Conservative Media Mogul Plays Defense on Racism Story

By
Friday, February 05, 2010 at 11:00 am
James O'Keefe and Andrew Breitbart (YouTube, ZUMApress.com)

James O'Keefe and Andrew Breitbart (YouTube, ZUMApress.com)

On Wednesday morning, Salon.com published “James O’Keefe’s Race Problem,” an article by author Max Blumenthal that dug into the past of the 25-year-old activist whose hidden camera sting of ACORN offices devastated the community organizing group. Blumenthal described O’Keefe’s career as “a series of political stunts shot through with racial resentment” and honed in an August 30, 2006 “race and conservatism” forum in Arlington, Va. The guests were African-American conservative activist Kevin Martin, National Review writer John Derbyshire, and white nationalist magazine editor Jared Taylor. According to Blumenthal, O’Keefe had helped “plan” the event with a fellow employee of the conservative Leadership Institute. The main piece of evidence: a cropped headshot of O’Keefe from the event and an account from the photographer, an investigator from the anti-racism group the One People’s Project.

[GOP1] The article trafficked around the web at a moderate pace. Because I attended the event, I wrote about it, and the Blumenthal story, here. Soon, other websites grabbed onto the story and added unsupportable spin. Little Green Footballs, whose editor Charles Johnson has made a splashy departure from the right, linked to the revelation about what he called a “white nationalist conference.” Alex Pareene of Gawker wrote that “James O’Keefe pals around with white supremacists,” a winking reference to an attack Sarah Palin made on Barack Obama during the 2008 campaign. Steven Thrasher of the Village Voice wrote that O’Keefe “organized a speaking forum for white supremacists.” Like Blumenthal, they linked the story to Andrew Breitbart, the conservative journalism mogul who ran O’Keefe’s ACORN tapes at his Big Government web site and who subsequently paid the activist for his “life rights” — and who had just finished getting MSNBC and other media outlets to back off on accusing O’Keefe of “wiretapping” the New Orleans office of Sen. Mary Landrieu (D-La.), while lawyers and O’Keefe claimed he had only attempted to see if the phones were being tampered with.

Seven hours after the Salon story went up, Breitbart went to war. On his Twitter account, he wrote that “Salon, Max Blumenthal, Gawker, Village Voice (usual smear artists) [were] lying through teeth over James O’Keefe.” Larry O’Connor, a colleague from Big Government, called the One People’s Project and demanded more proof that O’Keefe had done what it and Blumenthal had claimed — that he hadn’t merely shown up, but that he’d organized the event and manned a table of racist literature. They called me for details, explaining that O’Keefe had acknowledged he was at the debate but insisted he was not involved with the planning. Afterward, Breitbart went back to Twitter to announce — correctly — that I’d confirmed that the “manning the table” charge was a “LIE.” Another week of Breitbart defending his reporter — and getting news organizations to retract parts of their stories — had commenced, with Blumenthal as the chief target. One Breitbart ally told TWI that his team was “suiting up for full war on this intellectually dishonest punk.”

By every indication, Breitbart’s full court press against the story — and the quick work he did debunking a key detail — has helped keep it out of the headlines. That pushback, coming in the wake of the Landrieu story, is a role reversal for Breitbart’s media network. The 40-year old mogul has won accolades from across the conservative movement for the aggressive reporting and media criticism engineered by his Big sites: Big Hollywood, Big Government, and Big Journalism. The impact of the ACORN tapes — which O’Keefe recorded on his own, before delivering the story to Big Government — was such that The New York Times and other mainstream media outlets were forced to explain why they hadn’t done similar investigations. On Friday night, Breitbart will introduce a film at the National Tea Party Convention.

Since that explosive 2009 ACORN story, Breitbart’s web sites have often kept unions and Obama administration officials on their heels. Big Government ran multiple stories about the activist past of Kevin Jennings, the founder of the gay, lesbian and transgender rights group GLSEN who joined Barack Obama’s administration as the “safe schools czar.” Big Government uncovered old brochures from Jenning’s group and linked the man himself to sex scandals. Sites like Media Matters — part of what Breitbart calls the “Democrat Media Complex” — invested time and resources into disproving facts in those stories and taking the air out of them. When O’Keefe became the focus of new media attention for the Landrieu debacle and the “race and conservatism” story, Breitbart was put into the same position, relentlessly demanding that media outlets retract unsupported allegations, and turning the narrative from what his employee was accused of to how the media had slanted and bungled the story.

“This is a monumentally hurtful, libelous, hurtful hit piece,” Breitbart told TWI. “There is no basis for any journalism here.”

Breitbart’s efforts to defuse the Salon story were met with some success. Interviewed by TWI, two of the key players in the story said that the most damaging parts of the original piece — that O’Keefe had organized the event, and that he’d helped peddle racist tracts — were unsupportable. Marcus Epstein, the controversial conservative activist who ran the Robert Taft Club — the conservative group that planned the event — told TWI that O’Keefe “did not collaborate” in putting it together.

Isis, the photographer who attended the event for the One People’s Project — she uses a pseudonym, she said, to protect herself from blowback from extremist groups — told TWI that her original characterization of O’Keefe’s involvement, cited by Salon, was not true.

“I don’t believe O’Keefe planned the event,” said Isis. “What I believe is that O’Keefe was there as a compatriot of Epstein’s and was sort of helping out with the event, sort of like when you go to a friend’s party and you decide to help them out.”

Epstein and Isis disagreed about whether O’Keefe had manned a table of racist literature — Epstein said he didn’t, while Isis said he did. She provided Blumenthal with a photo of the table, with copies of American Renaissance magazine (headlines included “The Genetics of Race” and “Black Racist Consciousness, Part I”) splayed across it. On Thursday, Blumenthal stuck by the story.

“O’Keefe admitted that he was there,” Blumenthal told TWI. “He has had a career marked by racial obsession, and this highlights that dimension of his career. Breitbart, who pays O’Keefe, has been exposed. Is anyone surprised that he’d freak out and muddy the water without facts?”

When the Landrieu story broke, Rep. Pete Olson (R-Texas) — who’s sponsored a congressional resolution honoring O’Keefe for the ACORN story — told TWI that “if recent events conclude that any laws were broken in the incident in Senator Landrieu’s office, that is not something I condone.” Asked for comment on the “race and conservatism” story, neither Olson nor the offices of other Republican congressmen who sponsored the resolution responded. And while a Pew study found that MSNBC spent fully 12 percent of its broadcast time covering the story of O’Keefe’s botched investigation of Landrieu during the week that the news broke, the network has barely touched the “race and conservatism” story. Reached by TWI, several liberal and conservative bloggers who had covered the Landrieu story said that doubts about the details of the Salon story — such as the headshot of O’Keefe that Salon pasted onto a cartoon body — kept them off the trail.

“That article claimed in its subhead to have photographic proof,” said Ed Morrissey of HotAir.com, “and then used an obviously Photoshopped image beneath it. I’m curious as to why that didn’t raise more red flags.”

For Breitbart, the pushback was personal. He has explained in the past that Democratic attacks against then-Supreme Court nominee Clarence Thomas were the spark that made him a conservative. When Sen. Ted Kennedy (D-Mass.) died, Breitbart unleashed a stream of tweets attacking him for what he said about Thomas. “Doing to the reputations of Clarence Thomas and Robert Bork what he did to [Chappaquiddick victim Mary Jo] Kopechne,” wrote Breitbart in The Washington Times, “only reinforced his value to the Democrat Media Complex as the memory of his brothers’ more authentic Camelot began to fade.”

On Thursday night, with the doubts about the latest O’Keefe story apparently killing its traction in other media, Breitbart started to have more fun. When the Landrieu story broke, Big Journalism introduced a “senior editor” named Retracto, the Correction Alpaca, a pseudononymous poster who matter-of-factly asked for retractions from organizations that accused O’Keefe of “wiretapping.” In an on-air interview, Breitbart got MSNBC’s David Shuster to retract the charge. And after another day of battling back on the Salon story, Breitbart warned web sites that had mentioned Salon’s story — like The Daily Beast — that the alpaca was making a comeback.

“Tina Brown,” wrote Breitbart, “Retracto is walking down the hillside…”

Follow David Weigel on Twitter


Comments

45 Comments

uberVU - social comments
Trackback posted February 5, 2010 @ 1:25 pm

Social comments and analytics for this post…

This post was mentioned on Twitter by TMCMemberFeed: Wash. Independent: Conservative Media Mogul Plays Defense on Racism Story: Media accounts by Salon.com and other o… http://bit.ly/c0AlBj...


Good Lt
Comment posted February 5, 2010 @ 1:28 pm

Retracto the Correction Alpaca is a “Senior Fellow at Brietbart.com,” not a “Senior Editor.”

A la Media Matters “Senior Fellows.”

Details.


chrisjay
Comment posted February 5, 2010 @ 2:33 pm

title should have been:

“When Smear Artists Get Smeared”


24AheadDotCom
Comment posted February 5, 2010 @ 3:07 pm

Maybe Weigel can find out whether it was my tweet that caused Breitbart to reverse course on O'Keefe; after the story first broke he couldn't run away from him fast enough but I believe I was the first to point out that the affidavit didn't say anything about a “wiretap”. That's not so much self-aggrandizement (OK, it's that) as much as me pointing out just how lame everyone else is.

Also, maybe Weigel could ask Max Blumenthal about his bigoted comments about Mormons and Gentiles.


Make The Pie Higher
Comment posted February 5, 2010 @ 3:24 pm

“ask Max Blumenthal about his bigoted comments about Mormons and Gentiles.”

Because everyone knows that makes bigotry from anyone else justifiable. Straw idiot.


24AheadDotCom
Comment posted February 5, 2010 @ 4:19 pm

Now, everyone should read the Max link in my comment below, noting that I already covered the issue that “Make The Pie Higher” raises in the last paragraph of my post. You can't trust sockpuppets around here to read or to understand; ignore them.


Washington Capitals Women’s 3/4 Sleeve Raglan Top – by Alyssa Milano – Small | Washington Capitals NHL Announcer
Pingback posted February 5, 2010 @ 4:55 pm

[...] Conservative Media Mogul Plays Defense on Racism Story « The … [...]


» Retraction Requests: Charles Johnson, Little Green Footballs - Big Journalism
Pingback posted February 5, 2010 @ 5:52 pm

[...] earlier in the post, Mr. Johnson declares that it was incorrect for Dan Weigel to attribute the phrase “white nationalist conference” to [...]


sus
Comment posted February 6, 2010 @ 12:43 am

“I don’t believe O’Keefe planned the event,” said Isis. “What I believe is that O’Keefe was there as a compatriot of Epstein’s and was sort of helping out with the event, sort of like when you go to a friend’s party and you decide to help them out.”

Epstein and Isis disagreed about whether O’Keefe had manned a table of racist literature — Epstein said he didn’t, while Isis said he did. She provided Blumenthal with a photo of the table, with copies of American Renaissance magazine (headlines included “The Genetics of Race” and “Black Racist Consciousness, Part I”) splayed across it. On Thursday, Blumenthal stuck by the story.”

=================
Why is that OK? According to the photographer, he was manning the table.

Why is Epstein's word better than the photographer? He has a history of racism and lying.


Little Chucky Johnson shits the bed (again) « docweaselblog
Pingback posted February 6, 2010 @ 1:19 am

[...] earlier in the post, Mr. Johnson declares that it was incorrect for Dan Weigel to attribute the phrase “white nationalist conference” to [...]


donanon
Comment posted February 6, 2010 @ 4:56 am

Probably because 1) the photo of O'Keefe is cropped to the point where someone could claim he was at a Black Panther rally 2) the only other known witness (Weigel) says O'Keefe wasn't manning the table 3) the African-American panelist at the event remembers O'Keefe supporting him and that O'Keefe “also repudiated the radical elements in the room that night”.

So it isn't Epstein's word against the photographer's. It's Epstein, two other people, and the photographer's evidence is edited and later photoshopped by Salon.


Conservative Media Mogul Plays Defense on Racism Story « The … | Drakz Free Online Service
Pingback posted February 6, 2010 @ 7:48 am

[...] more: Conservative Media Mogul Plays Defense on Racism Story « The … Share and [...]


hello01589
Comment posted February 6, 2010 @ 9:14 am

Welcome to our website: http://www.wowhotsale.com
The website wholesale for many kinds of fashion shoes, like the nike,jordan,prada,adidas, also including the jeans,shirts,bags,hat and the decorations. All the products are free shipping, and the the price is competitive, and also can accept paypal payment.,after the payment, can ship within short time.

free shipping
competitive price
any size available
We do wholesale and retail! All are extremely CHEAP, please visit: http://www.wowhotsale.com
jbgmsx


phastphil
Comment posted February 6, 2010 @ 11:25 am

“Strong and bitter words indicate a weak cause.” -Victor Hugo


Chsh Holds Successful Media Event to Promote Own Brands | Promotional Media Marketing Wisdom
Pingback posted February 6, 2010 @ 12:13 pm

[...] Conservative Media Mogul Plays Defense on Racism Story « The … [...]


Allswell
Comment posted February 6, 2010 @ 12:41 pm

“People who quote others instead of using their own words don't know what they are talking about” – ME


phastphil
Comment posted February 6, 2010 @ 1:40 pm

It's called not reinventing the wheel – get a clue!


todd_mn
Comment posted February 6, 2010 @ 3:33 pm

So, how much does O'Keefe really know about modern multi-line telecommunications systems? Sure, he knows how to dress up like a telephone maintenance technician, but is he really capable of diagnosing a complex system in the “peoples' office”?

Of course, “some people” have told me about e-mails not reaching some Republican Congresspeople, so I will have to examine all of the computers in the “people's office”. Obviously, I won't install spyware or pry into personal information, because I am an investigative journalist and that would be beneath me. I just have a deep concern for those poor anonymous people who can't reach their elected representatives by e-mail. If I ruin a few computers because I don't have a clue what I'm doing, well, they are the “people's” computers, after all. No harm done, really.

I'm sure that Republican Senators will be happy to give me the keys to their cars – the people's cars – so that I can examine the brake and fuel lines. Now, I'm no mechanic, but something tells me there's a story just waiting to be brought into the daylight. And “some people” have told me some very compelling stories that I can't really disclose at this time, so I can't just pass on this.

If you buy O'Keefe's bogus story, why wouldn't you buy mine?


Wonk Room » As GOP Leadership Backs Away, Conservatives Throw … | Management Business Wisdom
Pingback posted February 6, 2010 @ 4:45 pm

[...] Conservative Media Mogul Plays Defense on Racism Story « The … [...]


CENSORED NEWS: Indigenous Elders Singled Out for New Border … | Educational Nevada
Pingback posted February 6, 2010 @ 6:12 pm

[...] Conservative Media Mogul Plays Defense on Racism Story « The … [...]


Tracy
Comment posted February 6, 2010 @ 6:16 pm

Or maybe he'll consider the source and just laugh.


Make The Pie Higher
Comment posted February 6, 2010 @ 7:29 pm

The link to your site?

You're a leech and an idiot.


Washington Capitals Majestic Athletic Red Tek Patch Hooded Sweatshirt – X-Large | Washington Capitals NHL Announcer
Pingback posted February 7, 2010 @ 3:12 am

[...] Conservative Media Mogul Plays Defense on Racism Story « The … [...]


Conservative Media Mogul Plays Defense on Racism Story
Pingback posted February 7, 2010 @ 7:06 am

[...] The article trafficked around the web at a moderate pace. Because I attended the event, I wrote about it, and the Blumenthal story, here. Soon, other websites grabbed onto the story and added unsupportable spin. Little Green Footballs, whose editor Charles Johnson has made a splashy departure from the right, linked to the revelation about what he called a “white nationalist conference.” Alex Pareene of Gawker wrote that “James O’Keefe pals around with white supremacists,” a winking reference to an attack Sarah Palin made on Barack Obama during the 2008 campaign. Steven Thrasher of the Village Voice wrote that O’Keefe “organized a speaking forum for white supremacists.” Like Blumenthal, they linked the story to Andrew Breitbart, the conservative journalism mogul who ran O’Keefe’s ACORN tapes at his Big Government web site and who subsequently paid the activist for his “life rights” — and who had just finished getting MSNBC and other media outlets to back off on accusing O’Keefe of “wiretapping” the New Orleans office of Sen. Mary Landrieu (D-La.), while lawyers and O’Keefe claimed he had only attempted to see if the phones were being tampered with. (more) [...]


Washington Wizards | Washington Wizards NBA Announcer
Pingback posted February 7, 2010 @ 8:11 am

[...] Conservative Media Mogul Plays Defense on Racism Story « The … [...]


Jack Thompson
Comment posted February 7, 2010 @ 1:10 pm

That was a very fuzzy piece of journalism leaving us with no firm conclusions. When you media assholes go after each other it is even worse than the daily dung of politicians. Don't waste my time.


cat007
Comment posted February 7, 2010 @ 8:12 pm

Breitbart is a punk of the first order. He and Matt Drudge need to get a life.


chrisjay
Comment posted February 7, 2010 @ 11:00 pm

“Why do you necessarily have to be wrong just because a few million people think you are?”
—-Frank Zappa


chrisjay
Comment posted February 7, 2010 @ 11:02 pm

I think all that fuzz is from your navel and from between your toes


Cincinnatus
Comment posted February 9, 2010 @ 9:26 am

Is a hard hat and tool belt enough place wiretaps? That was all that was on his person. Or can he cut and splice with the powers of his mind? If O'Keefe has Keanu-Reeves-like-powers, then I understand why picking up the phone and pushing the push pad is called “manipulating the phone”.

While we're at it, we should put O'Keefe in jail for the sake of those poor unfortunate underage girls from El Salvador.


chrisjay
Comment posted February 9, 2010 @ 2:23 pm

Or for the underage slave-labor/sex-slaves Delay pimped for in the Marianas Islands…


Fun Facts About Alpacas
Pingback posted February 11, 2010 @ 12:12 am

[...] [...]


ludaasdfadsfdafdafdf
Comment posted February 11, 2010 @ 3:59 pm

asdfada


ludaasdfadsfdafdafdf
Comment posted February 11, 2010 @ 4:00 pm

jvf


ludaasdfadsfdafdafdf
Comment posted February 11, 2010 @ 4:07 pm

adfaagdg


ludaasdfadsfdafdafdf
Comment posted February 11, 2010 @ 4:07 pm

adfaagdg


trippin
Comment posted February 12, 2010 @ 4:32 pm

And don't forget that Limbaugh was caught returning the Dominican Republic, a vacation spot famed for its underaged prostitutes, and was caught with a large quantity of illegal Viagra in his luggage. Now that doesn't mean he was playing the role of plantation owner, now, does it? Of course not! He just really, really, REALLY likes to masturbate, I suppose.


trippin
Comment posted February 12, 2010 @ 9:32 pm

And don't forget that Limbaugh was caught returning the Dominican Republic, a vacation spot famed for its underaged prostitutes, and was caught with a large quantity of illegal Viagra in his luggage. Now that doesn't mean he was playing the role of plantation owner, now, does it? Of course not! He just really, really, REALLY likes to masturbate, I suppose.


adidas outlet
Comment posted June 5, 2010 @ 1:10 am

Thanks for this interesting post,i like it.


Little Chucky Johnson shits the bed (again)
Pingback posted December 24, 2010 @ 10:25 pm

[...] earlier in the post, Mr. Johnson declares that it was incorrect for Dan Weigel to attribute the phrase “white nationalist conference” to [...]


Media plays | AdventureLeap
Pingback posted March 12, 2011 @ 1:30 pm

[...] Conservative Media Mogul Plays Defense on Racism Story « TheThat pushback, coming in the wake of the Landrieu story, is a role reversal for Breitbart’s media network. The 40-year old mogul has won accolades from across the conservative movement for the aggressive reporting and media criticism engineered by his Big sites: Big Hollywood, Big Government, and Big Journalism. [...]


lacoste outlet online
Comment posted May 8, 2011 @ 6:29 pm

If I ruin a few computers because I don’t have a clue what I’m doing,
well, they are the “people’s” computers, after all. No harm done,
really.


NY Residential cleaning service
Comment posted September 6, 2011 @ 8:30 pm

Do you mind if I quote a few of your posts as long as I provide credit and sources back to your webpage? My blog is in the very same area of interest as yours and my users would truly benefit from a lot of the information you provide here. Please let me know if this okay with you. Many thanks!


how to cook steak
Comment posted September 7, 2011 @ 5:13 am

Oh so WonderFul!!! Me Go Me Go Goood!


2147150
Comment posted September 7, 2011 @ 12:44 pm

2147150 beers on the wall. sck was here


RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.