The National Security Case Against Killing Anwar al-Awlaki

By
Wednesday, April 07, 2010 at 4:07 pm

For a moment, leave aside the legal questions about the Obama administration’s apparent decision that it possesses the legal authority to order the extra-judicial killing of American citizen and possible al-Qaeda affiliate Anwar al-Awlaki. Karen Greenberg, director of New York University’s Center on Law and Security and the person who convinced me the government can’t just revoke al-Awlaki’s citizenship, views a potential assassination of the Yemen-based cleric as a looming national security blunder.

“Why kill someone who’s crucially important to linking that world and our world?” Greenberg said. “From the point of view of national security, having him in custody is far more important than killing him. He is an enemy that knows an incredible amount. Wouldn’t you like to know who in the U.S. has been in conversation with him?”

There’s an additional irony, as Marcy Wheeler pointed out this morning. (Full disclosure: Marcy and I are both part of the Firedoglake blog-mafia.) Chances are whatever determination that al-Awlaki has crossed the line from inciting terrorist plots to participating in them — as an anonymous administration official cited to Greg Miller – came from the interrogation of Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab. Which occurred with the full protections of Miranda rights under the U.S. criminal justice system. Abdulmutallab, of course, isn’t a citizen and al-Awlaki is.

On the other hand, maybe we shouldn’t even credit the recent determination that al-Awlaki has “recently become an operational figure for al-Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula,” as the official told Miller. After all, the U.S. tried to kill him with a drone-launched missile strike in December.

For Greenberg, even before the legal and constitutional questions about the permissibility of killing al-Awlaki arise, the strategic wisdom of it escapes her. “This is not a human rights issue, primarily, for me,” she said. “What do we get out of killing him?”

To be on the safe side, this morning, The Washington Independent filed Freedom of Information Act requests with the Justice Department and the CIA for any documentation determining the legal basis for an extra-judicial killing of any American citizen on counterterrorism grounds. This is after repeated messages left with DOJ, White House and CIA spokespeople to uncover that assertion. All I got was a quote from CIA spokesman George Little that “this agency conducts its counterterrorism operations in strict accord with the law.” I was unable to persuade George to elaborate on the basis for his confidence that, in this case, it’s doing that.

Follow Spencer Ackerman on Twitter


Comments

41 Comments

More on the assassination of American citizens on the President’s say-so « Later On
Pingback posted April 7, 2010 @ 4:26 pm

[...] Law, Obama administration, Terrorism at 1:26 pm by LeisureGuy First, Spencer Ackerman discusses the national-security case against assassinating Anwar al-Awlaki: For a moment, leave aside the legal questions about the Obama administration’s apparent decision [...]


uberVU - social comments
Trackback posted April 7, 2010 @ 7:25 pm

Social comments and analytics for this post…

This post was mentioned on Twitter by peacecompassion: The National Security Case Against Killing Anwar al-Awlaki http://bit.ly/csViLW...


Second man arrested in connection with March 2 murder in Crescent … | Putnam County FL Real Estate
Pingback posted April 7, 2010 @ 8:07 pm

[...] The National Security Case Against Killing Anwar al-Awlaki « The … [...]


Credigy Services Corp [ Five other states join suit against the Health Act (Update1) ]
Pingback posted April 7, 2010 @ 8:16 pm

[...] The National Security Case Against Killing Anwar al-Awlaki « The … [...]


Credit Search Online
Pingback posted April 7, 2010 @ 8:27 pm

[...] The National Security Case Against Killing Anwar al-Awlaki « The … [...]


National Best-Sellers
Pingback posted April 7, 2010 @ 8:52 pm

[...] The National Security Case Against Killing Anwar al-Awlaki « The … [...]


Travel Trends: “Spa Tapas” at Sense, A Rosewood Spa at The Carlyle … | Spa Beauty Wisdom
Pingback posted April 7, 2010 @ 9:05 pm

[...] The National Security Case Against Killing Anwar al-Awlaki « The … [...]


New Black Silicone Skin Case Cover for Sony PSP Go | ColdSip.com
Pingback posted April 7, 2010 @ 9:21 pm

[...] The National Security Case Against Killing Anwar al-Awlaki « The … [...]


Roman Polanski attorneys plead to end case (AP) | AVRDirect.com
Pingback posted April 7, 2010 @ 10:11 pm

[...] The National Security Case Against Killing Anwar al-Awlaki « The … [...]


Day 3: National Parks Promo Code Sale from Alaska Airlines
Pingback posted April 7, 2010 @ 11:57 pm

[...] The National Security Case Against Killing Anwar al-Awlaki « The … [...]


Surveillance Security – An Important Investment For Your Safety | Buy Home Security Cam
Pingback posted April 7, 2010 @ 11:59 pm

[...] The National Security Case Against Killing Anwar al-Awlaki « The … [...]


Credigy Receivables and Steve Stewart | How I can protect my assets, including retirement / home / Cash & Miscellaneous, against any kind of action?
Pingback posted April 8, 2010 @ 1:58 am

[...] The National Security Case Against Killing Anwar al-Awlaki « The … [...]


Kool-it Regalla Refrig Deli and Bakery Case – 72 Inches Long | eastwestbakery.com
Pingback posted April 8, 2010 @ 2:03 am

[...] The National Security Case Against Killing Anwar al-Awlaki « The … [...]


VOA83
Comment posted April 8, 2010 @ 1:19 am

I could not agree more with the notion that a captured bad guy is better than a dead bad guy (Abdul Qayum Zakir being a notable exception). However, a comment I left on your previous article rings true here as well: how would you or your above-mentioned-friends propose we gain control of A-A? Yemeni authorities are an unreliable and unlikely route. The thought of risking US troops' lives in an effort to extract this guy makes me sick, and would be an affront to the fragile relationship we share with the Yemenis. Putting him on trial is overly idealist, capturing him isn't much better.


SKB-4812WS ATA 2SKB Standard Travel Golf Case | golfbagaccessories.net
Pingback posted April 8, 2010 @ 2:45 am

[...] The National Security Case Against Killing Anwar al-Awlaki « The … [...]


Credigy Receivables and Steve Stewart | A question rather judgments against me?
Pingback posted April 8, 2010 @ 4:01 am

[...] The National Security Case Against Killing Anwar al-Awlaki « The … [...]


Ibanez Rgd320 Mgs Electric Guitar New W/case Option | Electric Guitar Sales
Pingback posted April 8, 2010 @ 4:17 am

[...] The National Security Case Against Killing Anwar al-Awlaki « The Washington Independent [...]


A Credit Report After Bankruptcy | taxbankruptcy | Credit Finance Wisdom
Pingback posted April 8, 2010 @ 7:00 am

[...] The National Security Case Against Killing Anwar al-Awlaki « The … [...]


The reason why we have chosen a tour to Italy travel « Italy … | Italy Traveling
Pingback posted April 8, 2010 @ 7:32 am

[...] The National Security Case Against Killing Anwar al-Awlaki « The … [...]


What type of gun might a fictional female criminal carry in her handbag? :Apparel Outlet USA
Pingback posted April 8, 2010 @ 8:00 am

[...] The National Security Case Against Killing Anwar al-Awlaki « The … [...]


Salvation Army reacts to news in Wise case | Comprehensive News listings, Reviews and Articles
Pingback posted April 8, 2010 @ 10:11 am

[...] The National Security Case Against Killing Anwar al-Awlaki « The … [...]


New Jersey Nets showing off their defense against the Grizzlies | New Jersey Nets NBA Announcer
Pingback posted April 8, 2010 @ 1:41 pm

[...] The National Security Case Against Killing Anwar al-Awlaki « The … [...]


N. Korea 10 years late with software system | Comprehensive Software listings, Reviews and Articles
Pingback posted April 8, 2010 @ 2:09 pm

[...] The National Security Case Against Killing Anwar al-Awlaki « The … [...]


Are Those Online Payday Loans Secure and Discreet? | eduonlineloan
Pingback posted April 8, 2010 @ 2:21 pm

[...] The National Security Case Against Killing Anwar al-Awlaki « The … [...]


My son is in default for student loan, how will this affect Stimulas Check? | Student Loans Repayment
Pingback posted April 8, 2010 @ 2:52 pm

[...] The National Security Case Against Killing Anwar al-Awlaki « The … [...]


The CIA Now Has White House Permission To Kill U.S. Citizens « Read NEWS
Pingback posted April 8, 2010 @ 4:13 pm

[...] News editorialIncomplete Picture on Justification for Killing American Citizen – The AtlanticThe National Security Case Against Killing Anwar al-Awlaki – Washington [...]


78 in Curved Glass Refrig Bakery Case, Glass Ends, Glass Slide Rear Drs | eastwestbakery.com
Pingback posted April 8, 2010 @ 8:14 pm

[...] The National Security Case Against Killing Anwar al-Awlaki « The … [...]


The Advantage of Having a Student Credit Card
Pingback posted April 9, 2010 @ 1:23 am

[...] The National Security Case Against Killing Anwar al-Awlaki « The … [...]


4 month old baby_babies 5 months_4 months babies » Newborn!!!?
Pingback posted April 9, 2010 @ 3:33 am

[...] The National Security Case Against Killing Anwar al-Awlaki « The … [...]


4 month old baby_babies 5 months_4 months babies » Oregon jury gets Boy Scouts sex abuse case
Pingback posted April 9, 2010 @ 4:18 am

[...] The National Security Case Against Killing Anwar al-Awlaki « The … [...]


Smooth engraved nickel cigarette case with Galat e | STOP SMOKING METHODS
Pingback posted April 9, 2010 @ 4:22 am

[...] The National Security Case Against Killing Anwar al-Awlaki « The … [...]


The Importance Of Worldwide Travel Insurance
Pingback posted April 9, 2010 @ 5:05 am

[...] The National Security Case Against Killing Anwar al-Awlaki « The … [...]


iPad Security Case « Specs, Reviews and Prices – MobileWhack.com | The Apple Ipad Blog
Pingback posted April 9, 2010 @ 7:15 am

[...] The National Security Case Against Killing Anwar al-Awlaki « The Washington Independent [...]


1 month baby_1 month pregnant_xbox live 1 month » Newborn!!!?
Pingback posted April 9, 2010 @ 9:22 am

[...] The National Security Case Against Killing Anwar al-Awlaki « The … [...]


License to Kill, Part II « APMnews
Pingback posted April 15, 2010 @ 5:35 pm

[...] Wright and Karen Greenberg have related takes on why it’s a bad idea, on national security grounds, to target [...]


License to Kill, Part II « apm35
Pingback posted April 15, 2010 @ 5:36 pm

[...] Wright and Karen Greenberg have related takes on why it’s a bad idea, on national security grounds, to target [...]


Unsecured Unemployed Personal Loans: Get Free From Tangles of … | Loans Finance Wisdom
Pingback posted April 25, 2010 @ 12:34 am

[...] The National Security Case Against Killing Anwar al-Awlaki « The … [...]


1500 Discount 2001 Volvo S40, K15 K1500 Pickup Exhaust Used Gmc Wiring Harness - 11.codebluehacks.org
Pingback posted May 23, 2010 @ 12:23 am

[...] 12345678910111213141516171819202122232425262728293031323334353637383940414243444546474849505152535455565758596061621500 Discount 2001 Volvo S40, K15 K1500 Pickup Exhaust Used Gmc Wiring Harness – 11.codebluehacks.org1500 Discount 2001 Volvo S40, K15 K1500 Pickup Exhaust Used Gmc Wiring Harnessaftermarket ford f150 chevrolet avalanche 2500 b150 ram 1500 dodge stratus auto parts gmc c13 c1500 pickup aftermarket bumper guard v1500 product reviews 7.1 channel silverado 1500 hd sale nissan versa silver birch metallic ram sale pontiac k15 k1500 pickup 1500 watts rms kawaii15 k1500 pickup part s15 jimmy sierra denali 2005 f150 mileage specs 2007 chevrolet silverado 1500 xm installation f 150 1500 work truck 2008 chevrolet silverado 2wd v1500 pft order d150 taillight bulb holder 1500 discount 2001 volvo s40 2006 ford f 150 5.4 l v8 horsepower pickup trucks p1500 factory problems lousy 1500 hd headlight fog gmc sierra third brake light p51 p1500 van aftermarket automatic our silverado 1500 hd crewmax 1995 chevrolet suburban k1500 suv 2006 dodge ram 1500 check engine light fuse c10 suburban discount s10 blazer c1500 second hand gmc p51 k1500 pickup f 150 ford parts b1500 models auto parts 150 price 2004 ford p15 p1500 van aftermarket free model pd150 parts way 11.1 v 1500mah 25c discount sony w150 np fg1 dsc w70 k24 k2500 1500 sale 1500 engine brake mean effective pressure 99 f150 heater core replacement e 150 econoline pt e85 fuel xl $1500 used yukon 2003 gmc envoy 1500 gmc sierra hd yukon xl auto parts kelso b150 difference between xl 1500 2500 used gmc yukon promotion gmc feather finish k1500 pickup gmc k15 c1500 suburban replacement 3rd row seat 1505 wireless n card xpress 1150 treiber p1500 draw 9v 1500ma adapter switching power supply k1500 urban old crf 150 aftermarket parts 1500 parts 2002 chevrolet suburban shock absorber delivery gmc c15 c1500 suburban sierra 1500 hd half k 2000 dodge ram 1500 headlights ford e 150 boiler btu sony dsc w150 review jpg 150 radiator used ford e galaxie 500 h1500 radiator 66mm pipe centre d150 part locate new dodge ram 2500 c35 c3500 1500 location part gmc k14 k1500 pickup ton chevrolet g15 g1500 van auto parts 1500 sale 2006 gmc sierra chevrolet silverado compact disc player p15 p1500 honda odyssey 150 watt tungsten bulb 2007 1500 specs 2009 gmc sierra 2000 gmc yukon xl 1500 5.3 l specs k10 pickup headlight direct fit silverado 1500 sierra 1500 hd download features d150 sound acer crystal eye 150 turbo havana 1500 headlight intermittent wipers k15 k1500 pickup hid gmc sierra beam 1500 watt kicker amp k15 k1500 pickup design s15 jimmy discount ram 2500 brake rotors dodge b150 k1500 price chevrolet 1500 fog light headlight assembly gmc sierra hd dodge b1500 aftermarket truck parts cold air intake dodge b1500 replacement bumper 1500 hd car parts 2002 gmc sierra window regulator 1500 buy 2002 chevrolet avalanche v1500 performance hypertech buy tail light chevrolet k15 k1500 pickup promotion gem electronics pb 150 c35 commercial 1500 1500 headlight silverado 1500 road armor chevy avalanche light bulb e26 d150 ww aftermarket gmc k15 k1500 suburban salvage yards e 150 locost k25 k1500 pickup truck parts air conditioner condenser 1500 part listings sovana b1500 discount mx 6 dodge ram gmc sierra 1500 denali grille towing capacity b150 fluid fuel injector truck headlight toyota p15 p1500 van radiator mitsubishi hc1500 1500 cars sale nj sankyo c150 2006 ford f150 driver side sun 2001 performance parts ford f150 d150 chevy dodge colt dodge w150 pickup part mercury merkur Used Eagle Premier | 2007 Mercury Montego | 1996 Lexus Es300 | S550 Sell 2010 | Lw300 Promo Headlight | [...]


Glory Hid Spiritual Life, Spirit Games Online - 445.tgrconversions.com
Pingback posted May 23, 2010 @ 7:23 am

[...] 12345678910111213141516171819202122232425262728293031323334353637383940414243444546474849505152535455565758596061626364656667686970717273747576777879808182838485868788899091Glory Hid Spiritual Life, Spirit Games Online – 445.tgrconversions.comGlory Hid Spiritual Life, Spirit Games Onlinebuy dodge spirit brake pads ebc spirit video school spirit quotes spirit tucson az troxel spirit schooling helmet honda shadow spirit parts prices buy dodge spirit plymouth reliant spirit airlines bankruptcy spirit teaser trailer dodge spirit thermostat 2009 honda shadow spirit 750 price dodge spirit aftermarket car truck weber spirit kr 320 lp spirit yachts for sale dodge royal mini ram parts shadow spirit grand voyager dodge spirit rt wheels dodge spirit parts floor mats fog light wind spirit medicine leona lewis spirit font odyssey legendary spirit sorcerer fu 2007 honda shadow spirit price spirit body kit front bumper spirit wiki american spirit review weber spirit manual genesis silver c school spirit kanye spirit halloween free shipping coupon dodge spirit discount disc brakes grand caravan bso spirit hans zimmer spirit software spirit seat replacement headlight assembly spirit lake cognac hennessy spirits dodge spirit accessories brake pads holy spirit overland park spirit horse farm spirit xbr25 used spirit adoption abba father shadow spirit ikea free shadow spirit honda vtx 1800f spirit wild mustang spirit monarch 25 37 fcr cb300 review locator shadow spirit spirit hid used dodge spirit led dodge spirit photos spirit headlight dakota durango tail light 1991 dodge spirit repair front wheel drive 1993 dodge spirit repair manual garments of spirituality quest spirit e 320 sell used shadow spirit dodge aries custom wheels for honda shadow spirit 750 spirit group dodge spirit replacement headlight assembly chrysler lebaron 1991 dodge spirit for sale spirit halloween atlanta spirit bag spirit of 76 parade thunder episode fighting spirit dodge neon dodge spirit aries used shadow spirit grand caravan dodge spirit ffv unleaded gasoline chrysler saratoga service manual dodge spirit spirit radiator car steering rack weber spirit e320 natural gas grill 1100 shadow spirit sissy bar engine honda shadow spirit spirit body kit nissan 350z weber spirit premium genesis e 320 chrysler 300 discount dodge spirit weber gasgrill spirit e320 liquid propane gas honda shadow spirit 750 motorcycle chrysler saratoga used pt cruiser dodge spirit fury life in the spirit 1995 dodge spirit complaints used spirit weber spirit ep 310 review headlight aftermarket dodge spirit weber spirit 210 grill easy spirit men spirit stallion cimarron film spirit of santa fe spirit animals rabbit dodge spirit r t lumina z34 custom spirit flags sale steinberger spirit gu deluxe spirit wind casino spirit e 320 cheap runaway auction spirit of youth 2007 honda shadow spirit exhaust spirit change spiritual restoration 1992 dodge spirit for sale srt 4 spirit cheap online weber spirit 320 natural gas char broil acclaim headlight buy 1995 dodge spirit dark shadow spirit spirit wholesale cost 750 honda shadow spirit transmission E 250 Econoline | J2000 Seamonkey Headlight | Saturn Relay 1 | Looking For Discount | 1991 Mercury Convertible | [...]


250cc Ford E Accessories, Find 250c Ls 600h - 84.cmanager.org
Pingback posted May 24, 2010 @ 8:22 am

[...] 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930313233343536373839404142434445464748495051525354555657585960616263646566676869707172737475767778798081828384858687250cc Ford E Accessories, Find 250c Ls 600h – 84.cmanager.org250cc Ford E Accessories, Find 250c Ls 600h250c headlight mercedesbenzfinancial 250c replacement brake pad 250cc buy kodak hp designjet 250c lexus is250c msrp iway 250c updates iway 250c sd mmc memory card portable gps stx 250c contractor conversion engine wholesale 250cc 250c dodge 250c comparison 250c radiator pelican parts 250c used bmw 750li is250c price convertible 250c led aftermarket 250cc ninja 250c dealers local lexus bl fu250c optoma replacement lamp for ep758 ep751 250c parts available wiper blade 250c anatomy iway 250c car charger iway 250c leather case mercedesbenz 250c replacement brake pad slk32 amg hp 9250c 250c radiator autohaus az quality vw 250cc truck radiators 250c part mercedes benz 280 1971 mercedes 250c buy 250c companies 250c version 1988 dodge ram 250cc parts conditional 250cc discount sl500 radiator 250cc 250c auto parts brake pads mercedes 250c sale color maroon cougar parts 250cc atv 110cc dirt bike 250c sale convertible bl fu250c lamp benq projector brother mfc 250c review 250c mercedes w114 250cc part 2004 chevrolet avalanche features lowrance iway 250c 250c replacement price bl fu250c projector lamp part 250c hood 250c zone way 250ce socket 250cc sale cheap ssr 250cc 125cc pit bike xerox brother mfc 250c ink cartridges 250c cooling system autohaus az suzuki gt 250cc bulb 250c replacement lcd dodge 250cc 250c 2010 lexus is lx 570 250c full episodes iway 250c car charger magellan maestro car lexus is 250c hp designjet 250c repair 250c repair models 250c cheap cars for sale 250c headlight discount c43 amg 250c sale gs 450h ls 600h 250c removal full spectrum fluorescent lighting mercedes 250c parts kodak 250c inkjet cartridges 250c cars for sale 2010 lexus is MercedesBenz 250C part 250c 2nd hand gs 450h 250cc head light bulb 250c exhaust catalog 250c used 240d mercedes benz diesel 250cc fahrenheit used 250c cars 250c coupon tiger gps 250c aftermarket for sale hewlett packard designjet 250c used mercedes benz 250c rear axle 250c promotion under iway 250c review lexus 250c model 250c bulb mercedes benz fuel pump cheap brother mfc 250c lowrance iway 250c gps 250c headlight tail light 250c automotive buy pathfinder big 250cc mopeds savana 250cc rear wheel drive 250ce replacement accessories mercedes benz 250c parts brake master cylinder fuel tank cap 1971 mercedes benz 250c guide find new lexus is 250c 250cc ford e parts fuel injector 250c used mercedes benz 240d shock absorber 250c radiator discount mercedes iway 250c update automotive gps 250c discount auto parts mercedes benz 500sl buy 250cc trike scooter 250c specs low tire pressure replacement quantity brother mfc 250c ink Glf Bulb Osram | Buy Gmc R8 | Lexus Gs400 Part | 1500 Part Datsun | Radiator Transmission Oil | [...]


electronic cigarette review
Comment posted February 2, 2011 @ 6:17 pm

All these guys need to learn a lesson when we get rid of one. This country is way to politically correct! They do not deserve a trial!


RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.