Duke Energy CEO Questions Viability of ‘Clean’ Coal Technology, Future of Coal
Wednesday, September 16, 2009 at 3:44 pm
Jim Rogers, CEO of Duke Energy, raised questions on Wednesday about the viability of capturing and storing carbon dioxide emissions from coal plants underground, and suggested that coal may not even be part of the energy mix by 2050.
“I actually can see a future where coal is not in the equation in 2050,” Rogers told reporters at an event in Washington.
He argued that it’s unlikely that the United States will be able to develop and bring to scale carbon-capture-and-storage – often called “clean coal” technology. “I think there’s no way we can scale in this country,” he said. “It’s more likely that China will develop and bring CCS to scale. I’d like to be China for a day so we can get CCS done. They’re more likely to get it scaled and deployed than we are. We’re going to be buying their technology.”
He also acknowledged that concerns about coal extraction methods like mountaintop removal may make coal more expensive in the near-term. “I’m under incredible pressure on moutaintop mining,” said Rogers. “Most of the coal we use in the southern part of the country is from mountaintop mining. I’m doing the math now and looking to determine my contracts and posing the question to my team, what if we made a policy decision that we’re not going to buy coal as a consequence of mountaintop mining.”
The future of mountaintop removal grew less certain last week as the Obama administration put the breaks on 79 surface mining permits in Appalachia. Rogers also cited concerns about the amount of space and infrastructure that would be needed to make CCS a reality, as well as concerns about the viability of storage. Instead, he says he foresees nuclear rising to become the biggest source of baseload power by 2050, along with solar and “a little wind,” and improved efficiency.
“On the time horizon, I have a higher probability of coming up with the next generation recycling [of nuclear waste], and it’s manageable,” he said. He argued that the spent fuel from the last 40 years from every nuclear power plant in the United States could be put on one football field, stacked seven feet high. But he said his company’s calculations have found that even storage of 20 percent of carbon emissions would require ten cubic miles over the life of a power plant.
“That’s a lot of football fields,” said Rogers.
Duke, the third-largest generator of electricity in the country and a major consumer of coal, made news earlier this month when it dropped out the controversial group Americans for Clean Coal Electricity, a coal front group. Duke is also a member of the U.S. Climate Action Partnership, a coalition of environmental and business groups formed to build support for a climate bill that has played an active role in shaping legislation this year.
Rogers acknowledged that his take on coal’s future would be “a little provocative.”
16 Comments
Pingback posted September 16, 2009 @ 5:56 pm
[...] here to see the original: Duke Energy CEO Questions Viability of ‘Clean’ Coal Technology, Future of Coal Share and [...]
Pingback posted September 17, 2009 @ 3:20 pm
[...] Duke Energy CEO Questions Viability of ‘Clean’ Coal Technology, Future of Coal Jim Rogers, CEO of Duke Energy, raised questions on Wednesday about the viability of capturing and storing carbon dioxide emissions from coal plants underground, and suggested that coal may not even be part of the energy mix by 2050. “I actually can see a future where coal is not in the equation in 2050,” Rogers told reporters at an event in Washington. He argued that it’s unlikely that the United States will be able to develop and bring to scale carbon-capture-and-storage – often called “clean coal” technology. “I think there’s no way we can scale in this country,” he said. “It’s more likely that China will develop and bring CCS to scale. I’d like to be China for a day so we can get CCS done. They’re more likely to get it scaled and deployed than we are. We’re going to be buying their technology.” He also acknowledged that concerns about coal extraction methods like mountaintop removal may make coal more expensive in the near-term. “I’m under incredible pressure on moutaintop mining,” said Rogers. “Most of the coal we use in the southern part of the country is from mountaintop mining. I’m doing the math now and looking to determine my contracts and posing the question to my team, what if we made a policy decision that we’re not going to buy coal as a consequence of mountaintop mining.” The future of mountaintop removal grew less certain last week as the Obama administration put the breaks on 79 surface mining permits in Appalachia. Rogers also cited concerns about the amount of space and infrastructure that would be needed to make CCS a reality, as well as concerns about the viability of storage. Instead, he says he foresees nuclear rising to become the biggest source of baseload power by 2050, along with solar and “a little wind,” and improved efficiency. “On the time horizon, I have a higher probability of coming up with the next generation recycling [of nuclear waste], and it’s manageable,” he said. He argued that the spent fuel from the last 40 years from every nuclear power plant in the United States could be put on one football field, stacked seven feet high. But he said his company’s calculations have found that even storage of 20 percent of carbon emissions would require ten cubic miles over the life of a power plant. [...]
Comment posted September 20, 2009 @ 2:56 am
I agree storing CO2 underground is not the way to go. Here are two websites that offer alternative solutions. http://www.swapsol.com offers process solutions that creates a market for CO2 and http://www.greatpointenergy.com/ourtechnology.php offers a truely Clean Coal process.
Pingback posted September 20, 2009 @ 2:47 pm
[...] Duke Energy CEO Questions Viability of ‘Clean’ Coal Technology, Future of Coal Jim Rogers, CEO of Duke Energy, raised questions on Wednesday about the viability of capturing and storing carbon dioxide emissions from coal plants underground, and suggested that coal may not even be part of the energy mix by 2050. “I actually can see a future where coal is not in the equation in 2050,” Rogers told reporters at an event in Washington. He argued that it’s unlikely that the United States will be able to develop and bring to scale carbon-capture-and-storage – often called “clean coal” technology. “I think there’s no way we can scale in this country,” he said. “It’s more likely that China will develop and bring CCS to scale. I’d like to be China for a day so we can get CCS done. They’re more likely to get it scaled and deployed than we are. We’re going to be buying their technology.” He also acknowledged that concerns about coal extraction methods like mountaintop removal may make coal more expensive in the near-term. “I’m under incredible pressure on moutaintop mining,” said Rogers. “Most of the coal we use in the southern part of the country is from mountaintop mining. I’m doing the math now and looking to determine my contracts and posing the question to my team, what if we made a policy decision that we’re not going to buy coal as a consequence of mountaintop mining.” The future of mountaintop removal grew less certain last week as the Obama administration put the breaks on 79 surface mining permits in Appalachia. Rogers also cited concerns about the amount of space and infrastructure that would be needed to make CCS a reality, as well as concerns about the viability of storage. Instead, he says he foresees nuclear rising to become the biggest source of baseload power by 2050, along with solar and “a little wind,” and improved efficiency. “On the time horizon, I have a higher probability of coming up with the next generation recycling [of nuclear waste], and it’s manageable,” he said. He argued that the spent fuel from the last 40 years from every nuclear power plant in the United States could be put on one football field, stacked seven feet high. But he said his company’s calculations have found that even storage of 20 percent of carbon emissions would require ten cubic miles over the life of a power plant. [...]
Pingback posted September 22, 2009 @ 4:16 pm
[...] comments are reported in this column by journalist Kate [...]
Comment posted April 29, 2010 @ 2:29 pm
Sea and land subject to the universe, but human life is subject to the jurisdiction of the supreme law of the command. – Cicero
cheap mbt shoes for sale MBT Voi Women Shoes Dark Red
Comment posted July 6, 2010 @ 7:18 am
Duke is also a member of the U.S. Climate Action Partnership, a coalition of environmental and business groups formed to build support for a climate bill that has played an active role in shaping legislation this year.
Pingback posted July 19, 2010 @ 8:21 pm
[...] be commercially available until at least 2020. Jim Rogers, the head of Duke Energy, recently expressed doubt about the feasibility of CCS. By Rogers’ calculations, storing just 20 percent of carbon emissions – nowhere near the goal [...]
Comment posted August 4, 2010 @ 4:22 am
clean coal? um… thats interesting, but will be turn out to be a disaster later on!?
Comment posted August 9, 2010 @ 1:40 pm
anyway, China will manage to paint all the green work EU and US did in last years in a very redish color. That part of the world will surely manage to undo all the green work that was done in the last years. So let's not worry for such small issues.
Comment posted August 14, 2010 @ 7:07 am
Great for any occasion in any season, stay cosy and comfy all year with a pair of
Sweet service,the honesty entertain guest,quality goods at reasonable prices
new louis vuitton
Louis Vuitton Women Handbags
Louis Vuitton Women Travel
Louis Vuitton Women Wallets
Louis Vuitton Men Bags
Louis Vuitton Men Travel
Louis Vuitton Men Wallets
discount louis vuitton
Comment posted August 17, 2010 @ 9:40 am
We are the nike shox shoes for cheap dealer in China, so if you want to choose a nike shox turbo
These brand nike shox looks quite clean and would probably be the perfect finishing touch to any outfit you can put together. Pick your pair up now. You will like them very much. from nike shox deliver
Get ready to glorify brand new nike shox shoes , these nike shox made for speed, agility and comfort for all four quarters of the game.from nike shox monster
welcome to come here to buy these great gucci shoes which is in high quality and reasonable price about gucci shoes
We have many style nike shox nz for you to pick up,what you have to do is choose the one you like most.
Make you feel stylish and charming if you wear our cheap womens nike shox r4. Take action quickly ,please.
By our professional service, you can buy your favorite nike shox oz from us with full confidence.
welcome to our online store to have a glance at timberland boots
the cheap timberland booots are hot sale now, so hurry up to pick up timberland roll top
thank you for selecting the great timberland boots from women's timberland 6 inchwelcome to our online store to have a glance at timberland boots
the cheap timberland booots are hot sale now, so hurry up to pick up timberland roll top
thank you for selecting the great timberland boots from women's timberland 6 inch
thank you for choosing these gucci shoes, and you can have a good shopping of gucci sneakers
Comment posted September 13, 2010 @ 6:41 pm
A Long Kept Secret For Generating Free Electricity is
Finally On The Open, And You'll Never Have To Pay A
Single Dime to the Power Company!
How would you like to create a generator which creates
free electric energy? Using our easy-to-follow guide,
you will be able create a Magnetic Power Generator which
creates absolutely free energy, and doesn't require any
resource like wind or solar energy to function, the
generator creates energy by itself and powers your home
for free. The generator works fully off the grid and is
built with .
Just leave your mail at
href=”http://myfreeenergynews.com/articles”> Jorit van
der Bogaerts Blog and follow the steps to receive
your magnetic generator DIY guide. All the raw materials
needed cost less than 100$. The materials needed are
very common, and can be easily found at your local
hardware store. Once you get our generator set-up and
working, you can even start building these generators
for your friends and family.
Comment posted December 10, 2010 @ 2:41 am
Sports Network YORK November 23, nike running shoes the Guangzhou Asian Amateur into the 11th chase day, athletes from all nations launched a angry antagonism of 30 titles, nike shox classic mens while Asian Amateur contest amphitheater already afresh become the protagonist, mens nike shox nzadherent a absolute of 8 amateur ablaze final, shox monsteras the Chinese sports appointment to accomplish objectives beyond the important weight of 200 gold, nike shox oz men’s the Chinese clue and acreage athletes to play with the adherence of the Chinese sports appointment aloft the assurance of the advantages of today in their own projects, did not let the appellation afflicted hands. nike shox oz shoes In the cutting arena, cheap nike o’nine shoes led by the adept Zhang Shan of China women’s aggregation swept the 2 skeet gold in the accomplished cutting bout is about to end, so beauteous achievement will assuredly poor all-embracing achievement of the Chinese cutting aggregation to save some face . nike shox r4 women Known as the “dream team” of the Chinese diving aggregation alternate to abide their “dream to win the Tour”,Shox torch running shoes afterward bygone afterwards demography two gold, today they are afresh all 2 gold in the bag. cheap nike shox r5 Coupled with the avant-garde pentathlon, fencing, nike shox si tennis absorbing on the achievement of Chinese athletes afresh with about absolute achievement for the Chinese sports appointment to accord 11 gold.
Continued acceptable drive of China’s gold badge and compared the achievement of South Korea and Japan, it is eye-popping, cheap nike shox turbo were alone accounted for a simple 3 Gold and 1 gold. cheap turbo shoesThe Chinese Taipei appointment in roller skating and cycling on the accomplished achievement of South Korea and Japan is to accroach the thunder, 4 gold fetched a individual day, nike shox turbo oz si let the appointment of Chinese Taipei is abounding of approaching achievement expectations.
As of the end of the 11th bout day, cheap o’nine shoes the Chinese sports appointment to 165 gold in additional abode advanced of South Korean sports appointment of the abundant advantages of abutting to 100 gold medals and the medals baronial top position, nike tl1 shoes no two amateur at the Chinese sports appointment will will accomplish “Beyond 183″ target. shox tl3 South Korea and Japan are aswell abiding in the aboriginal 2 and 3 position.
Based on afresh started agrarian beginning of clue and acreage events, men nike shox tl3 and sports accoutrement cast Nike-sponsored clue and acreage dominance, decidedly in the planning by the sports network’s “brand of Asian Amateur medals table”,mens nike shox r5 the Nike won 6 gold almanac for a additional day, “a individual day Cast Star “title, and sit bound in the top atom in China, nike shox tl1 shoes Li Ning is the cutting and diving ambit of gold medals in a individual day beneath the 4 gold, affliction and” Star of the cast today, “pass.
Comment posted September 7, 2011 @ 10:25 am
I have been trying to find the google for such information and just wanted to thank you for the post. BTW, just off topic, how can i download a copy of this theme? – Thanks
RSS feed for comments on this post.
Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.
rss