total control over what happens in his state with Catholic money,” notes Underwood. “It’s really sad, because [Homeless Voices] met all the criteria that good and faithful Catholics want to see a program meet.”

Follow Jesse Zwick on Twitter



Tweets that mention Despite Recession, Catholic Groups Grant Charitable Funds to Anti-Gay Marriage Initiatives « The Washington Independent --
Pingback posted September 21, 2010 @ 5:06 am

[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by mommadona, mommadona, T. De Paoli, Tony Webber, WashIndependent and others. WashIndependent said: Despite Recession, Catholic Groups Grant Charitable Funds to Anti-Gay Marriage Initiatives [...]

Despite Recession, Catholic Groups Grant Charitable Funds to Anti-Gay Marriage … – The Washington Independent | Gay Marriage News Articles
Pingback posted September 21, 2010 @ 5:57 am

[...] Go here to see the original: Despite Recession, Catholic Groups Grant Charitable Funds to Anti-Gay Marriage … – The W… [...]

Despite Recession, Catholic Groups Grant Charitable Funds to Anti-Gay –
Pingback posted September 21, 2010 @ 6:03 am

[...] Despite Recession, Catholic Groups Grant Charitable Funds to Anti-Gay Sep 21st, 2010 by admin. Despite Recession, Catholic Groups Grant Charitable Funds to Anti-Gay Marriage … The Washington Independent The Roman Catholic Diocese of Portland, Maine, reported that the “turmoil in world financial markets and the resulting worldwide recession” had … [...]

Harvest Power Announces Superheroes Program to Celebrate and Accelerate Organics Recycling Initiatives | advanced-nutrients
Pingback posted September 21, 2010 @ 6:47 am

[...] Despite Recession, Catholic Groups Grant Charitable Funds to Anti … [...]

World Wide News Flash
Trackback posted September 21, 2010 @ 7:27 am

Despite Recession, Catholic Groups Grant Charitable Funds to Anti ……

I found your entry interesting do I’ve added a Trackback to it on my weblog :)…

Comment posted September 21, 2010 @ 11:58 am

the catloics burned witches and tortured people,,, why am I not surprised here?

Jimmy in LA
Comment posted September 21, 2010 @ 12:04 pm

I agree with those mentioned in the article who are upset that their donation money is going to fund these attacks against gay people when there are so many other things that SHOULD be a higher priority.

If anyone Catholic or otherwise wants to help someone – find a good charity such as the United Way to donate to, and step right on past any fundraiser the Knights of Columbus are involved in. The United Way (and so many OTHER decent, honest charities) will use that money to feed, clothe, house, and employ people – NOT to attack different types of families in the political arena.

Another suggestion, albeit one you might find distasteful: If any Catholic school, hospital, or other supported organization is having a fundraiser – tell them to ask the Knights of Columbus for assistance. Maybe they can take a little out of their attack budget to help put a roof on a church or buy some extra equipment for the kids at one of the Catholic schools.

Even in a church, you can “vote” with your donations. Donate to a worthy cause who will actually HELP people, not one that is known to use money you donate to ATTACK people and bring misery into their lives. Which do you think Jesus would donate to? Look for examples of His type of charitable works in the gospels.

Comment posted September 21, 2010 @ 12:06 pm

Wow, how very, very unfortunate.

While I officiate for couples who have been togther for 20, 30 and 45 years, these folks fund anti-marriage activities.

Onward to full civil and marriage equality rights in 21st century America, and abroad.

Cheers, Joe Mustich, Justice of the Peace,

Red Studio Farm, Washington, Connecticut, USA.

Just say no to these flat earth folks….

Doc Rock
Comment posted September 21, 2010 @ 1:35 pm

Those funds should be taxed!

Comment posted September 21, 2010 @ 4:27 pm

This one's an easy one……

Tax the diocese who fund ANY political activity.

Now if the obstructionists in the Senate could unpluck their heads, and vote to repeal DADT like they said they would…..

Comment posted September 21, 2010 @ 5:18 pm

'W' RCs:” I am the Rep for “the HAVES and HAVE MORES”!

No wonder 25,000,000 RCs have left since the late 1960s and proportionately more in the last two decades.

Profile typical 'me-only dinosaur' RC: over 55 yo, angry, self-centered, good pension and retirement(not 401k but defined benefit plan), self-righteous, hates JFK's speech, and may or may not have had adolescent same-sex experience in grade school.

Thinks because he and she worked hard, inherited their parent's WW2 VA financed house, they 'earned it all'.

These are defintely 'cafeteria' RCs who no longer accept RCsocial teaching and charitable works of mercy but Georgw W. Bush morality and politics.

Faith and politics(power) have never mixed for a noble end!

Tim Flagler
Comment posted September 21, 2010 @ 5:32 pm

Fascinating to see this money trail. I did not understand why anyone would oppose the marriage of loving couples. Today I checked out which looks at the pros and cons of gay marriage. Although I disagree with the anti-gay marriage folks, at least I understand their views better and no they are not all crazy.

Comment posted September 21, 2010 @ 8:32 pm

The Catholic Church has been morally bankrupt since its inception.

Comment posted September 21, 2010 @ 8:59 pm

Jimmy, the United Way does meaningful work BUT its leaders like the RC hierarchy live off donations as large as large Wall Street CEOs' bonuses.

Comment posted September 21, 2010 @ 10:21 pm

Monkey99- I agree wholeheartedly. If a church wants to be political, they should have to pay taxes. And on DADT too.

On another subject- I responded to your post on the other subject the other day and haven't heard back from you. Whats up?

Comment posted September 21, 2010 @ 11:17 pm

Go to CI.

I have a few posts there, hit me up at one….

How to pay for DENTAL HYGIENE SCHOOL with bad credit? | credit
Pingback posted September 22, 2010 @ 5:06 am

[...] Despite Recession, Catholic Groups Grant Charitable Funds to Anti … [...]

Despite Recession, Catholic Groups Grant Charitable Funds to Anti-Gay Marriage Initiatives North Capitol Street
Pingback posted September 22, 2010 @ 6:35 am

[...] View full post on The Washington Independent [...]

Comment posted September 22, 2010 @ 11:28 am

The churches are well within their rights to engage in policy matters and moral questions, including initiatives. They just can't endorse political candidates.

I assume you only want to pull the tax exemption for churches who support causes you disagree with, while churches who advocate for gay marriage with their funds and other resources could keep their tax exemption?

A sharper eye at courthouse | Popular bags
Pingback posted September 22, 2010 @ 12:56 pm

[...] Despite Recession, Catholic Groups Grant Charitable Funds to Anti-Gay Marriage Initiatives « T… [...]

Comment posted September 22, 2010 @ 1:48 pm


Comment posted September 22, 2010 @ 3:29 pm

That's why the First Amendment, and no, I'm not cherry-picking. I mean ALL political causes.

Comment posted September 22, 2010 @ 3:59 pm

Contact the Catholic Church. Looks like they have money.

Christine O’Donnell: Nancy Pelosi Is Not a True Christian North Capitol Street
Pingback posted September 23, 2010 @ 6:19 am

[...] Despite Recession, Catholic Groups Grant Charitable Funds to Anti … [...]

Cleveland Central Catholic High School dedicates new football field in Slavic Village North Capitol Street
Pingback posted September 23, 2010 @ 4:18 pm

[...] Despite Recession, Catholic Groups Grant Charitable Funds to Anti … [...]

Coach Weight Loss » Blog Archive » “Mom’s Secret Recipes” – 100s of Delicious Recipes! AAA+++
Pingback posted September 24, 2010 @ 12:14 am

[...] Despite Recession, Catholic Groups Grant Charitable Funds to Anti-Gay Marriage Initiatives « T… [...]

What You Need to Know about Debt in 2010 | | Credit Guide for USA citizens
Pingback posted September 26, 2010 @ 3:28 am

[...] Despite Recession, Catholic Groups Grant Charitable Funds to Anti-Gay Marriage Initiatives « T… [...]

Gerald Celente: Crash of 2010 inevitable | | Credit Guide for USA citizens
Pingback posted September 26, 2010 @ 6:59 am

[...] Despite Recession, Catholic Groups Grant Charitable Funds to Anti-Gay Marriage Initiatives « T… [...]

Is it about time Get tough on drunken-driver illegals hundreds of alcohol-related arrests of warrants posted? | affordable life insurance
Pingback posted September 28, 2010 @ 2:29 am

[...] Despite Recession, Catholic Groups Grant Charitable Funds to Anti-Gay Marriage Initiatives « T… [...]

low carb vegetarian diet
Trackback posted September 30, 2010 @ 7:38 am

Healthy diet plan…

I now long-established my email subscription! Appreciation!…

Conservation grants help more than 217 state projects
Pingback posted October 4, 2010 @ 7:27 am

[...] Despite Recession, Catholic Groups Grant Charitable Funds to Anti-Gay Marriage Initiatives « T… [...]

air max shoes
Comment posted October 8, 2010 @ 5:46 am

thank you for your sharing

My Blog Title
Trackback posted October 9, 2010 @ 11:05 pm


Injured worker…

Carl Paladino Says He’s Just Being Catholic When He Says Gays Are Disgusting |
Pingback posted October 11, 2010 @ 1:47 pm

[...] because funneling resources away from fighting poverty to stop gays from marrying, denying money to homeless shelters because they may be too LGBT-friendly, and calling LGBT people a threat to the fabric of humanity [...]

Comment posted March 30, 2011 @ 9:08 am

I agree to catholic groups, gay marriage should be stop because its not accepted by the catholic church.

Dina Williams,
State of California Donate a Car
Wheels for Wishes

Ain’t that rich: USCCB on labor unions » Life, post-epic.
Pingback posted September 5, 2011 @ 6:48 pm

[...] in their charge are having to close parishes due to dwindling funds and empty pews*, but they can impressively raise—and divert—funds to fight same-sex marriage literally in the same month. What does that say about their priorities? Additionally they have [...]

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.