rssFormer Bush DOJer ‘Not Opposed’ to Criminal Investigation
Wednesday, November 04, 2009 at 6:00 am
- 28 Comments
Illustration by: Matt Mahurin
Speaking on the subject for the first time on Tuesday, a former head of the Office of Legal Counsel under President George W. Bush announced that he was not opposed to a criminal investigation of his conduct and the work of his colleagues.
Daniel Levin was acting assistant attorney general in charge of the Office of Legal Counsel after Harvard Law Professor Jack Goldsmith resigned from the post. Although Goldsmith had withdrawn some of the most controversial memos issued by the OLC, the arm of the Justice Department that directly advises the president, many controversial opinions approving extreme interrogation techniques such as waterboarding, stress positions, prolonged sleep and food deprivation, sexual humiliation and confinement in a cramped box with insects remained in effect or were issued again later to justify ongoing CIA or defense department practices. Levin was in charge of the office from 2004 – 2005, just before Steven Bradbury took over in June 2005. Levin is now a partner at the law firm of White & Case.
[Law1]“I personally am not opposed to criminal investigation of my conduct and others during the period in question,” Levin said yesterday at a conference at American University’s Washington College of Law. The conference, titled “The Torture Memos: Lawyers, Ethics and the Rule of Law,” addressed the ethical responsibilities of OLC lawyers during the Bush administration, and whether and how they should be held accountable for authorizing abusive interrogations of detainees in U.S. custody. “Any government employee is appropriately subject to investigation of their conduct while they’re serving in government,” said Levin.
Beginning in 2002, the Office of Legal Counsel issued memos justifying a wide range of extreme interrogation tactics on detainees. Among the most controversial is the one written by John Yoo on August 1, 2002 that defined torture so narrowly as to include only acts that inflict “severe pain or suffering” equivalent to the pain accompanying organ failure or imminent death, or psychological pain that lasts for months or years and results form the threat of imminent death or torture. That memo has been widely criticized, including by former OLC director Jack Goldsmith, who withdrew the memo and later called it “deeply flawed” and “sloppily reasoned”. In a keynote speech yesterday, Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse (D-R.I.) argued, as he has several times before, that to define torture in that manner and to approve the use of waterboarding on detainees was to ignore the most obvious and relevant legal precedents, suggesting an intent to evade rather than apply and analyze the law in good faith.
Most of the other panelists, including Nan Aron, president of Alliance for Justice, and Georgetown Law professor David Luban, agreed that they believe there is sufficient reason to believe wrongdoing occurred to justify an investigation.
Stuart Taylor, on the other hand, the National Journal columnist and Newsweek contributing editor, said on Tuesday at the conference that “sticking to the memos, in my view they’re nowhere near as outrageous as they’re portrayed.” Yes, some of the techniques are “viscerally horrifying,” he admitted, but the lawyers’ job was to determine whether the proposed methods amounted to the crime of torture. The lawyers’ opinions were “defensable, even where I disagree with them,” he said, adding that their conduct could only be criminal if their intent was malicious.
The panelists all appeared to agree, however, that a “truth commission” aimed at discovering how the memos were drafted and the lawyers reached their controversial conclusions would be appropriate. “I could adopt that idea if it were structured to be a genuine inquiry as to facts that are not known as opposed to a big show on television,” said Taylor. Taylor has previously called for a truth commission that would provide immunity for its participants.
Levin, the former OLC official, also agreed that an independent truth commission “would be useful.” “I would agree that if you could have a serious look at this it would be very valuable,” he said.
Senate Judiciary Committee Chairman Patrick Leahy (D-Vt.) in February proposed such a commission, but so far does not appear to have won broad support from his colleagues. He has yet to even introduce legislation proposing the creation of a “truth and reconciliation commission” or “commission of inquiry,” as he has also called it.
House Judiciary Committee Chairman John Conyers, however, in January proposed legislation that would create what he’s called a “Blue-Ribbon Commission” of outside experts to probe the “broad range” of policies pursued by the Bush administration “under claims of unreviewable war powers,” including torture of detainees and warrantless wiretaps. His plan does not propose immunity for participants and does not rule out a criminal investigation or appointment of a special prosecutor.
The conduct of the Office of Legal Counsel’s lawyers has already been investigated by another government body, the Justice Department’s Office of Professional Responsibility, which investigates allegations of professional misconduct by Justice Department lawyers. Although completed by the end of the Bush administration, that office’s report still has not been released.
Upon completion, the OPR report was sent to the targets of the inquiry— including former OLC lawyers John Yoo, Jay Bybee and Steven Bradbury — for their review and comment. It is still under Justice Department and CIA review. It reportedly analyzes the lawyers’ communications with senior government officials and is highly critical of their conduct.
Yesterday, Whitehouse at the conference argued again for full disclosure of how the OLC lawyers came to recommend actions to the president that he said were clearly contrary to established law.
“America as an ongoing education in freedom, teaches us that the vehicle of America’s freedom is process of law, so process matters. It matters a lot. The question how we came to torture is not an idle or prurient one. Something went wrong,” he continued, and “the epicenter of the problem was the office of legal counsel.”
Responding to the frequent objection that investigation of the previous administration officials risks “criminalizing policy differences,” Whitehouse said: “No. Behavior becomes criminal not when it is investigated, not when it is punished, but when it is committed in violation of law. Prosecution vindicates the law; it doesn’t form it.”
28 Comments
Comment posted November 4, 2009 @ 8:58 pm
It is long past time to have some accountability from the band of amoral sociopaths whose cancerous perversion of the law has smeared this great nation's name. I should like to think we are better than we were in 1898; but from the 2009 vantage point we are little better. Many Americans have rejected every reform made in the Progressive era and the Roosevelt era and we are back to tainted food, sweatshops if you have a job, poisonous patent medicines from the Orient, and frequent periodic economic disasters caused by easily preventable fraud and shenanigans from the sleazy Wall Street classes. Is Warren Buffet simply the new Jay Gould or Hill? Time will tell.
Comment posted November 5, 2009 @ 12:27 pm
Commission my foot. Investigate and prosecute if warranted. But no, the Democrats aid and abet these criminal activities because their own were complicit then, and are continuing them.
If you have a commission, let's not call it “blue ribbon.” Let's call it “white wash” because that's what it is.
Comment posted November 8, 2009 @ 10:59 am
Ugg boots sale
Ugg sale boots
ugg boots cheap
<a href=” http://www.uggsmvp.com/ugg-bailey-button-c-2.html“ >bailey ugg boots
Ugg Classic Cardy
UGG Nightfall
UGG Classic Short
classic tall black uggs
ugg 5815
ugg 5819
nike
http://www.xiedu168.cn
http://www.uggsmvp.com
ugg sale boots
sale ugg boots
UGG Rainier Boots
UGG Persephone Sandal
Purple Ugg Tasmina
UGG Layback Slipper
UGG Ascot Men's Sand Slippers
purple ugg slippers
Ugg boots
Comment posted November 11, 2009 @ 8:29 am
Someone should water-board Matt Mahurin for impersonating and artist
Comment posted November 11, 2009 @ 12:36 pm
“Responding to the frequent objection that investigation of the previous administration officials risks “criminalizing policy differences,” Whitehouse said: “No. Behavior becomes criminal not when it is investigated,
not when it is punished, but when it is committed in violation of law.
Prosecution vindicates the law; it doesn’t form it.”
I Agree!!
Why would anyone not SIGN the PETITION calling for Torture Prosecutions?
http://AngryVoters.org
Comment posted November 17, 2009 @ 11:13 am
From a US Citizen/Latin American-who has lived in many countries-get out of your “Leave it to Beaver” comfort/safe/free speech/choice lives and go live in a few countries for at least 1 year, go experience the real world where Human Rights is usually not part of their vocabulary. What a joke that the US is being reprimanded by nations whose believe of Human Rights is at the bottom of their list or not on the list at all. These nations love who ever came up with this political gimmick that our world reputation is being tarnished by Gitmo and our interrogation methods. Of course they don't like Gitmo/interrogation methods, they don't like Human Rights either. Go travel the world and wake up. See things realistically for yourselves. This is the same as a druggy opposing the opening of a rehab to help druggies fight their addiction. Get up and travel. I am very proud of our country and our soldiers and the work we do in keeping us and others safe.
Comment posted November 17, 2009 @ 11:15 am
From a US Citizen/Latin American-who has lived in many countries-get out of your “Leave it to Beaver” comfort/safe/free speech/choice lives and go live in a few countries for at least 1 year, go experience the real world where Human Rights is usually not part of their vocabulary. What a joke that the US is being reprimanded by nations whose believe of Human Rights is at the bottom of their list or not on the list at all. These nations love who ever came up with this political gimmick that our world reputation is being tarnished by Gitmo and our interrogation methods. Of course they don't like Gitmo/interrogation methods, they don't like Human Rights either. Go travel the world and wake up. See things realistically for yourselves. This is the same as a druggy opposing the opening of a rehab to help druggies fight their addiction. Get up and travel. I am very proud of our country and our soldiers and the work we do in keeping us and others safe.
Comment posted November 17, 2009 @ 4:13 pm
From a US Citizen/Latin American-who has lived in many countries-get out of your “Leave it to Beaver” comfort/safe/free speech/choice lives and go live in a few countries for at least 1 year, go experience the real world where Human Rights is usually not part of their vocabulary. What a joke that the US is being reprimanded by nations whose believe of Human Rights is at the bottom of their list or not on the list at all. These nations love who ever came up with this political gimmick that our world reputation is being tarnished by Gitmo and our interrogation methods. Of course they don't like Gitmo/interrogation methods, they don't like Human Rights either. Go travel the world and wake up. See things realistically for yourselves. This is the same as a druggy opposing the opening of a rehab to help druggies fight their addiction. Get up and travel. I am very proud of our country and our soldiers and the work we do in keeping us and others safe.
Comment posted November 17, 2009 @ 4:15 pm
From a US Citizen/Latin American-who has lived in many countries-get out of your “Leave it to Beaver” comfort/safe/free speech/choice lives and go live in a few countries for at least 1 year, go experience the real world where Human Rights is usually not part of their vocabulary. What a joke that the US is being reprimanded by nations whose believe of Human Rights is at the bottom of their list or not on the list at all. These nations love who ever came up with this political gimmick that our world reputation is being tarnished by Gitmo and our interrogation methods. Of course they don't like Gitmo/interrogation methods, they don't like Human Rights either. Go travel the world and wake up. See things realistically for yourselves. This is the same as a druggy opposing the opening of a rehab to help druggies fight their addiction. Get up and travel. I am very proud of our country and our soldiers and the work we do in keeping us and others safe.
Comment posted August 20, 2010 @ 8:00 am
This is the same as a druggy opposing the opening of a rehab to help druggies fight their addiction.
Trackback posted September 30, 2010 @ 12:50 pm
Healthy diet plan…
thank you very nice article and idea…
Trackback posted October 14, 2010 @ 2:59 pm
Buy Soft Toys & Childrens Toy online now!…
These are impressive articles. Keep up the noble be successful….
Trackback posted October 14, 2010 @ 5:35 pm
Best mortgage rate today…
You can definitely see your enthusiasm in the work you write. The world hopes for more passionate writers like you who aren??t afraid to say how they believe. Always go after your heart….
Trackback posted October 18, 2010 @ 7:51 am
Best mortgage rate today…
I really be keen on the subject matter to facilitate you shared. Thank you on behalf of relocation….
Trackback posted November 10, 2010 @ 8:53 am
Healthy diet plan…
I am definitely bookmarking this page and sharing it with my friends….
Trackback posted November 20, 2010 @ 12:22 pm
Latest Software Reviews, Software Recommendations & Software Comparison…
For some reason only half of the post is being displayed, is it my browser or the site?…
Trackback posted November 24, 2010 @ 8:23 am
Stock Trading Guide & Tips – Investment Advice…
I am really delighted to have joined up with the forum and I am excited to chatting together with people within here as time passes…
Trackback posted November 28, 2010 @ 10:50 am
Great Photography Tutorials…
Your great blog is definitely worth a read if anyone comes across it. Im lucky I did because now Ive got a whole new view of this. I didnt realise that this issue was so important and so universal. You definitely put it in perspective for me, thanks fo…
Trackback posted December 3, 2010 @ 10:42 am
Pet Supplies, Pet Accessories, Pet Products, Pet food | Pet Shop Online…
Your website is without a doubt full of superb details and also is actually rather interesting to scan through.Nicely done….
Trackback posted December 4, 2010 @ 9:51 am
Online Fitness Program and Weight Loss Exercise Plan…
This is a really nice blog you got here. The theme is great! Color combination is awesome….
Trackback posted December 25, 2010 @ 11:40 am
New Car Guide, Reviews & Pricing, Auto News for New Models…
This post was very nicely written, and it also contains a lot of useful facts. I appreciated your professional way of writing this post. Thanks, you have made it very easy for me to understand….
Trackback posted December 25, 2010 @ 12:58 pm
Best Family Holiday Travel Vacation Plan…
I loved this article!!! Appreciation!…
Trackback posted December 25, 2010 @ 1:15 pm
Best Travel Tips, Tour Guide, Vacation Advice & Holiday Plan…
Super stuff! This was a really beneficial place of duty….
Trackback posted December 25, 2010 @ 2:18 pm
Best loan rate calculator and refinance…
Enjoyed the post. I will make sure to link to you from my blog….
Trackback posted December 28, 2010 @ 1:34 pm
CCleaner Download Free – Speedup 300%…
really this is a nice web thank you thanks admin good post super messege…
Trackback posted February 6, 2011 @ 8:38 am
Financial & Investment Management Advisors…
This is my first post on this website and all i can say is thank you for all these useful information! If you allow, I would like to use some of your content. I write articles for article directories as my part time job. I am willing to refernce your s…
Trackback posted February 6, 2011 @ 10:55 am
Unique Wedding Ideas Planning…
Have you ever considered adding more videos to your blog posts to keep the readers more entertained? Anyway this is a great article thanks for sharing this informative information. Regards, Lorna…
RSS feed for comments on this post.
Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.
