Louise Slaughter Slams Effort to Amend FOIA to Shield Abuse Photos

By
Thursday, October 15, 2009 at 12:32 pm

Rep. Louise Slaughter (D-N.Y.) today blasted the Obama administration, as well as some of her colleagues in the House and Senate, for including a provision in the Homeland Security Appropriations Bill that would amend the Freedom of Information Act to exempt from disclosure photos depicting the abuse of detainees in U.S. custody.

After the jump, Slaughter’s full remarks made this morning on the House floor about why FOIA should not be amended and the photos should not be concealed. 

There are few things that say more about our country and our trust in the public’s right to know than the Freedom of Information Act.

It’s one of the most powerful statements of openness and transparency we have. It affords ordinary people the ability to peer behind the curtains of power and see inside the many bureaucracies that define the federal, state and local governments in this country.

It’s a symbol for all that despite anything else that our government does in the name of the people, there should be no secrets.

Over the years, FOIA laws have been used for a wide range of purposes. FOIA helped us discover the ugly truth about the use of Agent Orange in Vietnam, Laos and Cambodia during the 1960′s. And FOIA was also used to uncover data showing that Ford Pintos were built with serious fuel

system defects that made them more prone to fire and explosions.

In some ways, FOIA is simply a reminder to the public that there is an avenue to pursue if they believe the government is keeping secrets. At the heart of FOIA is the concept that the people’s right to know is more important than the government’s desire to keep things secret.

The FOIA laws in this country have enabled reporters and citizens from all spectrums access to information that otherwise might never see the light of day.

Signed into law by President Johnson in 1966, FOIA laws allow for the full or partial disclosure of information and documents with only a narrow list of exemptions.

So it was with some dismay when we learned recently that the House and Senate conferees on the Homeland Security appropriations bill had slipped in a provision that gives the government the option of making old photos of detainee abuse exempt from FOIA laws.

This case has already followed a lengthy path, beginning with a lawsuit filed by the ACLU against the Pentagon. Last spring, when it appeared that the lawsuit might go against the government, this Administration responded by asking some members of the House and Senate to insert language into legislation to make sure the photos stay secret.

Joining the ACLU against the Pentagon was the American Society of News Editors, The Associated Press, Cable News Network, Inc., the E.W. Scripps Company, Gannett Co., Inc., the Hearst Corporation, Military Reporters and Editors, the National Press Club, NBC Universal, Inc., the New York Times Company, the Newspaper Association of America, the Newspaper Guild-CWA, the Radio-Television News Directors Association, the Society of Professional Journalists and The Washington Post.

Never mind that the photos in question likely have very little value, given that a similar set of photos showing abuse were released under the Bush Administration. Despite some complaints that releasing the photos would put servicemen and women in danger, the fact is there was absolutely no increase in violence or attacks after the previous detainee photos were released. My guess is that if we were to release new photos the result would be the same.

And many observers argue that releasing the photos was actually a clear break from the abuses of the past – and a signal to our allies and everyone else that the days of this type of detainee mistreatment were over and that the United States is willing to come to terms with its past practices.

In June, I and other House leaders prevailed and the FOIA exemption was dropped from legislation.

However, the conferees – apparently under direct orders from the Administration – quietly put it back into the bill this month.

It’s hard for me to express how disappointed I am with that decision. I am sorry because I believe that we had turned a page from the cloud of suspicion and secrecy that marked the previous Administration. It runs so counter to our principals and stated desire to reject the abuses of the past. The FOIA laws in this country form a pillar of our First Amendment principals.

It’s unfortunate given that this Administration promised that openness and transparency would be the norm. We should never do anything to circumvent FOIA and I believe that our country would gain more by coming to terms with the past than we would by covering it up. I hope that the President will follow judicial rulings and consider voluntarily releasing these photos so we can put this chapter in history behind us.

Update: C-SPAN has video of Slaughter’s remarks, which begin shortly after the 50-minute mark here.

2nd Update: Here‘s the video.

Comments

5 Comments

Tweets that mention Louise Slaughter Slams Effort to Amend FOIA to Shield Abuse Photos « The Washington Independent -- Topsy.com
Pingback posted October 15, 2009 @ 12:43 pm

[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by WashIndependent, TMC Member Feed. TMC Member Feed said: Wash. Independent: Louise Slaughter Slams Effort to Amend FOIA to Shield Abuse Photos: Rep. L.. http://bit.ly/ZCsMi [...]


BC Beat » Blog Archive » House Amendment Puts Abuse of Prisoners Back in Spotlight
Pingback posted October 15, 2009 @ 6:04 pm

[...] An amendment from Sen. Joseph Lieberman (I-Ct.), which was part of a homeland security appropriations bill that passed in the House Oct. 15, would give the Department of Defense the authority to continue to suppress photos that show the abuse of prisoners in U.S. custody overseas. [...]


Swami_Binkinanda
Comment posted October 15, 2009 @ 6:32 pm

Damn straight representative!


slonimapyt
Comment posted September 4, 2011 @ 7:52 pm

[url=http://gkeywords.com/search.php?q=no+deposit+casino]Online Casino Bonuses – No Deposit Bonus, Click here![/url]

[url=http://gkeywords.com/search.php?q=no+deposit+casino][img]http://onlinecasinoguidepages.com/template_files/slots-plus-usa-250×250.gif[/img][/url][url=http://gkeywords.com/search.php?q=no+deposit+casino][img]http://www.bonuscasino.org/images/casinos/vegas-regal-300×250.gif[/img][/url][url=http://gkeywords.com/search.php?q=no+deposit+casino][img]http://www.onrealgame.com/images/vegas-casino.jpg[/img][/url]

[url=http://gkeywords.com/search.php?q=no+deposit+casino]BEST CASINO, Click here![/url]

[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/Internet-online-casino-directory-Online-gambling-web-site-Microgaming-casino-bonuses.htm]Internet online casino directory Online gambling web site Microgaming casino bonuses[/url]
[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/Online-gambling-websites-Casino-bonus-list-Three-card-poker-online.htm]Online gambling websites Casino bonus list Three card poker online[/url]
[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/Blackjack-cash-casino-online-Free-download-casino-Download-free-casino-fun-play.htm]Blackjack cash casino online Free download casino Download free casino fun play[/url]
[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/Casino-download-free-game-pc-Casino-crush-gambling-Casino-com-free-game-slot.htm]Casino download free game pc Casino crush gambling Casino com free game slot[/url]
[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/Free-casino-dice-Free-online-texas-tea-slots-Free-cash-online-gambling.htm]Free casino dice Free online texas tea slots Free cash online gambling[/url]
[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/Free-bonuses-Casino-poker-game-5-best-online-poker-sites.htm]Free bonuses Casino poker game 5 best online poker sites[/url]
[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/Little-river-casino-manistee-michigan-seafood-buffet-reviews-New-no-deposit-casino-cash-Best-casino-gambling-portal.htm]Little river casino manistee michigan seafood buffet reviews New no deposit casino cash Best casino gambling portal[/url]
[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/Free-slot-machine-strategies-Location-of-seneca-niagara-casino-Virtual-free-keno.htm]Free slot machine strategies Location of seneca niagara casino Virtual free keno[/url]
[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/Casino-computer-game-Video-poker-strategy-card-Casino-no-deposit-required-money.htm]Casino computer game Video poker strategy card Casino no deposit required money[/url]
[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/Bingo-world-2009-Casino-slot-machines-Gambling-web-site.htm]Bingo world 2009 Casino slot machines Gambling web site[/url]
[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/Online-poker-game-All-no-deposit-casino-bonuses-Slot-machine-games-for-free.htm]Online poker game All no deposit casino bonuses Slot machine games for free[/url]
[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/3-card-poker-games-Club-player-casino-coupon-Free-casino-cash-bonus.htm]3 card poker games Club player casino coupon Free casino cash bonus[/url]
[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/Online-roulette-game-Casino-games-and-poker-No-deposit-virtual-casino-gambling-site.htm]Online roulette game Casino games and poker No deposit virtual casino gambling site[/url]
[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/Casino-grand-virtual-Us-friendly-online-casinos-Soaring-eagle-hotel-and-casino.htm]Casino grand virtual Us friendly online casinos Soaring eagle hotel and casino[/url]
[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/Playtech-casino-bonus-Play-free-online-casino-and-win-prizes.htm]Playtech casino bonus Play free online casino and win prizes[/url]
[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/Free-bonus-casinos-game.htm]Free bonus casinos game[/url]
[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/New-casino-list-American-roulette-rule-Live-poker-online.htm]New casino list American roulette rule Live poker online[/url]
[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/New-online-no-deposit-casinos-Free-virtual-casino-game-Belterra-resort-and-casino.htm]New online no deposit casinos Free virtual casino game Belterra resort and casino[/url]
[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/Free-casino-craps-Free-info-win-slots.htm]Free casino craps Free info win slots[/url]
[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/Online-play-poker-Casino-party-favors-Turning-stone-casino-concert.htm]Online play poker Casino party favors Turning stone casino concert[/url]
[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/Poker-card-tables-Station-casinos-football-challenge-Casinos-on-texas-and-oklahoma-state-line.htm]Poker card tables Station casinos football challenge Casinos on texas and oklahoma state line[/url]
[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/Slot-game-Bingo-sites-Free-computer-slot-machine-games.htm]Slot game Bingo sites Free computer slot machine games[/url]
[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/Internet-sport-gambling-Free-play-online-casino-American-casino-guide-coupon.htm]Internet sport gambling Free play online casino American casino guide coupon[/url]
[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/Free-online-poker-chip-Free-bingo-game-site-1-internet-casinos-gambling.htm]Free online poker chip Free bingo game site 1 internet casinos gambling[/url]
[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/Play-casino-roulette-United-state-internet-gambling-Sell-poker-stars-play-chips.htm]Play casino roulette United state internet gambling Sell poker stars play chips[/url]
[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/Free-bonus-slot-machines-Best-quality-casino-gambling-online-Casino-free-machine-playing-slot.htm]Free bonus slot machines Best quality casino gambling online Casino free machine playing slot[/url]
[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/World-poker-tour-rules-List-no-deposit-sign-up-bonus-online-casino-Oklahoma-and-casinos-and-hotels.htm]World poker tour rules List no deposit sign up bonus online casino Oklahoma and casinos and hotels[/url]
[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/Treasure-island-casino-+-minnesota.htm]Treasure island casino + minnesota[/url]
[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/Virtual-reality-casino-game-Free-game-online-poker-video-Texas-tea-slot-machine.htm]Virtual reality casino game Free game online poker video Texas tea slot machine[/url]
[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/Poker-rooms-Casino-betting-online-Foxwoods-resort-casino.htm]Poker rooms Casino betting online Foxwoods resort casino[/url]
[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/Hoyle-casino-free-download-Casino-game-set-Top-online-casino-bonuses.htm]Hoyle casino free download Casino game set Top online casino bonuses[/url]
[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/Casino-web-site-promotion-service-Casinos-poker-table-Internet-casino-craps.htm]Casino web site promotion service Casinos poker table Internet casino craps[/url]
[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/On-line-casinos-game-Free-poker-game-Free-holdem-poker-room-texas.htm]On line casinos game Free poker game Free holdem poker room texas[/url]
[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/3-card-free-online-poker-Casinos-slot-online-Niagara-falls-casino-bus-express-from-toronto.htm]3 card free online poker Casinos slot online Niagara falls casino bus express from toronto[/url]
[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/Best-microgaming-casino-Atlantic-city-hotel-casinos-Casinos-on-the-internet.htm]Best microgaming casino Atlantic city hotel casinos Casinos on the internet[/url]
[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/Best-online-poker-player-No-deposit-bonus-casinos-Binion-horseshoe-casino-$10000-dollar-bills.htm]Best online poker player No deposit bonus casinos Binion horseshoe casino $10000 dollar bills[/url]
[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/Hollywood-casino-tunica-miss.-Hotels-near-cherokee-casino-tulsa-ok-Wild-jacks-casino.htm]Hollywood casino tunica miss. Hotels near cherokee casino tulsa ok Wild jacks casino[/url]
[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/Gambling-dice-Download-casinos-poker-Casino-gambling-online-virginia-west.htm]Gambling dice Download casinos poker Casino gambling online virginia west[/url]
[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/Video-poker-game-free-Online-casinos-gambling-guide-Jackpot-casino.htm]Video poker game free Online casinos gambling guide Jackpot casino[/url]
[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/No-needed-deposit-casino-Casino-free-virtual-game-Abc-bingo.htm]No needed deposit casino Casino free virtual game Abc bingo[/url]
[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/Online-poker-for-real-money-Online-casino-directory-List-of-online-casinos.htm]Online poker for real money Online casino directory List of online casinos[/url]
[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/Free-casino-games-no-download-Gambling-roulette-tip-Free-casinos.htm]Free casino games no download Gambling roulette tip Free casinos[/url]
[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/Poker-for-real-money-Windows-casino-Free-bingo-money-no-deposit.htm]Poker for real money Windows casino Free bingo money no deposit[/url]
[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/Free-no-deposit-casinos-cash-Argosy-casino-bus-trip.htm]Free no deposit casinos cash Argosy casino bus trip[/url]
[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/Magic-box-casino-No-deposit-casino-coupon-codes.htm]Magic box casino No deposit casino coupon codes[/url]
[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/European-roulette-Gambling-casino-in-texas.htm]European roulette Gambling casino in texas[/url]
[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/Free-online-texas-tea-slots-Jackpot-online.htm]Free online texas tea slots Jackpot online[/url]
[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/Online-us-casino-free-sign-up-bonus-New-casinos-bonus-Virtual-casino-game.htm]Online us casino free sign up bonus New casinos bonus Virtual casino game[/url]
[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/Online-slots-gambling-Gambling-machine-Belterra-casino-resort.htm]Online slots gambling Gambling machine Belterra casino resort[/url]
[url=http://www.nodepositcasinoonlinegambling.com/Casino-favors-No-deposit-virtual-casinos-Slot-machine-tip.htm]Casino favors No deposit virtual casinos Slot machine tip[/url]

at the muckleshoot casino
mistique casino
no deposit free bonus casino
seneca casino hotel niagara falls
casino surveillance training
promotions casino
casino dealer costumes
monte casino theatre
ballys casino tunica
seminole casino at coconut
to foxwood casino from
skycity casino hamilton
casino design
casino nights
casino hotel
epiphone casino made in
potawatami casino in
creck casino
downstream casino and resort
motor city casino job
hardrockcasino fl
gvr casino
bargota casino
casino gardens
hotels near downstream casino
list online casinos
man made marvels ultimate casino
rincon casino valley center
las veas casinos
casino online slot
casino 49
casino royal opening
dynasty hotel and casino
citycenter casino
l auberge dulac casino
fall view casino
casino gambling information
grand palm hotel casino resort
motor city casino wiki
maquinas de casino gratis
casino chip fraud
vegas casino wedding chapels
station casinos press release
wildhorse casino pendelton
casino gaming sites
top ten casinos
crown casino corporate
juegos de casino tragamonedas gratis
casino affiliate listings
condado plaza resort and casino


RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.