‘Unlawful Deaths’ in Afghanistan?

By
Thursday, May 20, 2010 at 9:08 am

Afghan relatives wait outside a hospital in Kandahar. (EPA/ZumaPress.com)

A very disturbing — and disturbingly vague — announcement came early this morning from the U.S. military command in Afghanistan. According to Army Lt. Col. Joseph “Todd” Breasseale, a command spokesman, the Army’s Criminal Investigation Division is investigating whether an unknown number of American soldiers are responsible for the “unlawful deaths” of “as many as three” Afghan civilians.

[Security1]Breasseale’s statement leaves many key details vague, including how many soldiers are involved in whatever incident CID is investigating; specifically where it took place; and when it occurred. But whatever occurred was serious enough to get additional soldiers from the same unit to come forward to their chain of command with knowledge of the incident earlier this month. The statement makes it sound as if the potential criminal act was planned in advance of its commission, as allegations of “illegal drug use, assault and conspiracy” are involved, although it isn’t clear if those allegations have to do with the incident or with the cohort of soldiers under investigation more generally.

One of the soldiers in question is being held in pre-trial detention. No charges have been filed yet.

Breasseale said in an email that he couldn’t discuss further detail about the case right now. “The bottom line is that we are executing this investigation by the numbers and will not compromise our ability to gather and maintain evidence,” he said. He added that more specificity about the case will probably be available “once the charges are preferred,” an indication that CID’s investigation has progressed to the point where it is more likely than not that the soldiers involved will face charges.

It is unfortunately difficult to infer what incident this case involves. Over the past few months, despite the restrictions on rules of engagement that Gen. Stanley McChrystal issued last year to minimize civilian casualties, there have been several high-profile cases of civilian deaths at the hands of NATO forces. A so-called “night raid” earlier this month in Nangahar Province left locals saying 11 civilians were killed by U.S. troops, even though NATO considers all to be insurgents, and their anger led to a violent protest in which Afghan police killed someone. On February 12 in Gardez, also in Afghanistan’s east, U.S. Special Forces killed two men and three women — two of whom were pregnant — during a house raid, and had to correct an initial mistaken announcement that attributed the women’s deaths to insurgents. And although this incident doesn’t sound like the one under investigation, a misunderstanding at a Kandahar checkpoint led soldiers to open fire on a passenger bus, leaving four civilians dead.

Statistics from McChrystal’s command compiled by USA Today last month found that NATO-caused civilian casualties have risen in early 2010 from a comparable period in 2009, a disturbing increase the command attributes to an increased tempo of military operations. In a joint press conference last week with Afghanistan’s president, Hamid Karzai, President Obama expressed personal anguish over civilian casualties in Afghanistan.

Before McChrystal took command in Afghanistan, he said that the perceptions of the Afghan people that the NATO coalition is interested in protecting them from harm and the Afghan government is interested in enriching their lives would be “strategically decisive” in the nearly nine-year war. His counterinsurgency guidance instructs his troops to assume additional risk to their own lives in the interest of preventing civilians from being accidentally killed. After the Paktia incident, McChrystal consolidated his hold over Special Operations Forces operating in Afghanistan.

The U.S. military command in Afghanistan “is committed to the security and safety of the Afghan population,” Breasseale’s statement concluded, “and will ensure any crimes are investigated fully and those responsible will be held accountable.”

Follow Spencer Ackerman on Twitter


Comments

34 Comments

Fatima Ayub
Comment posted May 20, 2010 @ 2:10 pm

Please correct your article to account for the fact the Gardez incident was not merely miscommunicated. A number of civilians were killed in that raid, including three women, one of whom was pregnant. The women had been bound and shot, and ISAF forces had gone so far as to remove bullets from the women's bodies in an attempt to cover up the deaths by alleging that insurgents or family members had killed the women in an honor killing. ISAF later had to reverse the story entirely. It is much more problematic and insidious than your report suggests. The London Times has covered the story in more detail. http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/world/afg…


John Wood
Comment posted May 20, 2010 @ 7:10 pm

This sort of thing comes from poor discipline as the soldiers feel frustrated and are confused by the way they are ordered not to pursue the warriors basic drive – to fight and do whatever is necessary to win


makaainana
Comment posted May 22, 2010 @ 5:47 pm

As many as THREE??? Give me a break.


America: Its Own Worst Enemy « God and Whose Army? The Blog
Pingback posted May 28, 2010 @ 9:56 am

[...] ‘Unlawful Deaths’ in Afghanistan (Washington Independent) [...]


air max 1
Comment posted June 3, 2010 @ 2:06 pm

move your feet with your heart


louis vuitton
Comment posted August 4, 2010 @ 5:39 am

as the soldiers feel frustrated and are confused by the way they are ordered not to pursue the warriors basic drive – to fight and do whatever is necessary to win


xujing
Comment posted May 17, 2011 @ 5:56 am

 ??DVD????dvd ?????????????????dvd ????????????DVD???????????????????????dvd ????????DVD?????????????????????????dvd ??????????dvd???????dvd?????????dvd ?????????????????dvd ??????????????????????dvd???????????dvd ???????????????dvd????????dvd ??????????????????????????????????????dvd?????????????????????????????????????????????dvd??????????????DVD??????????????????????????DVD????????????????DVD???????????????????????????????????????DVD?????????????????????????????????DVD?????????????DVD?????????????????????????????DVD?????????????????????????????DVD?????????????1???????????
??DVD????dvd ?????????????????dvd ????????????DVD???????????????????????dvd ????????DVD?????????????????????????dvd ??????????dvd???????dvd?????????dvd ?????????????????dvd ??????????????????????dvd???????????dvd ???????????????dvd????????dvd ??????????????????????????????????????dvd?????????????????????????????????????????????dvd??????????????DVD??????????????????????????DVD????????????????DVD???????????????????????????????????????DVD?????????????????????????????????DVD?????????????DVD?????????????????????????????DVD?????????????????????????????DVD?????????????1???????????


Christian Louboutin
Comment posted May 17, 2011 @ 7:56 am

Nice post.Thank you for taking the time to publish this information very useful!
Christian Louboutin Heels |
Louboutin Sale |
Christian Louboutin Sale |
Louboutin Flats |
Louboutin Pumps |
Louboutin Sandals |
Louboutin Slingbacks |
Jimmy Choo |
Yves Saint Laurent |
Manolo Blahnik |
Tory Burch


Rfopk Avtl
Comment posted May 17, 2011 @ 8:32 am

 I like it very much, thank you
???
???
???
???
???
???
???
???


Rfopk Avtl
Comment posted May 17, 2011 @ 8:32 am

 I like it very much, thank you
???
???
???
???
???
???
???
???


Rfopk Avtl
Comment posted May 17, 2011 @ 8:32 am

 I like it very much, thank you 
cheap custom jerseys
custom jerseys
customized jerseys
cheap customized jerseys


Rfopk Avtl
Comment posted May 17, 2011 @ 8:32 am

 I like it very much, thank you 
cheap custom jerseys
custom jerseys
customized jerseys
cheap customized jerseys


iPhone Application Development
Comment posted May 18, 2011 @ 1:27 pm

Now Afghanis in a big trouble but some them are innocent…:-/


nba nfl nhl mlb
Comment posted May 28, 2011 @ 12:51 am

I like it very much, thank you
运动鞋
篮球鞋
运动服


chan aiba
Comment posted June 6, 2011 @ 2:34 am

http://besttojp.com/zhongguotese/class44.html
http://www.besttojp.com/product/mh.html
http://www.besttojp.com/product/cp.html
http://www.besttojp.com/product/szr.html
http://www.besttojp.com/product/xr.html
http://www.besttojp.com/product/wuweizi.html
http://www.besttojp.com/product/saoyao.html
http://www.besttojp.com/product/sy.html
http://besttojp.com/chinatea/index.html
http://www.besttojp.com/chinatea/class40.html
http://www.besttojp.com/chinatea/class35.html
http://www.besttojp.com/Product/axqx.html
http://www.besttojp.com/product/xhlj.html
http://www.besttojp.com/product/jyh.html
http://www.besttojp.com/chinatea/class43.html
http://besttojp.com/Product/dzc.html
http://besttojp.com/Product/kdc.html
http://besttojp.com/Product/jmz.html
http://besttojp.com/Product/xc.html
http://besttojp.com/Product/tqrs.html
http://faeaeoqa.arekao.jp/
http://afsjwjf.arekao.jp/
http://goomenn.arekao.jp/
http://fafeoo.arekao.jp/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/fdghgfh/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/hjhgjghj/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/ssgsgg/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/gjhgjhj/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/fdfdfdf/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/fassyondu/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/happykasi/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/gogoteaxi/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/sweetcuptea/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/juewei/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/teagadai/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/cuptea/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/cuptea1/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/cuptea2/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/teagasuki/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/hohoho/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/lakajai/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/lopiia/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/kmikio/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/loljji/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/cvccbvb/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/hgfhetfe/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/retoreit/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/cvcvbvrdgd/


chan aiba
Comment posted June 6, 2011 @ 2:35 am

http://www.afinjapan.com/
http://www.afinjapan.com/category-486-b0.html
http://www.afinjapan.com/category-500-b0.html
http://www.afinjapan.com/category-527-b0.html
http://www.afinjapan.com/category-491-b0.html
http://www.afinjapan.com/category-497-b0.html
http://www.afinjapan.com/category-518-b0.html
http://www.afinjapan.com/category-490-b0.html
http://www.afinjapan.com/category-496-b0.html
http://www.afinjapan.com/category-501-b0.html
http://www.afinjapan.com/category-502-b0.html
http://www.afinjapan.com/category-510-b0.html
http://www.afinjapan.com/category-511-b0.html
http://www.afinjapan.com/category-512-b0.html
http://www.afinjapan.com/category-525-b0.html
http://www.afinjapan.com/category-526-b0.html
http://www.afinjapan.com/category-521-b0.html
http://www.afinjapan.com/category-527-b0.html
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/cocomeu/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/memeha/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/dfdsfds/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/gfgfgf/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/gfjgkfj/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/bbcvd/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/vbcbcb/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/gdfghfg/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/vcbcxrf/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/dsfhgg/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/bvbcv/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/mifuha/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/gagamifu/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/jumifu/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/gougoumeng/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/happueng/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/babikoko/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/lweigaga/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/linkopwu/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/goushi989/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/gougou989/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/aolafa/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/vabama/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/lkalaja/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/vcbtdgfg/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/jiajiajia/


chan aiba
Comment posted June 6, 2011 @ 2:35 am

http://www.afinjapan.com/
http://www.afinjapan.com/category-486-b0.html
http://www.afinjapan.com/category-500-b0.html
http://www.afinjapan.com/category-527-b0.html
http://www.afinjapan.com/category-491-b0.html
http://www.afinjapan.com/category-497-b0.html
http://www.afinjapan.com/category-518-b0.html
http://www.afinjapan.com/category-490-b0.html
http://www.afinjapan.com/category-496-b0.html
http://www.afinjapan.com/category-501-b0.html
http://www.afinjapan.com/category-502-b0.html
http://www.afinjapan.com/category-510-b0.html
http://www.afinjapan.com/category-511-b0.html
http://www.afinjapan.com/category-512-b0.html
http://www.afinjapan.com/category-525-b0.html
http://www.afinjapan.com/category-526-b0.html
http://www.afinjapan.com/category-521-b0.html
http://www.afinjapan.com/category-527-b0.html
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/cocomeu/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/memeha/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/dfdsfds/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/gfgfgf/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/gfjgkfj/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/bbcvd/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/vbcbcb/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/gdfghfg/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/vcbcxrf/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/dsfhgg/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/bvbcv/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/mifuha/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/gagamifu/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/jumifu/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/gougoumeng/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/happueng/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/babikoko/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/lweigaga/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/linkopwu/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/goushi989/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/gougou989/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/aolafa/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/vabama/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/lkalaja/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/vcbtdgfg/
http://pub.bookmark.ne.jp/jiajiajia/


iPhone Application Developer
Comment posted June 10, 2011 @ 5:01 am

We are all know about Afghanistan condition but we also helped them to re-establish again


building on a budget
Trackback posted August 21, 2011 @ 10:52 pm

Superb website…

[...]always a big fan of linking to bloggers that I love but don’t get a lot of link love from[...]…


Backyard Water Features
Trackback posted August 22, 2011 @ 1:01 pm

outdoor wall waterfall…

[...]we like to honor other sites on the web, even if they aren’t related to us, by linking to them. Below are some sites worth checking out[...]…


Attorneys
Trackback posted August 22, 2011 @ 4:12 pm

US Immigration…

[...]the time to read or visit the content or sites we have linked to below the[...]…


Investing For Beginners
Trackback posted August 23, 2011 @ 3:20 am

Find a Financial Advisor…

Wonderful story reckoned I could insert a few not related posts, although still worthwhile having a look!!!…


miss america 2012
Trackback posted August 31, 2011 @ 7:22 am

Amy Winehouse…

[...]below are a handful of urls to internet websites which we link to since we feel they will be really worth visiting[...]…


Scholarships for African Americans
Trackback posted August 31, 2011 @ 10:08 pm

Netflix…

[...]here are several web links to web pages which I link to seeing as we feel these are well worth checking out[...]…


Red Bottom Shoes
Trackback posted September 1, 2011 @ 9:06 pm

Netflix…

[...]here are some web page links to web-sites we link to as we believe they are definitely worth visiting[...]…


Medical supplies
Trackback posted September 4, 2011 @ 6:18 am

Best Medical supplies store online…

[...]over h?re you can find a short enumaration of links I picked up that I think you sh?uld visit[...]…


Med supplies
Trackback posted September 4, 2011 @ 1:08 pm

Medical supplies for everybody at SaveRite…

[...]You might find it dificult to find the conection between this 2 sites but we still think you should check it out[...]…


nova scotia restaurants
Trackback posted September 6, 2011 @ 12:51 am

nova scotia resorts…

[...]we like to honor other nova scotia resorts websites on the web, even if they aren’t related to us, by linking to them. Below are some sites worth checking out[...]…


Stop sweating start living review
Trackback posted September 6, 2011 @ 11:37 am

Stop sweat fast…

[...]these sites are really worth a look im sure you will agree they are top class[...]…


RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.