rssState Secrets Critics Slam New Obama Policy
Wednesday, September 23, 2009 at 5:56 pm
- 25 Comments
President Barack Obama (WDCpix)
Although the Obama administration’s much-anticipated new policy on the use of the so-called “state secrets” privilege, announced this morning, has drawn some praise, civil liberties lawyers and other critics of the use of the privilege don’t think it solves the problem.
The state secrets privilege allows the government to conceal certain evidence in a court case that, if disclosed, would endanger national security by revealing “state secrets”. But who gets to decide what is a state secret and whether it will actually endanger national security has long been a point of contention. The Department of Justice, first under President Bush and then under President Obama, has invoked the privilege to ask courts to dismiss every single legal case that has come before them seeking compensation for torture or warrantless wiretapping by the government. That’s led critics to charge that the administration is trying to use the evidentiary privilege not to protect national security, but to conceal government wrongdoing and avoid embarrassment, or worse.
Today’s announcement says the government will use the privilege more sparingly, and requires the attorney general himself to sign off on its use. But the provision does not bar the government from using the privilege to try to dismiss cases alleging government wrongdoing.
“They don’t anywhere say, ‘we will not seek dismissal on state secrets grounds at the outset’” of a case, said Ben Wizner, a staff attorney at the American Civil Liberties Union who’s come up against the privilege while representing victims of torture. “They say we’re going to make an effort to apply it as narrowly as possible. But that doesn’t change what they’ve been doing all along.”
What the Department of Justice has been doing all along is essentially what the Obama administration has done in one case Wizner’s working on, in which a victim of torture due to the CIA’s “extraordinary rendition” program sued Jeppesen Dataplan, a subsidiary of Boeing, claiming the company was partly responsible for helping transport CIA prisoners to other countries to be tortured. The government claimed that allowing the case to go forward would reveal state secrets and endanger national security, and asked the court to dismiss it. Eventually, the ACLU won the right to proceed with the litigation, but the Obama administration in June asked the court of appeals to reconsider and dismiss the case.
“Any new policy will be an empty gesture if the administration continues to assert the same expansive theory of state secrets to dismiss cases brought by torture victims,” Wizner said Wednesday. “At the same time that they are rolling out this new policy with fanfare, they are asking the Ninth Circuit [Court of Appeals] to reverse its own decision and rehear the case because of state secrets.”
The Jeppesen case is one of several where the Obama administration has made the same expansive arguments that entire cases should be dismissed to protect state secrets, rather than simply excluding the particular piece of evidence that could actually endanger national security.
The real problem, say critics, is that the Obama administration is trying to use its new policy as a way to prevent the passage of legislation that will clarify the role of the executive versus the role of the courts.
“The Bush administration’s approach to state secrets was wrong-headed, causing significant public distrust and potentially shielding government wrongdoing and embarrassing mistakes behind a questionable legal doctrine,” said Sen. Russ Feingold (D-Wis.) in a statement released after the Justice Department’s announcement today. Feingold is a cosponsor of the proposed State Secrets Protection Act, which would provide guidance to federal courts considering cases where the government has asserted the state secrets privilege. “While I am pleased that the Obama administration recognizes that the Bush approach was a mistake, its new policy is disappointing because it still amounts to an approach of ‘just trust us.’ ”
Or as Wizner put it, “this is voluntary executive self-policing.” Legislation would “bind not just this president but the next one. That’s critical.”
What’s more, the new policy doesn’t really address the role of judges in cases where the privilege is invoked. The proposed legislation, on the other hand, “says courts cannot dismiss cases simply on the basis that the government claims the case involves state secrets. The legislation says courts are required to look at the underlying evidence” and decide for themselves. In many of these cases that have come up so far, it’s the government agency being sued — such as the CIA — that submits a statement to the court saying that the evidence that it committed a crime would endanger national security. “The court shouldn’t be able to rely just on an affidavit filed by the perpetrator,” said Wizner.
Under the proposed State Secrets Protection Act, if a court looks at the evidence and determines that some piece of it really does constitute a state secret — say, the identity of a CIA agent — then that evidence would be removed from the case. But before making that determination, the judge would have to explore every alternative, to see if other tools, such as protective orders, could be used to protect the evidence but still allow it to be used. If carefully and narrowly applied, says Wizner, only particular pieces of evidence that are not important to the litigation would have to be excluded. “No one’s saying we can litigate the identity of covert agents in civil cases,” says Wizner.
Ken Gude, Associate Director of the International Rights and Responsibility Program at the progressive Center for American Progress, expressed similar concerns about the Obama administration’s new state secrets policy. “My main concern is that the government should not be able to have a whole case dismissed simply by asserting a state secrets claim,” he said in an e-mail on Wednesday. “There may be instances when it’s simply not possible to proceed without certain evidence, but that should result from a subsequent decision after the plaintiffs have had a chance to plead their case without the material.”
That seemed to be what President Obama supported, too, when he first spoke about the state secrets privilege back in April. At an April 29 press conference, he called the state secrets doctrine “overbroad.” He went on to say that “searching for ways to redact, to carve out certain cases, to see what can be done, so that a judge in chambers can review information, without it being an open court — you know, there should be some additional tools, so that it’s not such a blunt instrument. And we’re interested in pursuing that. I know that Eric Holder and Greg Craig, my White House counsel, and others are working on that, as we speak.”
Today’s announcement is the policy that resulted from that process. But critics aren’t convinced it that it will actually accomplish what the president has promised.
As Feingold said today: “Independent court review of the government’s use of the state secrets privilege is essential. I urge the administration to work with Congress to develop legislation that sets reasonable limits on the privilege and will not be subject to change under each successive president.”
–
25 Comments
Pingback posted September 23, 2009 @ 6:09 pm
[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by WashIndependent and TMC Member Feed. TMC Member Feed said: Wash. Independent: State Secrets Critics Slam New Obama Policy: Although the Obama administrat.. http://bit.ly/1R0Zeb [...]
Pingback posted September 23, 2009 @ 8:06 pm
[...] in Daily life, Government, Law, Obama administration at 5:06 pm by LeisureGuy Daphne Eviatar in the Washington Independent: Although the Obama administration’s much-anticipated new policy on the use of the so-called [...]
Pingback posted September 24, 2009 @ 6:02 am
[...] Visit Source [...]
Comment posted September 24, 2009 @ 5:05 pm
Your colleague Ed Brayton has an excellent analysis of what the Obama Administration could have advocated for that would have been both prudent in optimizing national security while maintaining fealty to the Constitution and its principles: http://scienceblogs.com/dispatches/2009/09/obam…
Pingback posted September 24, 2009 @ 9:46 pm
[...] [...]
Comment posted September 25, 2009 @ 3:29 pm
“Independent court review of the government’s use of the state secrets privilege is essential. I urge the administration to work with Congress to develop legislation that sets reasonable limits on the privilege and will not be subject to change under each successive president.”
I never thought I'd see a day when I would agree with something said by Rus Feingold!
Pingback posted September 29, 2009 @ 6:57 am
[...] that it changes little, if anything. Daphne Eviatar find several more civil libertarians that agree with him. Oddly, security maximalists may not be pleased with the news, either. In any case, only hours [...]
Pingback posted October 26, 2009 @ 11:48 am
[...] continued efforts to dismiss cases alleging government-sponsored torture and illegal wiretapping by raising the “state secrets” privilege; to President Obama’s continued insistence on hiding photos of brutal detainee abuse — [...]
Comment posted April 29, 2010 @ 2:43 pm
Life of the law is not logic but experience. – Holmes
cheap mbt shoes for sale MBT Lami Red Shoes
Pingback posted May 20, 2010 @ 2:38 am
[...] 123456789101112131415161718192021Pre Owned Mercury Milan Interior, Mercury Milan Oem Parts FordPre Owned Mercury Milan Interior, Mercury Milan Oem Parts Fordsale wi used mercury milan milano shopping corso buenos aires sea milan airports milano radiator 5.0 l used milano investors gas mileage mercury milan ford fusion monaco milan discount airfares milan aftermarket montego mercury milan milano white leather bed photos laure milan milan headers mercury milan sale wisconsin grand marquis milan tourist office classic mercedes 380slc milan brown shock absorbers milan substitute match milan airport rush milan setlist milan second hand milano discount hotel cristoforo colombo bagatti valsecchi milan lamp uttermost montego aftermarket mercury milan sedan made in milan melbourne parts ford fusion all weather floor mats mercury milan parts 2009 lincoln mkx mercury milan oguchi onyewu ac milan performance parts for 2006 2009 mercury milan and ford fusion buy used 2008 mercury milan montego sale milan pre owned mercury sable milano schedule milano problems description mercury milan all wheel drive for sale milano plug buy milani skin tone model mercury milan mpg milano new nonprofit sector ac milan away shirt milano part jimmy kimmel live jackhole productions milan parts oem 2008 mercury milan aftermarket milan bulb frugal shopper chrysler sebring torino university european universities politecnico di milano milan shops via montenapoleone 2010 milan nissan altima milano aftermarket v9 milan lincoln mercury diamante discount top pollution alfaparf milano milan castello sforzesco photos download mercury milan interior milan bus milan used sedan milan radiator fan cooling mercury milan fiyati dealer harley milano milano fix escudo ac milan milano part jimmy fallon zoe saldana milan executive limousine mercury milan led tail lights milani skins aftermarket milan serie a mercury milan parts warranty premier trade compass milano milano papers milan replacement direct fog light milan champions league 2009 alfa romeo milano radiator mercury merkur cafe milano review mercury milan sale mn mileage sale owner buy used mercury milan milan bulb headlight grand marquis inter milan official site 2007 mercury milan msn sale used alfa romeo milano milano symptoms montego sale classified 2009 mercury milan 2009 ford fusion reliability mercury milan milano ceiling light cost lease mercury milan mercury milan 2012 mercury milan repair history reliability milan led mario balotelli milano installation need 2010 fusion body kit mercury milan birkenstock milano discount milano service ford fusion mercury milan better milan free used 2006 mercury milan premier 2006 acura rsx type s sale gladstone milano red mecury milan reviews milan auction genericdomains disc milano 2007 mercury milan for sale used car sempion car milano milan travel help milan ny real estate northern dutchess realty milano part hulu jackhole productions milano formals size mercury milan repair history mpg V40 Games Free | Chevrolet Spectrum Replacement | Gs350 Used Lexus | Cars 1970 Chevy | Nissan Altima C | [...]
Pingback posted May 20, 2010 @ 2:13 pm
[...] 12345678910111213141516171819202122232425262728293031323334353637383940Santa Fe Parts Headlight Assembly Bulbs Hyundai Xg300, Xg300 Discount Performance Auto Parts Brake Pads Catalytic ConverterSanta Fe Parts Headlight Assembly Bulbs Hyundai Xg300, Xg300 Discount Performance Auto Parts Brake Pads Catalytic Converterxg300 free auto parts warehouse chevrolet g30 van muffler xg300 discount halogen bulb hyundai scoupe chevy van g30 vanteet power steering pump xg300 genesis coupe santa fe hyundai azera buy tiburon gt hyundai xg300 sound hyundai xg300 hyundai xg300 hps xg300 removal end xg300 classic shipping chevrolet g30 van manual auto parts hyundai xg300 truck wholesale dodge g30 sale cargo van radiator hyundai xg300 thousands oem g30 company xg300 pet hyundai xg300 part lowest buy g30 chevrolet monte carlo gm g30 van specs cheap hyundai xg300 parts hyundai xg300 episodes online g30 tube used chevrolet taillight discount replacement hyundai xg300 g30 van oem body find g30 chevrolet g3500 xg300 videos xg300 map hyundai elantra part hyundai xg300 lowest brake pads xg300 pre owned azera hyundai entourage xg300 i have azera here hyundai xg300 edit headlight hyundai xg300 6cyl l h100118 hyundai xg300 tiburon spark plugs santa fe aftermarket elantra hyundai xg300 discount light 2001 hyundai xg300 headlight assembly 1994 chevy g30 van parking brake yukon quest aftermarket hyundai xg300 suzuki aerio xg300 2nd hand parts body kit fog lights 2001 hyundai xg300 hyundai xg300 heater assembly auction azera hyundai xg300 certified hyundai xg300 radiator fan hyundai xg300 used parts throttle body xg300 cover fit hyundai xg300 oem car parts 2001 hyundai xg300 headlight assembly salvage yards santa fe parts headlight assembly bulbs hyundai xg300 buy hyundai xg300 free shipping xg300 parts damper kyb gr 2 part discount catalog hyundai xg300 g30 van exhaust aftermarket discount 2001 hyundai xg300 buick century mercury sable diagram 2001 hyundai xg300 brake rotor pt 2001 hyundai xg300 mercury sable xg300 auto elantra hyundai veracruz discount guaranteed 2001 hyundai xg300 xg300 turn signal g30 van auto parts aftermarket entourage second xg300 used hyundai tiburon radiator hyundai xg300 free shipping ignition coil buy g30 oakley flak jacket dust particles xg300 wamp aftermarket high quality hyundai xg300 hyundai xg300 model catalog g30 aftermarket online c15 cg300 suburban headlight truck 2001 hyundai xg300 autotrader xg300 bulb hid xenon car parts hyundai xg300 adapter buy g30 base light bulb 172 part garmin g300 g30 sale g20 used chevrolet g30 van chevrolet g20 ebay motors g30 van used chevrolet truck parts buy hyundai xg300 fuel injector truck parts radiator hyundai xg300 hundreds xg300 repair recalls owners entourage used xg300 hyundai elantra xg300 leather upholstery 2005 hyundai wheel covers hyundai xg300 auto lights hyundai xg300 car parts oxygen sensor a c condenser g30 co uk xg300 used azera hyundai sonata g30 van coolant brake pads headlight driver hyundai xg300 side marker xg300 used parts rear bumper cover throttle body hyundai xg300 xg300 water vehicle xg350 used hyundai xg300 automatic transmission xg300 parts timing belt tensioner autozone hyundai xg300 engine buy 2001 hyundai xg300 car parts salvage yard xg300 tmobile xg300 accessories tiburon hyundai santa fe parts discount guaranteed to fit hyundai xg300 part hyundai xg300 accessories floor mats shock absorber xg300 parts sports compare prices engine fit hyundai xg300 xg300 headlight printer xg300 episodes online montero 2001 E55 Amg | Crv Equipment Crv | 2002 Sonata Parts | Pilot Map Pl | 2005 Gx470 Brochure | [...]
Pingback posted May 22, 2010 @ 9:20 am
[...] 12345678910111213141516171819202122232425262728293031323334353637383940414243444546474849505152535455565758596061626364656667686970717273747576777879808182Download Liberty, 2010 Jeep Liberty CanadaDownload Liberty, 2010 Jeep Liberty Canadafactory jeep liberty speakers 2010 jeep liberty sport jeep liberty diesel manual transmission hid jeep liberty tail lights jeep liberty radiator jeep liberty weekend liberty skis lyrics statue of liberty meaning new york harbor liberty 0 60 liberty ross casamento liberty mutual sales report 2002 jeep liberty hitch wrangler accessories jeep liberty spark plugs liberty high school bethlehem basketball jeep liberty rear window off track jeep compass bulb warranty liberty jeep liberty hood scoop jeep liberty lights jeep liberty for sale manual liberty baseboard install jeep liberty second hand liberty mutual affinity marketing 2005 jeep liberty headlight bulb replacement 2002 jeep liberty 4×4 ford escape liberty 600 liberty renegade 2010 jeep statue of liberty gustave eiffel structure jeep liberty overheating liberty postage stamp liberty high school academic calendar 2005 jeep liberty radiator replacement fuel filter liberty board shop sale nike sb liberty mutual middle market liability claims jeep liberty radio problems liberty bathroom radiator liberty jr high school logo liberty c64 headlight auto parts discount jeep liberty 2002 jeep liberty sport specs liberty motors liberty coin pcgs jeep liberty turn signal light side marker 2005 jeep liberty safe edmunds jeep liberty 2004 jeep liberty c tail b b light b b assembly b 2004 grand cherokee performance parts jeep liberty liberty half dollar liberty outlet quality liberty oil yagoona liberty distributor replacement jeep liberty parts liberty revolutionary war battle of bunker hill grand cherokee tire rack jeep liberty jeep liberty park brake jeep liberty aftermarket grilles liberty bell liberty mutual middle market marsh liberty tax melbourne florida liberty 2nd hand jeep wagoneer pre owned liberty high school used class liberty high school sale search classified listings jeep liberty car driver jeep patriot liberty comparison 02 lift kit jeep liberty subaru liberty 2003 2005 liberty executive safe gauge steel cheap used jeep liberty for sale car search 2002 2004 jeep liberty bumper dcs liberty side burner sink unit liberty bank remote deposit capture checks did liberty bell used called 2009 jeep liberty parts manual transmission liberty custom designs 2007 jeep liberty pictures specs liberty supplies polymedica corporation review compact jeep liberty jeep liberty tail light tent liberty diesel forum new subaru liberty liberty ellis island park statue cruises statue of liberty tickets coupon liberty high point liberty radiator plastic tanks 1997 jeep grand cherokee automatic transmission jeep liberty kk tow hooks liberty mpg wrangler unlimited 2010 jeep grand cherokee statue of liberty give me your tired your poor tx liberty mutual insurance liberty sale georgia wrangler unlimited 2002 jeep liberty aftermarket grille guard liberty zone special depreciation allowance tax breaks bulb 2007 jeep liberty warranty liberty high school aftermarket grand voyager tc maserati jeep liberty accessories roof rack diesel kit jeep liberty suspension lift liberty board shop auction jeep liberty headlight problems chrysler dodge nitro performance chip jeep liberty jeep liberty defrost stuck jeep liberty fan club liberty definition converge Georgia Tech Ccf | Mercedes Benz 500e | Eurovan Part Camper | Clk63 Amg Ancient | Bmw 330xi Performance | [...]
Pingback posted May 24, 2010 @ 3:53 pm
[...] 123456789101112131415161718192021222324252627282930313233343536373839404142434445464748495051525354555657585960616263646566676869707172737475767778798081828384858687888990919293949596979899100101E 450 Econoline Super Duty Sale Catalytic Converter Eastern Explorer Sport Trac, Ktm 450 Motard – 465.tvshowzone.comE 450 Econoline Super Duty Sale Catalytic Converter Eastern Explorer Sport Trac, Ktm 450 Motard2009 f450 harley davidson truck e 450 crew cab stripped chassis sale camshaft position sensor faucet d450 enterprises canon ip4500 print head problem d450 replacement our selection c4500 hood aftermarket parts honda crf450 refurbished d450 p35 p3500 bus bulb gmc w4500 gs350 discount headlights gs 450h swivels 2009 ford f 450 dually ford e450 super duty repair manual explorer sport trac bronco ii e 450 econoline super duty 5.4 l replacement headlight assembly explorer sport trac d450 installation warranty e 450 seats van d450 adoption until chrysler d450 manufactured gl450 installation adjustment cl55 amg f 450 pickup replacement kool vue mail 1972 mercedes benz 450sl parts salvage yards sd450 used usb 2.0 hi speed battery charger cb 2lv d450 organs wfw9450wr d450 pt product weber s450 gas grill d450 part find d450 headlight supplies dodge ram 3500 450sel bosch k jetronic arab oil embargo dodge d450 pt seat belt lexus lx450 trial lexus rx450h interior mp3 lexus lx450 1997 lexus lx 450 reliability f 450 pickup bulb headlight assembly gs450h pt up 1978 mercedes 450slc w107 rx450h aftermarket hybrid lexus rx 450h 450slc listings ford e 450 super duty stripped chassis oxygen sensor spark plug rx450h zone 450se rock c3500 dots per inch mp c4500 ieee 1284 lx 450 parts eos 450d promo digital slr cameras ford e 450 econoline super duty stripped price headlight assembly ford f 450 for sale king ranch photoconductor e250x22g e450dn lexmark e350d aftermarket w0133 450sl heater 450sl full financing 450sl sale values 450 pickup full ford f littermaid 450 accessori canon eos 450 d t rex 450se v2 1996 lexus lx450 edmunds lexus f 500 hp gs 450h f 450 super duty aftermarket e450dn toys r us gl450 pot gs300 1993 lexus gs 450h ls 600h used 4500 chevy van super duty body parts f 450 450slc stainless steel rx450h bumper new lexus e 450 econoline super duty replacement 5.4 l fits 550 econoline f 150 part crown victoria ford e 450 ford e 450 super duty replacement james duff e 450 lightning 2nd hand lx450 parts accessories lexus lx470 gs450h pt 2008 lexus lexus rx 450 performance d450 bumper sale savana 4500 model cutaway van thule 45050 crossroad roof rack systems gs450h beaters 380slc headlight discounts 450sl applications f 450 ram parts dodge used canon powershot sd450 nb 4l rx450h radiator accounts receivable 450sl motor 450d lens gl450 up buy 4500 2010 gl450 mercedes benz gl class gmc c4500 full 450sel stop odor 450sel 450sl discount antenna mast drum 450 olympus d 450 book 450r honda graphic kit mercedes benz 450se used wiring harness clk55 amg 1981 suzuki 450l buy econoline super duty 7.3 l diesel ford e450 closeout gl450 california 4500 used gl450 parts cheap mercedes benz fuel injector e 450 vehicle thousands e 450 f350 stripped chassis part oxygen sensor canon eos 450d 18 55 lens kit Typhoon Car Pics | C320 Chevy Replacement | Aerostar 601 Safety | 2000 Bmw 540i | C240 Accessories Clk55 | [...]
Comment posted July 6, 2010 @ 6:48 am
As Feingold said today: “Independent court review of the government’s use of the state secrets privilege is essential. I urge the administration to work with Congress to develop legislation that sets reasonable limits on the privilege and will not be subject to change under each successive president.”
Comment posted August 5, 2010 @ 4:03 am
Excellent site, keep up the good work my colleagues would love this. I read a lot of blogs on a daily basis and for the most part, people lack substance but, I just wanted to make a quick comment to say I’m glad I found your blog. Thanks
Comment posted August 13, 2010 @ 4:00 am
winni2078 08 13
juicy couture
omega watches
juicy couture handbags
omega seamaster
Comment posted August 20, 2010 @ 8:07 am
but, I just wanted to make a quick comment to say I’m glad I found your blog.
Pingback posted November 29, 2010 @ 9:25 pm
[...] and in the early days of his presidency, he did take some steps in that direction — he soon morphed into a cosmetically more personable version of George W. [...]
Pingback posted November 29, 2010 @ 9:37 pm
[...] and in the early days of his presidency, he did take some steps in that direction — he soon morphed into a cosmetically more personable version of George W. [...]
Pingback posted January 7, 2011 @ 4:31 pm
[...] on the entirely cosmetic nature of the so-called “new state secrets” policy, see this excellent article from The Washington Independent‘s Daphne [...]
Trackback posted April 4, 2011 @ 5:58 pm
Property Solicitors…
[...]we like to honor other sites on the web, even if they aren’t related to us, by linking to them. Below are some sites worth checking out[...]…
Pingback posted May 21, 2011 @ 8:44 am
[...] on the entirely cosmetic nature of the so-called “new state secrets” policy, see this excellent article from The Washington Independent‘s Daphne [...]
RSS feed for comments on this post.
Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.
