Obama Unlikely to Use McChrystal Flap to Change Course on Afghanistan

By
Wednesday, June 23, 2010 at 6:00 am

Gen. Stanley McChrystal (Louie Palu/ZUMApress.com)

By the time you read this, Gen. Stanley McChrystal may very well have lost his command in Afghanistan. McChrystal is headed to a White House Situation Room meeting with President Obama on Wednesday; Time’s Joe Klein reported Tuesday afternoon that the general offered to resign after making disrespectful comments about senior Obama administration officials to Rolling Stone’s Michael Hastings. Whether Obama takes him up on his offer is a different story.

[Security1] And in some ways, it’s a less important decision than another one Obama must make: whether to take the opportunity to change the course of the administration’s strategy in Afghanistan. But if Obama has a chance to use the McChrystal controversy to overhaul his strategy, all signs indicate that he’s not interested.

The past two months in Afghanistan have been brutal. Since returning from a Washington summit with Obama, President Hamid Karzai acrimoniously parted ways with two of his top security officials, men trusted by the U.S. who believe Karzai’s attempts at outreach to the Taliban to bring the war to a close represent capitulation. A United Nations report released this weekend documented a rise in violence in southern Afghanistan ahead of a crucial attempt at pushing the Taliban out of Kandahar, the south’s most populous city. McChrystal had to slow down his push to provide what he calls a “rising tide” of security for Kandahar in order to secure buy-in from residents, as Karzai pledged his support for the operation at a mostly supportive local shura only last Sunday.

What remains unclear from any Kandahar planning is the effect even a successful operation will have on the overall strength of al-Qaeda’s allies in Afghanistan — and al-Qaeda itself, across the border in Pakistan. “There was good reason to drive al-Qaeda out of Afghanistan, but there’s no good reason to stay in the place,” said Douglas Macgregor, a retired Army colonel and a skeptic of counterinsurgency. “I don’t see any evidence [Obama's] suddenly going to summon the wherewithal to change course, but frankly this is an opportunity for him to do precisely that.”

If Robert Gibbs’ press briefing Tuesday was any indication, Macgregor has a point about Obama’s wherewithal. Gibbs, the White House press secretary, couched his and the president’s disapproval of McChrystal’s comments by questioning whether McChrystal was committed to implementing Obama’s strategy. “We’re here to implement a new strategy,” Gibbs said in his Tuesday briefing, and “that’s what we want everybody from the ambassador to the combatant commander to anybody else involved with this to focus on.” Gibbs emphasized that the mission in Afghanistan “is bigger than anybody on the military or the civilian side” — signaling that no officer is irreplaceable — and that it’s incumbent on the administration’s national security team “not to re-litigate” the internal autumn debate over Afghanistan strategy.

It was a surprising remark from Gibbs. McChrystal’s comments to Rolling Stone didn’t express any dissatisfaction with either the strategy or the resources he’s received to implement it. That’s probably because Obama ultimately embraced most of McChrystal’s favored approach: a rededication to counterinsurgency in Afghanistan, backed by an increased complement of 30,000 new troops until July 2011, after which Afghan police and soldiers are to gradually assume primary security responsibilities. In the article, McChrystal merely sniped at his civilian superior, Vice President Joe Biden, who favored a more modest course in Afghanistan, and disrespected two of the senior State Department officials who are key to counterinsurgency in Afghanistan this year, Amb. Karl Eikenberry and Richard Holbrooke, the administration’s special representative for Afghanistan and Pakistan.

But while McChrystal may not have meant to damage the strategy he helped create, the dismissive attitude toward the Obama team that he and his senior aides displayed to Rolling Stone put the president in a corner. “To take McChrystal out now and keep the deadline in place means that everything goes somewhat rudderless while time advances,” said a former senior U.S. diplomat who would not talk for the record because of the sensitivity of Obama’s impending decision. “That would be very deleterious to the policy. But to keep him in place would be harmful to the president’s authority. He has to decide what hit he wants to take.”

An additional factor: The short list for replacing McChrystal is heavy on counterinsurgents, further underscoring Gibbs’ emphasis on fidelity to the current strategy. Army Lt. Gen. David Rodriguez is McChrystal’s deputy, head of the International Security Assistance Force’s Joint Command, responsible for overseeing day-to-day military operations. Marine Gen. James Mattis, the head of U.S. Joint Forces Command, is perhaps the Marines’ leading counterinsurgency advocate. (A spokeswoman for Mattis told The Washington Independent on Tuesday, “General Mattis serves at the pleasure of the President, and is completely focused on his assignment as Commander, U.S. Joint Forces Command.”) Marine Lt. Gen. John O. Allen is the deputy commander of U.S. Central Command, where he serves under the military’s foremost counterinsurgency theorist-practitioner, Gen. David Petraeus. A choice that would indicate Obama intends to shift course would be Navy Adm. Eric Olson, the head of U.S. Special Operations Command, who recently criticized counterinsurgency for an insufficient focus on “countering the insurgents” — that is, battling them instead of securing populations from them — but Olson said at a recent conference that many of his criticisms are issues of degree, rather than wholesale rejection.

If Obama ends up making no changes to his strategy ahead of a scheduled December review and opts to keep his chastened commander, McChrystal will have to repair his relationship with his civilian partners if he’s to have any hope of achieving the unity of effort that counterinsurgency theory considers imperative. “I don’t know if I’d say it’s untenable, but he’s obviously in a difficult position,” said Mark Moyar, the author of a recent book on command in counterinsurgency who will arrive in Afghanistan next month to advise the U.S. military. “Most of [the offensive comments] came from his staff. Perhaps if he changed some members of his staff, it’d be possible to salvage” McChrystal’s command.

Sean McFate, a fellow with the New America Foundation and foreign policy adviser to the Obama campaign who used to work for McChrystal as a young officer with the Army’s 82nd Airborne Division, said the administration’s approach in Afghanistan had yet to resolve a fundamental “disunity” that stretches beyond the personalities at the top of particular civilian and military billets. “The national security establishment has to decide if this is ultimately a civilian mission or a military mission,” McFate said, echoing a discarded proposal last year to appoint an official to oversee the implementation of both civilian and military aspects of the strategy. The Rolling Stone article “points to a fallacy of the ‘whole-of-government’ approach. It’s not clear if it’s civilian or military, and it’s certainly not both.” McFate made it clear that he has not spoken to McChrystal in years.

Officials and analysts cautioned that not all of the 30,000 surge troops have yet arrived in Afghanistan, making firm judgment on the strategy’s prospects ahead of December premature. Administration officials pledged last year that as they implement their strategy, they will take “a hard look at the strategy itself” in a review scheduled for December, as Defense Secretary Robert Gates told Congress. But last week, Petraeus and Undersecretary of Defense Michele Flournoy played down the importance of the review, characterizing it as a more aggressive version of the monthly administration-wide examinations of progress — which McChrystal will attend on Wednesday.

In his only public comments on Tuesday ahead of meeting with McChrystal, Obama said his decision would be “determined entirely on how I can make sure that we have a strategy that justifies the enormous courage and sacrifice that those men and women are making over there, and that ultimately makes this country safer.”

But that only begs the question of whether that’s Obama’s current strategy or some alternative. In Kabul and Islamabad, the former diplomat said, the U.S.’s chosen Afghan and Pakistani partners are looking for guidance as to the meaning of Obama’s July 2011 timeline, regardless of how often administration officials have publicly stated they want “long-term partnerships” with both Afghanistan and Pakistan. “Is it a conditions-based start of a slow process [of withdrawal], as Petraeus and Flournoy said, or is it more [in line with] quotes from Biden and impressions given by the president stressing the deadline” as the beginning of the end of the U.S. military presence in the country, the diplomat asked. “That’s a strategic question, one that only Obama can ultimately provide guidance on.”

Follow Spencer Ackerman on Twitter


Comments

61 Comments

World Wide News Flash
Trackback posted June 23, 2010 @ 6:08 am

Obama Unlikely to Use McChrystal Flap to Change Course on Afghanistan…

I found your entry interesting do I’ve added a Trackback to it on my weblog :)…


North Capitol Street » Blog Archive » Obama Unlikely to Use McChrystal Flap to Change Course on Afghanistan
Pingback posted June 23, 2010 @ 6:36 am

[...] full post on The Washington Independent Don't miss a single post! Subscribe to my RSS [...]


Unique Articles | wedding-secrets.info
Pingback posted June 23, 2010 @ 7:09 am

[...] Obama Unlikely to Use McChrystal Flap to Change Course on Afghanistan « The Washington Indepen… [...]


Tweets that mention Obama Unlikely to Use McChrystal Flap to Change Course on Afghanistan « The Washington Independent -- Topsy.com
Pingback posted June 23, 2010 @ 7:48 am

[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by attackerman, WashIndependent. WashIndependent said: Obama Unlikely to Use McChrystal Flap to Change Course on Afghanistan – http://bit.ly/d4i1xF [...]


Make Life Easier With A Dog Door
Pingback posted June 23, 2010 @ 1:12 pm

[...] Obama Unlikely to Use McChrystal Flap to Change Course on Afghanistan « The Washington Indepen… [...]


All Around the World News
Trackback posted June 23, 2010 @ 1:20 pm

Obama Unlikely to Use McChrystal Flap to Change Course on ……

I found your entry interesting do I’ve added a Trackback to it on my weblog :)…


My friend has an online dating profile, he told the truth? | MATCH DATING ONLINE ON HERE
Pingback posted June 23, 2010 @ 5:55 pm

[...] Obama Unlikely to Use McChrystal Flap to Change Course on … [...]


zEEKo
Comment posted June 23, 2010 @ 7:22 pm

a good leader gives good guidance. the fact that we have a relatively very inexperienced White House staff crafting/approving the orders is both the cause of confusion at high offices (in both the DOD's and DOS's missions in Afghanistan) and a reflection of poor judgment in choosing one's closest advisers. by both of those counts, the COC has displayed a poor capability of guiding his subordinates. thus…i'm starting to have some serious doubts of our chosen leader. and this is not the first time we've heard of him lacking presence, guidance, leadership, so forth, and so on. by the way, other leaders around the world are starting to view our COC as merely a great photo opportunity – not much more than that. this is very, very disappointing. does he deserve this flak? hmmmm…..


Methods to Choose the Finest Umbrella | Atlanta Carpet Cleaning
Pingback posted June 23, 2010 @ 8:28 pm

[...] Obama Unlikely to Use McChrystal Flap to Change Course on … [...]


How do you build a brick shed/kennel for my 2 dogs? | Outdoor Sheds
Pingback posted June 23, 2010 @ 11:43 pm

[...] Obama Unlikely to Use McChrystal Flap to Change Course on … [...]


Couple?s Sex Toys and Enhancers Round-up
Pingback posted June 24, 2010 @ 12:49 am

[...] Obama Unlikely to Use McChrystal Flap to Change Course on … [...]


FB Siphon
Comment posted June 24, 2010 @ 2:49 pm

A general view can not be wrong. I think White House and Obama should really look into the Afghanistan situation because it is getting out of control day by day.


SEO Profession need web design knowledge? | SEM??
Pingback posted June 24, 2010 @ 11:48 pm

[...] Obama Unlikely to Use McChrystal Flap to Change Course on Afghanistan « The Washington Indepen… [...]


If I change internet service providers does my IP address change? | Custom oil painting
Pingback posted June 26, 2010 @ 11:02 pm

[...] Obama Unlikely to Use McChrystal Flap to Change Course on Afghanistan « The Washington Indepen… [...]


What is the average price for a piece in a student art gallery? | Custom oil painting
Pingback posted June 27, 2010 @ 2:05 am

[...] Obama Unlikely to Use McChrystal Flap to Change Course on Afghanistan « The Washington Indepen… [...]


How much do music lessons / art lessons cost in Sydney? | Custom oil painting
Pingback posted June 27, 2010 @ 3:33 am

[...] Obama Unlikely to Use McChrystal Flap to Change Course on Afghanistan « The Washington Indepen… [...]


Hawaiianstyle
Comment posted June 29, 2010 @ 7:16 pm

Obama should have his staff research the conditions, actions by Presidents and their staffs, the military comments of the time and the jpolitical positioning and comments made during the last 5 years of Viet Nam.

He would see that he is in the same process as Presidents of the past were. Unfortunately it seems Presidents, the military and the US public have a short membry and an even bigger ability to distort the present to try to make it the way they wish it would be.

We need a new word to describe pulling out of a war. The word defeat is an obstacle to rational thought for US Presidents, and the word victory is an insult to the intelligeince.

Perhaps “Achievable Victory” or “Mission Accomplished” or “Troop realighnment” or “Strategic Policy Change” or …..?


Tiffany Jewelry
Comment posted July 3, 2010 @ 6:12 pm

good


Wholesale Handbags
Comment posted July 5, 2010 @ 9:56 am

so cool!!!!!!!!!


Wholesalers
Comment posted July 6, 2010 @ 7:49 am

Very good article, thank you for sharing


Lachou
Comment posted July 7, 2010 @ 12:50 am

Buy Cheap Football Jerseys from Sport Jersey's Store, Basketball Jerseys, NFL Jerseys,NHL Jerseys, NBA Jerseys,MLB Jerseys,Hockey Jerseys,Cheap NFL Jerseys,Wholesale NFL Jerseys
Cowboys cheap jerseys Steelers cheap jerseys Saints cheap jerseys Vikings cheap jerseys Raiders cheap jerseysYou may need Summer Equipment,Have a good summer holiday:Many kind of Brand Sunglsss ,Puma Shoes,Converse Shoes,Nike Shox Shoes .

Women's Air Max LTD on sale,Men's Air Max LTD Shoes was introduced in 2002,Nike Air Max 95 and Nike Basketball shoes are hot now,Nike Air Max 2009 retail for men and women,Nike running shoes and mbt shoes are the latest stock to hit our shores,with more boots shoes online,Our nike sneakers like Mens Shox NZ and Womens Shox NZ sale online.


Veitch: Keep your eyes on Friend or Foe at Saratoga Race Course | facebook,myfacebook soft,myfacebook com
Pingback posted July 12, 2010 @ 11:26 pm

[...] Obama Unlikely to Use McChrystal Flap to Change Course on Afghanistan « The Washington Indepen… [...]


V-day with my best friend? | facebook,myfacebook soft,myfacebook com
Pingback posted July 14, 2010 @ 3:07 am

[...] Obama Unlikely to Use McChrystal Flap to Change Course on Afghanistan « The Washington Indepen… [...]


Music/Theater | facebook,myfacebook soft,myfacebook com
Pingback posted July 14, 2010 @ 6:16 am

[...] Obama Unlikely to Use McChrystal Flap to Change Course on Afghanistan « The Washington Indepen… [...]


louis vuitton
Comment posted August 4, 2010 @ 1:27 am

He would see that he is in the same process as Presidents of the past were. Unfortunately it seems Presidents, the military and the US public have a short membry and an even bigger ability to distort the present to try to make it the way they wish it would be.


Roll laminators
Trackback posted October 10, 2010 @ 6:08 am

That is definately a single from the ideal blogs I’ve sen in ages online. Keep up the great posts….


24 hour fitness center
Trackback posted October 18, 2010 @ 12:41 am

Ok. I believe you’re appropriate!…


italian shoes
Trackback posted October 23, 2010 @ 12:29 am

I thought that was extremeley exciting. Thanks for the unusual facts. I’ll keep next this….


Speed Karting
Trackback posted October 26, 2010 @ 11:14 pm

SZH It really is good to possess the capacity to go through a very good high quality publish with beneficial particulars on topics that plenty are interested on. The place that the information indicated are all primary hand on live experiences even aid…


genuine ugg boots
Trackback posted October 29, 2010 @ 11:02 pm

LJR You guys have a wonderful web site heading below, KIU! -OK….


Burberry handbags
Trackback posted October 31, 2010 @ 12:13 pm

CEJ I would like to thank you for that endeavors you have created in publishing this post. I am trusting the exact same greatest function from you inside future too. Actually your fanciful writing abilities has inspired me to start my own weblog now. R…


Needlepoint pillow kits
Trackback posted November 1, 2010 @ 2:30 am

Ok. I think you are correct!…


Moncer
Trackback posted November 5, 2010 @ 2:31 am

i genuinely like your internet internet site. Its pretty informative. Goodbye!…


Moncer
Trackback posted November 6, 2010 @ 1:25 am

Hi! Your publish rocks and is often a great understand!…


Gucci outlet
Trackback posted November 14, 2010 @ 3:13 pm

It’s beneficial to possess the capability to go through a great high quality article with valuable facts on topics that plenty are fascinated on. The place that the facts indicated are all first hand on live experiences even help more. Keep on doing w…


Coach shoes
Trackback posted November 19, 2010 @ 7:06 am

One particular on the best internet sites for relevant details on this niche !?!…


Gucci bags
Trackback posted November 22, 2010 @ 10:59 pm

Cheers for this write-up, guys, continue to keep up the good function….


Moncler jackets
Trackback posted November 26, 2010 @ 11:58 am

Yes! I agree what you say!…


Coach handbags
Trackback posted November 29, 2010 @ 5:31 am

It’s a excellent stage!…


Moncler jackets
Trackback posted November 29, 2010 @ 10:43 am

Another new write-up with powerful points, I’ve been a lurker here for a brief time but would like to be much much more engaged inside the future….


Tiffanys
Trackback posted December 1, 2010 @ 6:36 am

good advice and sharing,I’ll get this wonderful for me .many thanks!…


Gucci purses
Trackback posted December 3, 2010 @ 1:57 am

Here is definitely an location that may possibly be of support for you!…


Moncler
Trackback posted December 5, 2010 @ 7:34 am

This web site is excellent. How did you come up witht he idea?…


Coach wallets
Trackback posted December 6, 2010 @ 12:08 pm

I believed that was extremeley interesting. Thanks with the unusual details. I’ll retain using this….


Burberry handbags
Trackback posted December 17, 2010 @ 12:14 am

It truly is very good to possess the capability to go through a great quality post with beneficial specifics on topics that plenty are interested on. The place that the files indicated are all primary hand on reside experiences even aid a lot more. Pro…


Spyder jacket
Trackback posted December 22, 2010 @ 5:52 am

Extremely frequently I go to this website. It incredibly much is pleasant to me. Many thanks the author!…


Coach bags
Trackback posted December 30, 2010 @ 12:37 pm

This really is definately 1 on the best blogs I’ve sen in ages on the internet. Preserve up the wonderful posts….


Cheap GHD Hair Straightener
Trackback posted January 3, 2011 @ 1:06 am

Cheers for the data. Significantly appreciated….


Chloe Marcie Bag
Trackback posted January 3, 2011 @ 3:23 am

Hi! Your publish rocks and can be a very good study!…


Gucci Outlet Online
Trackback posted January 4, 2011 @ 3:09 am

It is a very good place!…


Gucci Watch
Trackback posted January 5, 2011 @ 1:33 pm

Yes, thank for your info a million! Should discover anyone organizing Tea Party. I wants to participate in organizing….


GHD Hair Straightener
Trackback posted January 6, 2011 @ 3:23 am

I believed that was extremeley interesting. Many thanks for your unusual details. I’ll retain following this….


Gucci Outlets
Trackback posted January 18, 2011 @ 11:48 am

I wants to thank you with the endeavors you might have created in publishing this article. I’m trusting the exact same finest operate from you inside long term too. In fact your fanciful writing abilities has inspired me to begin my personal blog site…


Gucci Outlets
Trackback posted January 19, 2011 @ 3:57 am

Excellent post! I’ll subscribe proper now wth my feedreader software program!…


Gucci Outlets
Trackback posted January 20, 2011 @ 1:12 am

I would like to thank you for the endeavors you could have produced in publishing this content. I’m trusting the same ideal work from you inside future as well. Actually your fanciful writing abilities has inspired me to begin my own web site now. Sin…


Gucci Outlets
Trackback posted February 15, 2011 @ 1:54 am

Cheers for this post, guys, keep up the good operate….


Overcoming Panic Attacks
Trackback posted March 8, 2011 @ 10:16 am

Overcome Panic Attacks…

[...]while the sites I link to below are completely unrelated to mine, I think they are worth a read, so go and have a look[...]…


RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.