Mitch Landrieu thumbnail

Who Gets to Rebuild New Orleans?

Tuesday, August 31, 2010 at 4:30 am

New Orleans Mayor Mitch Landrieu hopes to make contracting more fair, and to help local businesses. (Flickr, dsb nola)

This week, The Washington Independent is featuring a series of investigative stories on the rebuilding of New Orleans, five years after Hurricane Katrina. Find all of them here.

Two weeks before the fifth anniversary of Hurricane Katrina, New Orleans’ mayor, Mitch Landrieu (D), just three months into his tenure, made a major announcement. A hundred recovery projects, from libraries to fire stations to parks, were ready to go after years of red tape and implementation scandals.

[Environment1] “I can say this with certainty: that these 100 projects are a priority in somebody’s mind in the city, that they are 100 percent funded, that they are part of the city’s long-term master plan and will be built, or are in the process of being built,” Landrieu told The Times-Picayune. “Some of them are further along than others. But you can take these to the bank.”

In a city that has long suffered from halting and ineffective efforts to contract municipal recovery funds, the news came as a welcome relief. It stoked hopes that Landrieu’s administration would offer a clean break from Mayor Ray Nagin’s (D) fraught eight-year tenure. “I think this city is ready to soar,” declared City Council President Arnie Fielkow.

But as the mayor gets ready to cut ribbons and break ground, a number of local labor and anti-discrimination groups are voicing worries that the new projects will not benefit the city’s local businesses. Their concerns center around the city’s Disadvantaged Business Enterprise (DBE) program, intended to make good-faith efforts to help local, women, and minority-owned firms secure city contracts. Wary due to rampant cronyism and corruption in the past, leaving local companies adrift, the NAACP and other groups are seizing on Landrieu’s announcement. For them, turning around the DBE will be the litmus test for success.

Even before Hurricane Katrina wreaked havoc on New Orleans, activists and businesses charged that the city had an opaque and cronyism-ridden system for awarding building and contracting deals — a major hurdle for local firms. The Bureau of Governmental Research, a private, independent research organization released a major report entitled “Contracting with Confidence” to call attention to the matter and make recommendations in March.

“An $81 million energy efficiency contract saddled the city with two decades of excessive payments and resulted in the convictions of an administration official, political supporters, and contractors who skimmed money from the deal,” the report said in its lengthy summary of recent examples of political patronage. “A contract for home monitoring of municipal offenders went to a politically connected firm that possessed no experience providing the service and that scored lowest on the city’s evaluation of proposals. The public paid 60 percent more to install and manage electronic parking meters than it would have had the city contracted with the firm that scored highest in the city’s own evaluation. A post-Katrina car removal contract went to the most expensive of 14 bidders through an evaluation process that did not account for the cost of services. The list goes on.”

Former Mayor Ray Nagin was implicated in the political patronage system as well after revelations that his family vacationed in Hawaii and Jamaica due to the largess of Mark St. Pierre, who held numerous city technology contracts. Later, St. Pierre was indicted, along with Greg Meffert, Nagin’s chief techonology officer, on 63 federal counts of bribery, money laundering, tax evasion and other crimes.

In the wake of the hurricane, when federal recovery money began pouring in and outside firms often secured work for complicated projects, rather than local businesses, the city’s opaque methods and history of corruption ginned up anger and outrage from an underemployed citizenry. Particularly troubling in the eyes of local business owners, particularly black business owners, was the persistent sense that the city was allowing the money to be funneled to out-of-state contractors who made little effort to hire local businesses.

“We’re dealing with local contractors on a daily basis and they’re not getting the work,” argues Barry Kaufman, secretary treasurer of the Construction and General Laborers Union Local 689. “There are more out-of-state contractors in here than holes in cheese. Local contractors are being low bidded by out-of-state contractors. It’s a shame how [Nagin] let that happen.”

When, in February 2009, the New Orleans City Council passed an ordinance that required Nagin’s closed-door review panels to meet in public, the mayor vetoed the bill and later issued an order that scrapped the evaluation panels altogether. That process, or the lack thereof, remained in place until Landrieu assumed office in May and made contracts reform a signature priority of his administration.

In addition to restoring transparency and expertise to city contracting, Landrieu’s administration also tried reaching out to disillusioned local groups. The mayor set up a “provisional certification program,” which allowed businesses certified as “disadvantaged” by state and other agencies to compete for city contracts alongside City Hall’s previous designees. He also created an Office of Supplier Diversity, tasked with enforcing city ordinances and implementing programs like DBE.

These new programs and agencies, however, have yet to perform up to expectations. A report on DBE released by the city’s Office of the Inspector General in early August made a number of damning observations about its effectiveness, including, “(1) that the personnel responsible for implementing this program did not have a clear understanding of the applicable legal standards; (2) that the certification procedure implemented did not have written rules or comply with open meeting laws; and, (3) that the responsible office lacks sufficient staff and funding to carry out its intended functions.”

The Inspector General’s observations, the report noted, reflected more on the failings of the DBE program over the years than any of Landrieu’s specific efforts, but they also highlighted that, thus far, progress has been substandard. Groups like the NAACP seized upon the report, voicing fears that the administration is faltering on its promise to help New Orleans-based and minority-owned businesses secure contracts on new recovery projects.

“We have requested documentation from the city on previous contracts, but our focus right now is not what has happened in the past but on the one hundred projects just announced by Landrieu,” explains local NAACP chapter president Danatus King. “That’s a billion dollars worth of projects that the mayor publicized in the media last week. No matter what happened in the past, we want to make sure the law is enforced with respect to that.”

In order to keep tabs on all the contracts, King and other leaders have demanded that the city gather records for all its contracts — and all the required documentation contractors are required to submit for them — in publicly accessible folders that volunteers can access and use to monitor for compliance. “If the city doesn’t have the manpower to do it,” King explains, “we’re asking for citizens to get involved.”

Neither the city nor activists possess data on whether New Orleans is complying with an ordinance requiring that half of public spending go to locally owned companies and 35 percent to “socially and economically disadvantaged businesses.” It is not even clear which businesses qualify as “socially and economically disadvantaged.” While the ordinances originally included race- and gender-based criteria, the Supreme Court has since declared such rules to be unconstitutional. As a result, the city has tinkered with its certification process over the years but has yet to come up with firm criteria.

And while the DBE participation goals are “aspirational” in nature, the paperwork required to demonstrate a good faith effort in achieving them is not. Despite this fact, the Inspector General’s office noted that the current panel that approves companies for the city’s DBE program holds monthly meetings that are not advertised and are not open to the public — nor is there an adequate avenue of appeal if a business’s application is rejected. Moreover, the city’s Office of Supplier Diversity currently has only one employee, who has no time sufficiently monitor or enforce compliance on the part of contractors with the DBE program’s participation goals.

The mayor’s office announced earlier this year that it would undertake a “disparity study” to begin putting numbers on the debate. (The office declined to speak to TWI about the issue.) In the meantime, businesses, unions and activists remain unconvinced.  “I can tell you at the Langston Hughes school right over by the race track,” notes Kaufman, of the Construction and General Laborers Union Local 689. “This contractor from Biloxi, Miss., built that school. You’re telling me, with all the local contractors in New Orleans, we can’t build a school?”

“I think there’s one person in the office [of Supplier Diversity], but that’s no excuse,” he notes. “I think they’ve been doing this for years and years, and I think it’s business as usual. I hope it changes. We’re going to give Landrieu an opportunity to prove us wrong.”

Follow Jesse Zwick on Twitter



Who Gets to Rebuild New Orleans? North Capitol Street
Pingback posted August 31, 2010 @ 5:11 am

[...] View full post on The Washington Independent [...]

Who Gets to Rebuild New Orleans? – The Washington Independent | Blogs
Pingback posted August 31, 2010 @ 6:08 am

[...] post: Who Gets to Rebuild New Orleans? – The Washington Independent Share and [...]

Who Gets to Rebuild New Orleans? « The Washington Independent | Independent
Pingback posted August 31, 2010 @ 7:12 am

[...] here: Who Gets to Rebuild New Orleans? « The Washington Independent Tags: a-major-report, and-make, bureau, call-attention, confidence, governmental, independent, [...]

Iraq ‘independent’ as US combat operations end – BBC News - Most hotest, Most latest U.S. News Online - Online News 28 – Top Stories in U.S.
Pingback posted August 31, 2010 @ 8:11 am

[...] Who Gets to Rebuild New Orleans? « The Washington Independent [...]

Steelers Star Troy Polamalu Gets Hair Insured For $1 Million – TIME | Latest News On Web
Pingback posted August 31, 2010 @ 8:12 am

[...] 207 news articles »Possibly related posts: (automatically generated)Related posts on GetsWho Gets to Rebuild New Orleans? « The Washington IndependentRoyal Navy's New Submarine Gets Royal Approval | Navy News at …Google gets into the badges [...]

  Who Gets to Rebuild New Orleans? – The Washington Independent by Colocation Data Center Hosting Costs
Pingback posted August 31, 2010 @ 12:04 pm

[...] Who Gets to Rebuild New Orleans?The Washington IndependentTheir concerns center around the city's Disadvantaged Business Enterprise (DBE) program, intended to make good-faith efforts to help city firms secure city …and more » [...]

Comment posted August 31, 2010 @ 12:35 pm

Why do race, ethnicity, and sex need to be considered at all in deciding who gets awarded a contract? It's fine to make sure contracting programs are open to all, that bidding opportunities are widely publicized beforehand, and that no one gets discriminated against because of skin color, national origin, or sex. But that means no preferences because of skin color, etc. either–whether it's labeled a “set-aside,” a “quota,” or a “goal,” since they all end up amounting to the same thing. Such discrimination is unfair and divisive; it costs the taxpayers money to award a contract to someone other than the lowest bidder; and it's almost always illegal—indeed, unconstitutional—to boot (see 42 U.S.C. section 1981 and this model brief:… ). Those who insist on engaging in such discrimination deserve to be sued, and they will lose.

A Concerned New Orleanian
Comment posted August 31, 2010 @ 3:15 pm

Perhpas you should look at the focus of the article again – “LOCAL Business” not race, ethnicity or sex…I read the focus of the article was to affirm a process where LOCAL CONTACTORS get work, maybe your head is focused somewhere else but the article is NOT!

Comment posted August 31, 2010 @ 3:56 pm

@ A Concerned New Orleanian

It's both: “Their concerns center around the city’s Disadvantaged Business Enterprise (DBE) program, intended to make good-faith efforts to help local, women, and minority-owned firms secure city contracts”; and “Groups like the NAACP seized upon the report, voicing fears that the administration is faltering on its promise to help New Orleans-based and minority-owned businesses secure contracts on new recovery projects.”

Comment posted August 31, 2010 @ 6:47 pm


The article clearly states that local contractors are not getting any contracts. Many city governments try to give local businesses some preferences, since the money will linger longer in the local economy. Giving genuine preferences to local contractors will mean giving more chances to minorities. The NAACP stepped in because this rigged and corrupt process excludes minorities. If we lived in a fair world where the white and connected didn't get a preference, I might agree with your assessment, but we clearly don't. I'm tired of people talking about theoretical fairness. Many of these local contractors are minorities and they need opportunities as well.

Comment posted August 31, 2010 @ 6:58 pm

Many of the crooked contractors ARE locals who got no-bid contracts from Nagin OR who got Community Block Grants from HUD w/no oversight..just free taxpayer money.

Sound familiar, then go north 400 miles up the Mississippi River to corrupt Memphis where the former mayor for 16 years gave out $7,000,000 IT no-bid contracts to slug with no education or IT experience to Reginald French, etc, Then, go north 225 mi up the MR to St. Louis.

Minority corruption is pandemic from Oakland, LA, Detroit, Newark, Atlanta as long as there is government money to be picked like low hanging fruit.

The poor people never see it, only there 'elected' officials and family members.

Comment posted August 31, 2010 @ 8:05 pm

Contractors in my home town of Tulsa, Okla. were paying kickbacks to county officials to get work and all of them were white. You say “minority corruption is pandemic.” But what percentage of government contracts go to minorities? Very few, which makes for a pretty SMALL pandemic. Including a greater range of participants would make for a fairer process and increase opportunity.

Comment posted August 31, 2010 @ 8:11 pm

@Vjeffrey827: I don't see why p.c. racial preferences are the solution to corruption OR un-p.c. racial preferences, as a theoretical OR practical matter. There's plenty that can be done to make sure contracting programs are open to all, that bidding opportunities are widely publicized beforehand, and that no one — black or white, male or female, Asian or Latino — gets discriminated against because of skin color, national origin, or sex. The solution is transparency, not more discrimination.

Comment posted August 31, 2010 @ 9:14 pm

To my mind, the corruption goes hand in hand with the exclusion of minorities and women. The traditional network of politicians and businessmen shuts out all competition, especially minorities. This is why the open system you seek never materializes.

In Newark, for example, Sharp James was the very long time Black mayor. Although he had some Black cronies, most of his backers and benefactors were white real estate developers. Nagin in NO had similar establishment backing. That is why he continued his closed-door review panels, as stated in the article. The time to question the fairness of the process is not just when someone tries to make an effort to include minorities. It would be nice if there was a color blind way to break up this corruption, but I haven't seen it happen, even in liberal New York City. Too many people depend on this exclusion to make money.

discount Louis vuitton
Comment posted September 3, 2010 @ 5:53 am

black or white, male or female, Asian or Latino — gets discriminated against because of skin color, national origin, or sex. The solution is transparency, not more discrimination.

Fast Online news
Trackback posted September 3, 2010 @ 11:03 am

Fire out on Gulf of Mexico rig, no oil slick: Coast Guard…

I found your entry interesting do I’ve added a Trackback to it on my weblog :)…

Joanne Hilton
Comment posted September 3, 2010 @ 5:49 pm

Thank you so much for continuing to write about our city. My husband and I own a small B&B Inn in the Lower Garden District (St. Charles Guest House) which we have operated for over 30 years. Five years ago, after the “thing,” we were very afraid that we would never be able to keep our business because the tourist business dried up for us, but then, you know what happened? VOLUNTEER GROUPS happened. They became our new “tourists.” Many of them were from your city. They worked like dogs, clearing rubble, framing, painting, just whatever needed to be done on the jobsites they attended. We gave them dirt-cheap rates, treated them like family with barbeques, round-table discussions about the city, hot biscuits in the morning, cookies at night, just anything that made them feel at home, and let thnem know how much we appreciated them, not only for the business they gave us, but for the wonderful selfless back-breaking work they did for our people. And they helped us stay in business.

While there is still work to be done, New Orleans is, and has been, ready for it's regular tourists to “come on down.” Whether you come as volunteers, or just regular guests, you'll find our music, food, architecture, local characters, cultural attractions, museums, and natural resources sparkling and unparalled, and our prices to access these treasures, many of which are FREE, are some of the lowest in the country. We'll show you what real southern hospitality is all about.

Joanne Hilton

Trackback posted September 5, 2010 @ 4:11 pm

Official: Honduran helped massacre survivor flee…

Insightful. Inspirational. Beautifully Designed :) . The experiences and skills gained through your website be carried throughout my professional career. If only everyone had the same level of perseverance – the world would be an enjoyable place to liv…

Comment posted September 14, 2010 @ 12:30 pm

I like this site very much

===== ====

jordan air max oakland raiders $34–39;

Ed Hardy AF JUICY POLO Bikini $25;

Christan Audigier BIKINI JACKET $25;

gstar coogi evisu true jeans $35;

coach chanel gucci LV handbags $36;

coogi DG edhardy gucci t-shirts $18;

CA edhardy vests.paul smith shoes $32;

jordan dunk af1 max gucci shoes $37;

EDhardy gucci ny New Era cap $16;

coach okely Adidas CHANEL DG Sunglass $18;

===== ====

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.