‘Helmand Is a Sideshow’

By
Monday, August 10, 2009 at 9:37 am

One of your two Afghanistan must-reads today is this amazing Yochi Dreazen/Peter Spiegel piece reporting Gen. Stanley McChrystal’s view of the war he’s conducting. There’s too much in here for just one blog post, so you really ought to read the whole thing. A major point: while McChrystal is said to be undecided over whether to request more troops, his next big operation, following the big Marine offensive in the Helmand river valley, will take place in Kandahar. Why?

“Helmand is a sideshow,” said the senior military official briefed on the analysis. “Kandahar is the capital of the south [and] that’s why they want it.”

That’s your Whiskey Tango Foxtrot moment right there. We sent thousands of Marines to a sideshow? Thousands of Marines, a meager complement of civilians, and barely any Afghan capacity? For a sideshow? A place McChrystal recently called a “critical area“? The general tells Dreazen and Spiegel that Helmand was, in fact, critical to focus on first, in order to disrupt the opium trade in the province that helps bankroll the Taliban. But then how could any halfway-responsible military official come away thinking that Helmand is a sideshow?

Perhaps even more alarming is this analysis:

Some U.S. military officials believe the Taliban have taken advantage of the American preoccupation with Helmand to infiltrate Kandahar and set up shadow local governments and courts throughout the city.

I’m open to an argument that because the Taliban seeks to hold critical territory, dispersing them isn’t the failure that it may appear at first glance. (That argument, though, also holds true for the Taliban’s efforts at repelling the Afghan government’s meager efforts at sowing its roots.) But that still calls for the constant harassment that only more troops can provide and the establishment of a political and economic alternative that only the Afghan government can provide. And here’s Anthony Cordesman of the Center for Strategic and International Studies, an adviser to McChrystal’s 60-day review, to say the U.S. needs to send 45,000 more troops to Afghanistan.

Follow Spencer Ackerman on Twitter


Comments

12 Comments

narciso
Comment posted August 10, 2009 @ 2:37 pm

Dreazen was one of those who had thrown in the towel on Iraq, even when the surge was underway, so I take his analysis at face value. That being said, I don't see them getting
45,000 troops out of this administration. General Jones, is always being outvoted by McDonough
and Rhodes


The Captain’s Journal » Helmand, Afghanistan is a Sideshow - Or Not
Pingback posted August 10, 2009 @ 11:46 pm

[...] interesting report from the WSJ (h/t Spencer Ackerman): “How many people do you bring in before the Afghans say, ‘You’re acting like [...]


rscott
Comment posted August 11, 2009 @ 4:01 pm

The “Taliban” don't “want” to take Kandahar and they are not “infiltrating” the city. They live there as they did during the Soviet occupation. And anyone who saw the city after the Soviet withdrawal can tell you, given the damage, it was clear that there was fighting there for the whole period of occupation.
Helmand “sideshow”? The occupation of Khanashin/Garmser was supposed cut the supply line from Pakistan into Helmand for the “Taliban”. This is an area of mostly sparse population (south of the Darwishan irrigation system that we helped build). Khanashin is mostly flood plain with small indigenious irrigation structures off the Hemand river…limited production. But our sideshow did not focus on the areas that produce most of the opium which is central Helmand: Nad-i-Ali, Marja and Shamalan (Nawa) and the “Taliban” apparently control Marja which is a populated area of settled farmers from the 1950s-60s on the irrigation system that we help build. Maybe we focused on the wrong area?


chenlifeng0810
Comment posted August 19, 2009 @ 1:44 pm

Only One word to characterize such a great post “WOW” that was a very interesting read
a href=”http://www.victoriaclassic.com”>Links of London Jewellery

Everything dynamic and very positively!
a href=”http://www.victoriaclassic.com”>Links of London Jewellery

I think I will try to recommend this post to my friends and family, cuz it’s really helpful.
a href=”http://www.victoriaclassic.com”>Links of London Jewellery

Just wanted to say great job with the blog, today is my first visit here and I’ve enjoyed reading your posts so far
a href=”http://www.victoriaclassic.com”>Links of London Jewellery

Thanks for article. Everytime like to read you.
a href=”http://www.victoriaclassic.com”>Links of London Jewellery


adidas outlet
Comment posted June 5, 2010 @ 12:55 am

Thanks for this interesting post,i like it.


Qianwenjie122581
Comment posted May 12, 2011 @ 5:18 am

??DVD????dvd ?????????????????dvd ????????????DVD???????????????????????dvd ????????DVD?????????????????????????dvd ??????????dvd???????dvd?????????dvd ?????????????????dvd ??????????????????????dvd???????????dvd ???????????????dvd????????dvd ??????????????????????????????????????dvd?????????????????????????????????????????????dvd??????????????DVD??????????????????????????DVD????????????????DVD???????????????????????????????????????DVD?????????????????????????????????DVD?????????????DVD?????????????????????????????DVD?????????????????????????????DVD?????????????1???????????


Christian Louboutin
Comment posted May 17, 2011 @ 7:56 am

Nice post.Thank you for taking the time to publish this information very useful!
Christian Louboutin Heels |
Louboutin Sale |
Christian Louboutin Sale |
Louboutin Flats |
Louboutin Pumps |
Louboutin Sandals |
Louboutin Slingbacks |
Jimmy Choo |
Yves Saint Laurent |
Manolo Blahnik |
Tory Burch


Rfopk Avtl
Comment posted May 17, 2011 @ 8:33 am

 I like it very much, thank you
???
???
???
???
???
???
???
???


Rfopk Avtl
Comment posted May 17, 2011 @ 8:33 am

 I like it very much, thank you 
cheap custom jerseys
custom jerseys
customized jerseys
cheap customized jerseys


nba nfl nhl mlb
Comment posted May 28, 2011 @ 12:52 am

I like it very much, thank you
运动鞋
篮球鞋
运动服


luoluying
Comment posted June 2, 2011 @ 2:40 am

アバクロンビー&フィッチ(Abercrombie&Fitch)アバクロ本国アメリカではハリウッドスターもアバクロ 店舗愛用する人気のブランド、Abercrombie&Fitchアバクロ 銀座アバクロのメンズダウンジャケットです。アバクロ 銀座 セールフード付きで、アバクロ 銀座 価格ジップの部分は比翼の付きのボタンになっているのでアバクロ 通販防寒対策はバッチリアバクロ サイズ★左腕にはロゴのアップリケが付いています。アバクロ福岡軽くてあたたかいダウンジャケットは寒い冬の必需品です。少量のみの入荷です。お早めに♪♪ホリスター【ブランド】 アバクロンビー&フィッチ(Abercrombie & Fitch) アバクロホリスター【サイズ】 S/M/L/XLホリスター 日本【素材】 シェル:ポリエステル100% 裏地:ポリエステル100% フホリスター サイズィリング:フェザー65% ダウン35% フィリング2:ポリエステル100%ホリスター 公式【スタイル】 メンズダウンベスト


RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.