With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm

By
Tuesday, April 13, 2010 at 6:00 am

VAT tax

When House Speaker Nancy Pelosi told Charlie Rose last October that a value-added tax was “on the table” as a possible way to solve the nation’s fiscal woes, the remark didn’t generate much interest. But as recent budget figures have put the depth of America’s problem into black and white, and with former Federal Reserve Chairman and White House adviser Paul Volcker nearly seconding Pelosi’s view recently, the idea of a VAT — already in use in nearly 160 countries — is gaining traction. And some progressives are sounding an alarm.

[Economy1] The prospect of a VAT is likely to be discussed by the fiscal commission established by President Obama. The Wall Street Journal’s opinion page has already sarcastically labeled the consortium the “VAT Commission.” At a recent event organized by the Scholars Strategy Network, a left-leaning think tank, an MIT political scientist floated the prospect of VAT as a solution to the federal revenue crunch. Volcker just last week fueled the fire even more, noting that a VAT tax was not as toxic an idea as it once had been. (Sen. Charles Grassley, R-Iowa, responded this week by coming out against the tax.) All the attention has not been welcomed by progressive groups, who worry that a VAT would unfairly burden the already-struggling working poor. “It crushes the low-income and the elderly,” said Robert McIntyre, director of Citizens for Tax Justice.

Since VAT is a tax on consumption rather than income or investments, it’s considered a regressive tax. Poor people, who tend to spend a higher percentage of their income than wealthier ones, are disproportionately affected by consumption-based taxes. In the U.S., regressive sales taxes are balanced out by a progressive income tax structure.

Proponents of a VAT, though, contend that it wouldn’t hurt lower-income Americans if implemented properly, and that the additional revenue it generates would prevent cuts to social-service and welfare programs.

Left-leaning think tanks such as the Center for American Progress express concern that adding a VAT to the country’s existing tax code or using it to replace the majority of the income tax, as Michael Graetz, Columbia University School of Law professor and author of “100 Million Unnecessary Returns: A Simple Fair and Competitive Tax Plan for the United States,” proposed to the Senate Finance Committee in 2008, would tip the balance in favor of the rich and drop a staggering weight on an already-struggling demographic.

While value-added taxes are common throughout the rest of the world (including Europe, Canada and Australia), many Americans are still fuzzy about what exactly this tax is and how it works. A VAT is essentially a tax on all or nearly all goods and services. Many European countries exempt certain items such as groceries from VAT collection — a mistake, according to economists who counter that a laundry list of exemptions only serves to make the rate higher. What makes a VAT different from a sales tax is the way it’s collected.

The tax is levied on every company that participates in the development of a product, but each participant gets credit for the VAT that has already been paid. If a retailer in a country with a 10 percent VAT buys goods from a vendor, they pay an extra 10 percent on those goods. That retailer is then responsible for collecting 10 percent VAT on sales to customers. When each company in the supply chain pays taxes, though, they get to deduct the VAT they paid from what their customers paid. These somewhat complicated mechanics create a lengthy paper trail that thwarts would-be evaders. Since each company in a supply chain has to collect the tax, there’s also a certain degree of self-policing.

Although right-leaning lawmakers tend to favor regressive tax policies, some conservatives dislike the concept of a VAT because they worry it would inflate the size of the government. “Conservatives think VAT is a hidden tax and therefore a money machine,” said Gilbert Metcalf, professor of economics at Tufts University. In reality, analysts say that concern is overblown. The U.S. debt load has mushroomed so substantially that even adding a new revenue stream in the form of a VAT wouldn’t generate huge surpluses.

The cost of Social Security, Medicare and other entitlement programs is predicted to skyrocket in the coming decades. “The largest programs in the budget support older people,” said Eric Toder, a fellow at the Urban Institute and the Tax Policy Center.

For the nation’s working poor, that’s bad news, says Will Marshall, president of the Progressive Policy Institute. “What’s happening now is the automatic growth of entitlement spending is squeezing out space in the budget for everything else, which includes programs for low-income families.”

Toder and others dismiss the notion that ratcheting up existing taxes will be enough to fill the revenue gap. “You’re running against how high you can squeeze income tax. You don’t want to push it too much further. If you tax investment income too high, we’ll start seeing capital fleeing the U.S.”

If the administration and Congress do consider a value-added tax, some experts do hold out hope that it can be levied in such a way that doesn’t disproportionately impact the disadvantaged. While a VAT itself will never be progressive, there are ways to offset its burden on the poor. “There’s no reason low-income people should bear the burden of getting our nation’s finances in order,” said Columbia’s Michael Graetz. “There’s no inherent reason a VAT has to disproportionately burden low-income people,” he said.

Offering refundable tax credits for Americans living below a certain income threshold, for instance, would help equalize the burden. Graetz also proposed distributing debit cards similar to those on which food stamps are issued to lower-income consumers that would exempt a certain dollar amount of purchases from value-added taxation.

While many of the European VAT structures exclude necessities like food and clothing in the name of making the tax more progressive, many analysts say this just makes administration harder. Exempting certain categories of purchases also means that the rate on everything else is pushed higher. For instance, some European countries have VATs of up to 20 percent, a rate that can be attributed to numerous exemptions.

One of the most sweeping proposals is that put forth by Graetz, who suggests implementing a VAT of 10 to 14 percent and eliminating income taxes for households making less than $100,000 annually. Graetz, who also co-authored a book lambasting the 2001 repeal of the estate tax, maintains that his plan would simplify the tax process for 150 million Americans, and a combination of credits and offsets for lower-income people would keep them from bearing the brunt of the new tax.

While Graetz’s plan is revenue-neutral, he says it offers a better way to tackle the revenue crunch because a VAT is easier to increase than the current income tax. It would also relieve many current taxpayers of the annual burden of preparing and filing their returns. “Americans feel better about taxes that they feel they can pay without undue burden,” Andrea Louise Campbell, a political science professor at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, wrote in a recent paper. “Easing payment not only helps public acceptance but also encourages compliance.” There’s also no way for the wealthy to avoid paying their share via tax shelters or accounting tricks, since the tax is collected at the point of purchase. This still isn’t convincing for some progressives. Yes, credits could offset the burden on America’s poor. But, they argue, those credits could be rescinded at the whim of a right-leaning Congress. “One concern has to be, will there be political pressure to eliminate those kinds of credits?” said Michael Linden, associate director of tax and budget policy at the Center for American Progress. “Having a VAT replace income tax entirely is a terrible idea,” he said. “If VAT becomes a solution it will have to be part of a larger tax system, ideally part of a larger tax reform effort.”

Graetz argues that draconian spending cuts in social and support programs would hurt low-income people more than an incremental tax increase. “You’ve got to look not just at the way revenues are collected but at the way those benefits are distributed,” he said. Credits or exemptions for the poorest Americans would protect them from paying a higher percentage of their income towards a VAT, and the revenues raised could keep social-service programs off the chopping block.

Comments

73 Comments

With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm | TheUnical Technologies Blog
Pingback posted April 13, 2010 @ 6:47 am

[...] The Washington Independent pay per click These somewhat complicated mechanics create a lengthy paper trail that thwarts would-be evaders. Since each company in a supply chain has to collect the tax … See all stories on this topic [...]


Amazing Recipes
Pingback posted April 13, 2010 @ 7:29 am

[...] With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm « The … [...]


Alternative Tight and Loose Play for Maximum Results at the Poker Table | Independent World Class Magazines...
Pingback posted April 13, 2010 @ 7:33 am

[...] With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm « The … [...]


SCIENCE KNOWLEDGE: Exposing Hackers as an International Deterrent | Artificial Intelligence Science Applied
Pingback posted April 13, 2010 @ 7:43 am

[...] With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm « The … [...]


trippin
Comment posted April 13, 2010 @ 8:19 am

Obama worships Larry Summers. Larry Summers was quoted in the WSJ from a 90s era screed that extending unemployment benefits enable people to hold out for a job that pays them what they’re worth, the very antithesis of what Summers and his ilk have been striving for, namely, reduction of America’s middle class to Third World economic status.

So, will we implement the most regressive form of tax available? You betcha. Just grind the working poor and people on fixed income into the ground, shift the tax burden to them, and allow the fat cats to get away with 15% tax on their capital gains.

That’s the American Way, and Obama won’t do a single blessed goddamned thing to stand in its way — you can count on it.


Is it ok to put two 8 – 10 inch koi in a toddlers swimming pool? | Baby Learning Systems
Pingback posted April 13, 2010 @ 8:55 am

[...] With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm « The … [...]


Fender Strat Eric Johnson Pickup Assy No Reserve | Electric Guitar Sales
Pingback posted April 13, 2010 @ 9:19 am

[...] With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm « The Washington Independent [...]


Private Student Loan, What Is It? | Student Loans Repayment
Pingback posted April 13, 2010 @ 10:03 am

[...] With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm « The … [...]


California bill exempts foreclosed homeowners from taxes on forgiven debt · bee blog
Pingback posted April 13, 2010 @ 11:38 am

[...] With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm « The … [...]


Best Deals on Verizon Cell Phones | Verison Cell Phones
Pingback posted April 13, 2010 @ 2:09 pm

[...] With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm « The … [...]


WHERE IS MY DHCP SERVER ACTIVE IP TABLE?? · bee blog
Pingback posted April 13, 2010 @ 2:14 pm

[...] With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm « The … [...]


Leo Hindery, Jr.: When two Progressives disagree – about creating jobs
Pingback posted April 13, 2010 @ 3:09 pm

[...] With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm « The … [...]


Mattson Technology's Millios(TM) Flash RTP System Recognized as … | Thermal Processing Material Geek
Pingback posted April 13, 2010 @ 3:22 pm

[...] With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm « The … [...]


Frog tadpoles ’scream’ underwater when attacked, say scientists
Pingback posted April 13, 2010 @ 3:25 pm

[...] With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm « The … [...]


How do I know stores actually pay the sales tax to the IRS?
Pingback posted April 13, 2010 @ 3:38 pm

[...] With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm « The … [...]


What is the deal with Kitties and showers?
Pingback posted April 13, 2010 @ 3:41 pm

[...] With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm « The … [...]


College Tax Breaks Can Trim Your Bill By Thousands | Student Loans Repayment
Pingback posted April 13, 2010 @ 5:16 pm

[...] With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm « The … [...]


can you claim a second home on your taxes if you have two mortgages on the first home? | HomeGalaxy.info
Pingback posted April 13, 2010 @ 5:36 pm

[...] With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm « The … [...]


patriotsoul
Comment posted April 13, 2010 @ 5:07 pm

Just keep adding more expenses to our lives.
We don't need any of our own money!
GIVE IT ALL and work to give even more to those who steal from others to make ends meet somewhere, and buy a new flat screen 3-D tv.
It is for the common good.


ALLENTOWN: Angry residents decry UFR school budget with 10% tax levy hike | Student Loans Repayment
Pingback posted April 13, 2010 @ 7:58 pm

[...] With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm « The … [...]


Gen Next: 2009-10 AHL Playoff Preview :: 2010 Free Fantasy Hockey … | Bridgeport Sound Tigers AHL Announcer
Pingback posted April 13, 2010 @ 10:16 pm

[...] With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm « The … [...]


Rachel
Comment posted April 13, 2010 @ 10:45 pm

We need to stop Nancy Pelois, support John Dennis in 2010. We cannot afford to be taxed to death. Pelosi think that the American people are just a piggy bank for her agenda. Go to JohnDennis2010(dot)com and show your support.


refinancing
Pingback posted April 14, 2010 @ 1:06 am

[...] With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm « The … [...]


how will i know if the irs will take out money for a default student loan? | Student Loans Repayment
Pingback posted April 14, 2010 @ 2:31 am

[...] With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm « The … [...]


Bose speakers? | Bose Computer Speakers.net
Pingback posted April 14, 2010 @ 2:55 am

[...] With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm « The … [...]


What to do if you find your spouse is thinking of cheating, after reading her email? | Email Search Address
Pingback posted April 14, 2010 @ 4:13 am

[...] With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm « The … [...]


Travel Channel – time to travel » Blog Archive » A Guide To … | Austria Traveling
Pingback posted April 14, 2010 @ 4:16 am

[...] With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm « The … [...]


Gigabyte Psu buzzing? · bee blog
Pingback posted April 14, 2010 @ 4:45 am

[...] With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm « The … [...]


Blackjack Highrollers « Live Casino Now
Pingback posted April 14, 2010 @ 6:01 am

[...] With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm « The … [...]


Checking for Income tax garnished for default student loan? | Student Loans Repayment
Pingback posted April 14, 2010 @ 8:29 am

[...] With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm « The … [...]


adventures_adventure trips_adventure trip_free online adventure games_adventure quest worlds » Why the U.S. can learn from New Zealand when it comes to taxes
Pingback posted April 14, 2010 @ 8:49 am

[...] With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm « The … [...]


— What would my deductable be if i donated my car to charity?
Pingback posted April 14, 2010 @ 8:59 am

[...] With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm « The … [...]


Multi Medium » Yet Another Brilliant Deficit-Reduction Idea
Pingback posted April 14, 2010 @ 11:44 am

[...] one thing we really need to do in the middle of a recession with 10% unemployment, it’s raise the cost of living… When House Speaker Nancy Pelosi told Charlie Rose last October that a value-added tax was “on the [...]


Akon Thinks Christina Aguilera Is "Insecure" About Lady Gaga … | Christina Aguilera Celebrity Monitor
Pingback posted April 14, 2010 @ 12:20 pm

[...] With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm « The … [...]


More Taxes? The Regressive VAT « A. J. MacDonald, Jr.
Pingback posted April 14, 2010 @ 1:59 pm

[...] you heard about this new tax the feds are proposing: the Value Added Tax (VAT)? It’s bad enough that the feds are proposing yet another tax upon the American [...]


Control Engineering North American edition, April 2010 – 2010-04 … | Control Engineering Addict
Pingback posted April 14, 2010 @ 6:17 pm

[...] With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm « The … [...]


Suburban Guerrilla » Blog Archive » Taxing The Poor To Bail Out The Rich
Pingback posted April 14, 2010 @ 6:19 pm

[...] what it’s all about these days. Ian Welsh: Value Added Tax (VAT) version: When House Speaker Nancy Pelosi told Charlie Rose last October that a value-added tax was “on [...]


Save for a rainy day or go on a spending spree? | Best Saving Rates
Pingback posted April 14, 2010 @ 7:27 pm

[...] W&#1110t&#1211 VAT Tax &#959&#1495 t&#1211&#1077 Table, Progressives Sound Alarm « T&#1211&#10… [...]


eztempo
Comment posted April 14, 2010 @ 6:39 pm

A VAT is yet another way to shift the burden of paying for Bush's tax cuts for the rich onto those at the lower end of the income scale over the next generation. We used to be better than this as a nation.


You Can Make an Outdoor Cooking Camp Table Out of the Twigs
Pingback posted April 14, 2010 @ 7:41 pm

[...] With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm « The Washington Independent [...]


Make Them Accountable / Take VAT!
Pingback posted April 14, 2010 @ 7:48 pm

[...] Washington Independent (thanks to Ian Welsh): [...]


— Where to donate my car?
Pingback posted April 14, 2010 @ 8:56 pm

[...] With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm « The … [...]


3 Quick Tips to Make Sure You Are Ready for the April 15th Deadline
Pingback posted April 14, 2010 @ 9:00 pm

[...] to have mistakes. http://www.ProVisionWealth.com Other points of interest related to this article With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm « The … | The National Tax Day Amalgamated Federation of Confederated Unions … | RealClearPolitics – Tax [...]


Swami_Binkinanda
Comment posted April 14, 2010 @ 9:12 pm

Who will be Eloi and who will be Morelock?


Tax Breaks For Students | Student Loans Repayment
Pingback posted April 14, 2010 @ 11:52 pm

[...] With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm « The … [...]


The Real Niagara Falls, New York | Hotels in Niagara Falls, Ontario Canada
Pingback posted April 15, 2010 @ 1:48 am

[...] With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm « The … [...]


Silverlight, Microsoft Answer to Adobe — Software Reviews … | Silverlight WebDev Insider
Pingback posted April 15, 2010 @ 3:33 pm

[...] With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm « The … [...]


Bears Bites and Insights: Bears Turn Back Tigers in Series Opener | Bridgeport Sound Tigers AHL Announcer
Pingback posted April 16, 2010 @ 4:22 am

[...] With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm « The … [...]


Where can I buy carbon monoxide detectors that sound at 10ppm? | Carbon Monoxide Alarm First Alert
Pingback posted April 16, 2010 @ 9:56 am

[...] With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm « The Washington Independent [...]


sea world san diego_sea animals_sea world san antonio_sea temperature_sea world orlando » How can i Contact Poseidon, Greek God of the Sea?
Pingback posted April 16, 2010 @ 10:21 am

[...] With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm « The … [...]


sea world san diego_sea animals_sea world san antonio_sea temperature_sea world orlando » What video editor can I use to do simple operations?
Pingback posted April 16, 2010 @ 7:22 pm

[...] With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm « The … [...]


Guest
Comment posted April 16, 2010 @ 9:03 pm

Ok…it must a “demorat” who posted, putting the blame on BUSH. Clearly for you, you are probally thinking it is his fault when today's run government has outspend past presidents. Come on now, did you eat your Wheaties in the morning before posting.

Now, this still doesn't excuse the publicans either.


sea world san diego_sea animals_sea world san antonio_sea temperature_sea world orlando » RAC decision: VAT relief list to contain maximum food items
Pingback posted April 17, 2010 @ 2:53 am

[...] With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm « The … [...]


Campaign For Liberty — Senate votes against a value-added tax | Tax Finance Wisdom
Pingback posted April 17, 2010 @ 9:09 pm

[...] With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm « The … [...]


rightdemocrat
Comment posted April 17, 2010 @ 9:03 pm

A value addeed tax could be made far less regressive by ending the income tax for those making less than 100K per year and providing rebates to the poor. A number of countries use a VAT to protect their manufacturing base and support a social safety net. If a VAT helps to pay for Social Security and health care while creating middle jobs, then it sounds like a progressive idea to me.


Do online businesses have to pay federal taxes?
Pingback posted April 20, 2010 @ 3:03 pm

[...] With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm « The … [...]


danvvvvv
Comment posted April 20, 2010 @ 7:20 pm

Can anyone in DC answer this question for me regarding VAT? My company employs 4,000 (union) and is in a commodity based manufactured item – competing primarily with China and Eastern Europe. If a VAT tax was added into our cost of goods, would we be at a competitive disadvantage with imports – or is a duty of a like amount added to these products? I can't get an answer from my represenatives in California – hoping someone in DC reads this. Thanks


Obama suggests value-added tax may be an option - Page 6
Pingback posted April 22, 2010 @ 2:52 pm

[...] [...]


calvinthecat
Comment posted April 29, 2010 @ 12:10 pm

The transaction tax is much better. It taxes transactions not currently taxed and will be paid by those most able to afford them. Think of all those daily Wall Street transactions that go on every day. We could tax them fractionally and it wouldn't even be felt. Listen to them howl over that and prefer the VAT where they aren't touched.


Humor: Tax on corporate board fees? The outrage!
Pingback posted April 30, 2010 @ 11:16 pm

[...] With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm « The … [...]


Filtered news 5/3/10 « Russ' Filtered News
Pingback posted May 3, 2010 @ 1:45 pm

[...] What would a VAT tax do to our low-income and elderly citizens? It ain’t pretty. [...]


4 month old baby_babies 5 months_4 months babies » Proposal would remove sales tax cap on certain items
Pingback posted May 4, 2010 @ 9:29 pm

[...] With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm « The … [...]


Can Turbo Tax 2007 be used for a 2008 return? | turbo tax,turbo tax coupons,compare turbo tax - turbo tax worth home
Pingback posted May 5, 2010 @ 2:15 pm

[...] With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm « The … [...]


ACSial
Comment posted May 5, 2010 @ 11:14 pm

I'd advise against this. Here, in Canada, the Mulroney (Progressive Conservative) government brought in the 7% Goods and Services Tax, widely derided as the 'Gouge and Screw Tax'. The bureaucracy for this thing eats up half the revenue it brings in. The Chretien Liberals promised to repeal it…but didn't. Now, the Harper Conservative government whittled it down to 5%, but kept it. Now, some provinces with a sales tax (all, but Alberta) are merging their taxes, with the GST, to the anger of many.

It would be better to raise income taxes (i.e., using the existing tax-collection infrastructure) and slash spending. There are many things that could be cut in your country. For instance, pointless porkbarrel defense and space programmes (e.g., missile defense, most of NASA), Amtrack (which eats up 5% of your Federal budget), subsidies for union-ridden municipal transit systems and infrastructure projects…and giving illegal aliens the boot: uninsured illegals and their anchor babies cost your country billions in subsidies to state and local governments, for healthcare and education. And be ruthless with your cuts, as every billion you save is NOT money in the form of PRC-held T-bills.


MYMY
Comment posted May 17, 2010 @ 4:45 pm

If it got rid of the onerous filing of taxes on personal income year in year out for those of us who pay these taxes (under 100K a year; the top guys don't ever actually pay out at nearly the rate we do) it is worth considering. I'm not certain that it would be worked out correctly, as it is in most European countries I am familiar with, but if done in truly good faith, it might alter a number of unproductive practices in this country, all done to avoid paying income tax on them.


What’s the percentage of tax charged upon a ringtone download in France? | Download Zone
Pingback posted May 27, 2010 @ 4:11 am

[...] With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm « The … [...]


OPISO.legal » Are Higher Taxes in Your Future
Pingback posted September 27, 2010 @ 8:20 am

[...] we consider alternative taxes?: “With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm” and “Flat tax yields [...]


Nancy Polosi's Transaction Tax! - SailNet Community
Pingback posted October 11, 2010 @ 11:01 pm

[...] [...]


OPISO » Are Higher Taxes in Your Future
Pingback posted November 20, 2010 @ 10:08 pm

[...] we consider alternative taxes?: “With VAT Tax on the Table, Progressives Sound Alarm” and “Flat tax yields [...]


Dog bark collar
Comment posted February 12, 2011 @ 4:11 am

Thanks for the article. This keeps me informed about the topic.


Venapro
Comment posted February 15, 2011 @ 5:51 pm

Thanks for ones marvelous posting! I truly enjoyed reading it, you could be a great author.I will be sure to bookmark your blog and may come back in the foreseeable future. I want to encourage you continue your great work, have a nice holiday weekend!


RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.