The Not-So-Secret RNC Health Care Memo

Tuesday, July 21, 2009 at 2:02 pm

I hate to pour cold water on Sam Stein here, but the Republican National Committee health care memo from Alex Castellanos that I quote from in my story today is not new or secret. It went out on July 7, and the RNC has happily passed it on to reporters. Byron York makes similar hay out of the Castellanos memo in his story today, a breathless report about how the word “experiment” has risen from the GOP’s focus groups … something reported in this memo two full weeks ago.

This is something of a meta-story, an insight into how confident the RNC is about the health care debate. What gets reported at The Huffington Post as a “document obtained from a Democratic source” gets reported at the Examiner as a sneak peak inside the RNC, complete with a quote from an anonymous “strategist.” Of course, in both cases the RNC is getting reporters to write about what a crackerjack job it’s doing of framing the health care debate. Dana Milbank gets at the really interesting part of this, the man-behind-the-curtain message discipline, in his column about Michael Steele’s speech yesterday.

Anyway, here’s the memo:

To:  GOP Health Care Advocates

Re:  GOP Health Care Strategy

Fr:   Alex Castellanos

July 7, 2009


The research Chairman Steele has conducted at the RNC on health care has produced some significant new insights allowing us to advance GOP interests in the health care debate.

Following are a few observations based on that work, understanding these views do not necessarily reflect those of the Republican National Committee.

Where We Start

We are fighting something bigger than policies or plans.  The President and the Democrats are selling a cause.  Never mind that their plans will actually increase costs for individuals and the country:

Their cause is reducing health care costs.

To the public, reducing health care costs is health care reform.

    Quality:  As Wes Anderson has noted, people are satisfied with the quality of their health care.  Quality is not driving this debate.
    Access:  While everyone favors increasing access, access is only seen as a problem because of cost.  Access alone, unrelated to cost, is not driving this debate.
    Choice:  Americans believe they have choice; so much so that it makes health care anarchic, confusing, and chaotic.  Choice confusion, they tell us, allows the system to take advantage of them. Though more choice may be a solution, Americans do not perceive the lack of it as a problem.  If anything, they perceive the abundance of choice as a problem. Choice is not driving this debate.

Cost is driving this debate.

We cannot compete with their cause v. our policies.  We must compete with their cause v. our cause.

Our cause must be about what is driving this debate as well.  Our cause must also be bringing down health care costs.

The good news is that reducing costs consistent with free-market principles is not only the GOP mission, it is also a different and better way of doing it than the Administration is proposing.  We only need to congeal what have become our talking points into a cause.   This cup needs a handle.


We need to bring new language to this debate.  If we paint the house the same color, no one will notice anything has changed:

    We will still be the same, outdated Republicans who have no new ideas and oppose everything.  We have to bring something new to the game.
    We tested new language on the survey.

The GOP Cause

“Republicans are here today for a cause:  We want to help families and businesses get a hold of health care costs and bring them down.  Health care costs every family and every business too much. We all know that and we have to fix that.  Republicans see a new and better way of doing it.

“That’s why we are excited to join the growing number of Americans supporting the patient-centered health care reform movement.

    “We believe the patient-centered health care movement offers the best way to reduce health care costs, bottom-up, with patients and doctors in control.

“The old, top-down Washington-centered system the Democrats propose will empower Washington to restrict the cures and treatments your doctor can prescribe for you.

“Their Washington-centered system will end up costing trillions more, not less, and bankrupting the country.  This is what they do – a trillion here, a trillion there, pretty soon, our country ends up owing real money.

“It’s time to look at health care reform in a new way.

“The President sees the problem.  So do we.  He talks of making health care more affordable.  So do we.  But we have a completely different vision of how to fix it.

  • “They want a Washington-centered plan.
  • “We support patient-centered reforms.
  • “They want a big Washington Experiment with our health.
  • “We want common-sense simple fixes that will yield real results.
  • “They want to start building a closed health care system where Washington decides how much money will be saved on health care by controlling the doctors you can see and limiting the treatments and cures your doctor can prescribe.
  • “The patient-centered health care movement supports an open health-care system where patients and doctors make those decisions.
  • “They want a top-down system where bureaucrats far away end up deciding what health care is worth paying for and what isn’t, and for whom.
  • “We want a bottom-up, patient-centered system where control remains with your doctor and with you.
  • “They want political and artificial cost-reductions from Washington.
  • “We want to get politics out of health care not put more politics in.  We want common sense fixes not politically driven experiments.
  • “They want to empower a big Washington-run monopoly to control your health care.
  • “We say monopolies are just not natural.  Big monopolies are bad no matter who runs them, whether it is big government or big insurance businesses.

“Ultimately, with their Washington-centered plan, you won’t be able to keep the things you like about your health care:

  • “Obama’s plan will put government in charge of the doctors you can see and the types of treatment you can receive.
  • “Obama’s plan will cut hundreds of millions of dollars from seniors on Medicare.
  • “Obama’s plan will further bankrupt the country with trillions more in deficit spending.
  • “Obama’s plan will raise a lot of taxes on middle class families and businesses.  Taxing insurance, taxing sodas, even taxing health care benefits.  It doesn’t matter if your insurance charges you more through the front door in higher premiums or President Obama charges you more through the back door in higher taxes.  It’s the same thing.  You are going to pay a lot more.
  • “Obama’s plan will tempt your employer to dump you into a cheaper, government-run health care program.  End of the day, it doesn’t matter who takes your private coverage away, whether it’s your insurance company, the government or your employer:  When it’s gone it’s gone. You are going to lose your health coverage, and then you will see a reduction in the quality of your health care.

“In a nutshell, getting government more involved is not going to reduce costs. It will extend wait times, limit what you can get, cost you coverage; raise your taxes and the deficit.

“They tell us more Washington will make health care cost less.  Really?  Can we stop for a second and ask when Washington has made anything cost less?

“The truth is the Obama-Pelosi plan doesn’t save money.  Their Washington-centered plan, from Day One, costs a trillion more dollars.

“Common sense tells us, something is wrong here: Saving money on health care shouldn’t be more expensive.”

Slow Down, Mr. President

“The Obama Experiment with our health could change everything we like about our health care — and our economy.

“This big a risk, that risky an experiment is not something leaders on either side should rush through Congress in a few days or weeks.

“This is 20% of our economy.  This is our health care and our future. If we screw this up, it could last for generations.  And Congress is trying to do this in two months!  This should scare the living daylights out of all of us.

“Slow down, Mr. President.  We can’t afford to get health care wrong.

“President Obama is experimenting with America, too much, too soon, and too fast.”

Key Message Point:

Your browser may not support display of this image. Even voters who support a “public plan” think Obama and Congress are moving too fast, with reckless speed, risking a huge part of our economy and our health care, when they don’t know what reform would really bring.

If we slow this sausage-making process down, we can defeat it, and advance real reform that will actually help.

Key Message Point:  We’ve got to “SLOW DOWN the OBAMA EXPERIMENT WITH OUR HEALTH.”


The following is a menu of other bottom-up, common sense fixes (policy ideas) and new language that the patient-centered health care reform movement might support:

  • We support requiring/incentivizing doctors and hospitals to post pricing and outcomes.  In this day and age, why aren’t the cost of all tests, treatments, procedures and office visits — as well as effectiveness of treatments posted openly on the Internet?
  • We believe health insurance companies should compete with each other with simple, one-page contracts/summaries so insurance is simpler, cheaper, and fairer.  (Like many banks are doing w/ car or home loans).  And how about incentivizing insurance companies to have simple, one page reimbursement forms?
  • We believe doctors should be protected from frivolous, expensive lawsuits so they can work together with other doctors and patients in their communities to reduce unnecessary and expensive tests and procedures.
  • We want to change the law so you can take your health insurance with you if you have to change jobs (eliminating expensive and unnecessary insurance turnover).
  • We want to change the law so insurance companies can’t deny you coverage because of pre-existing conditions.
  • We want to cut out the “Washington health care middle-man,” reducing expensive bureaucracy to produce big health care savings.
  • We support (tax incentives?) new paperless, computer-age health care IT systems to reduce the cost of health care management as well as reduce medical mistakes.
  • Every American should have equal opportunity to get the best value and buy the cheapest insurance no matter where he lives or whom he works for. We want to change the law so any American can buy the lowest cost insurance available nationwide, not just in their states — whether from insurance companies, businesses, church groups, college alumni associations, or groups like the AARP, who often provide it less expensively.
  • The Wall-Mart way to bring costs down is better than the Washington way.  So we want to use consumer-buying power, also called “group buying power,” not Washington price-controls, to bring health care costs down.
  • We support effective prevention, wellness, and disease management programs because they will improve our health and save money.
  • We support bold new tax deductions for companies that develop new treatments and cures because that is smarter than paying for chronic long-term illnesses we can’t cure today.
  • We believe in bottom-up health care savings:  every American should get a tax deduction for their health insurance premiums.
  • We believe the working poor should get a refundable, advanceable tax credit to help them get health insurance.
  • We want to incentivize and expand practical, down-to-earth reforms that are already working and reducing health care costs all across America.  Safeway’s plan, which gives employees a stake in holding down health care costs, is a model.  Instead of cutting care or shifting costs to employees, Safeway has held health care costs flat the last 4 years, while it’s up 40% for the rest of corporate America.
  • We support special “too much paperwork” tax credits for small businesses, so they don’t have to bear the intolerable costs of filling out insurance forms or meeting government mandates and regulations.
  • We want to give small businesses the same cost-saving breaks big businesses get by helping them form small business health plans and small business health co-ops.
  • And no lifetime health care benefits and insurance for Congressmen who leave their jobs — unless and until everybody else in America has the same.

And From Here…

    “… and as I said throughout the campaign, change never begins from the top down. It begins from the bottom up.”  President Obama, Feb. 9, 2009

Unfortunately, what President Obama promised during the campaign, he has abandoned as President.  Instead of putting his faith in the American people and bringing change from the bottom up, he has put his trust in Washington and given us more, old, trickle-down big government. In health care and everywhere else, our President has given us nothing new.  It’s the same old thing, just bigger and more expensive:  One federal pill for every ill.

Such old thinking from such a young President is a disappointment and it is time to put it behind us.  The future belongs to those who really believe change comes from the bottom up — from the American people and not Washington, DC.

You can follow TWI on Twitter and Facebook.

Follow David Weigel on Twitter



ShortsandPants - GOP Memo Outlines Health Care Plan— How Screwed They Are
Pingback posted July 21, 2009 @ 3:02 pm

[...] famous genius PR man Alex Castellanos wrote an exciting memo to other high-ranking members of the GOP attempting to sort out some of the “confusion” [...]

Posts about Huffington Post as of July 21, 2009 » The Daily Parr
Pingback posted July 21, 2009 @ 4:40 pm

[...] Blaming California’s Black Voters for Prop 8 . Keep on keepin’ on RayRo.  xx Posted by thuy The Not-So-Secret RNC Health Care Memo – 07/21/2009 I hate to pour cold water on Sam Stein here , but the [...]

The Not-So-Secret RNC Health Care Memo | cheaper car insurance
Pingback posted July 21, 2009 @ 7:19 pm

[...] Read the rest here:  The Not-So-Secret RNC Health Care Memo [...]

Comment posted July 21, 2009 @ 10:08 pm

“The Wall-Mart way to bring costs down is better than the Washington way. “
WTF? Just offer them part time work with no benefits, and the problem is solved?
This is like a multipage exercise in projection and lame straw man arguments.
'“They want a top-down system where bureaucrats far away end up deciding what health care is worth paying for and what isn’t, and for whom.'
As opposed to the current one where the insurance companies control those decisions.
“Even voters who support a “public plan” think Obama and Congress are moving too fast”
Really? “High Broderism” in it's purest form.

Everything You Need to Know About RNC/Castellanos Healthcare Memo « Daily Dose
Pingback posted July 22, 2009 @ 12:23 am

[...] there is now some half-assed controversy about whether or not the Alex Castellanos memo that Sam Stein wrote about at HuffPo was a secret, or a double-super-secret, or free for public [...]

Comment posted July 22, 2009 @ 12:35 am

Yep. You just look at the Veterans' Health Administration (VHA) and tell everybody what a fine, responsive, wonderful job they're doing.

Hey, strangely, you ever practice medicine? You ever practice GOVERNMENT medicine? A lot of us old guys have done some time in uniform as medical officers, and we've seen the beast in full slaver.

I wish you “the Washington way” for whatever remains of your feeble little “Liberal” life. You obviously deserve it.

Meanwhile, see:

Washington Planner » Wednesday Required Reading
Pingback posted July 22, 2009 @ 1:06 pm

[...] David Weigel on the Not-So-Secret RNC Health Care Memo [...]

Comment posted July 23, 2009 @ 4:56 am

I just found your site and bookmarked it. I really hope everyone reads the Dana Milbank article. Thanks for pouring cold water on my little ass blog too.

Berkeley Place » Clem Snide Does Michael Jackson ! (and More!)
Pingback posted July 23, 2009 @ 8:41 am

[...] The Not-So-Secret RNC Health Care Memo | The Washington Independent [...]

Fact Check: Republicans Have No Health Care Plan « Daily Dose
Pingback posted July 23, 2009 @ 7:50 pm

[...] you still deserve to know why they’re lousy.Here are the “policy ideas” listed in Castellanos’ memo, with my commentary in bold. [...]

Bloggers Uniting for Health Care Reform « The Rumi Secret
Pingback posted July 29, 2009 @ 2:03 pm

[...] The Not-So-Secret RNC Health Care Memo [...]

Comment posted August 15, 2009 @ 10:15 pm

Have been reading , listening and comparing all these counter charges made. This article contains many points of misinformation, out and out garbarge. Since the election I have been waiting for the RNC to step up and be a part of the solution. I hate to change parties, but the RNC, Michael Steel are ruining what is left of the RNC. What these people are doing is a disgrace to old time Republicans. Come up with something already. I am tired of RNC being a laughing stock to this nation. Sure things were left in a mess after BUSH, but the RNC acts as though this is the end. It is not! The RNC has a lot to offer the American people, so lets begin here and now to meet the challenges that the American people need the RNC to address.
Stop running your base away!

Beware! Scare Tactics Are Coming!
Pingback posted August 28, 2009 @ 3:15 pm

[...] The actual Castellanos memo doesn’t seem to contain any allusions to secret plots, though it does, unsurprisingly, assert the standard Republican view that Obamacare will have the effect of driving up costs. But getting Grassley to disavow that paranoid notion reinforces the frame that everyone to his right, from Senate colleagues to the barking loon on the street with the hand-lettered “Obama is a Nazi” sign, is catching the 3:15 Conspiracy Express to Crazytown. [...]

Coburn Admits Republicans Are Just Trying To Kill The Bill: ‘The American People Want To Hear Us Say No’ | No Bull. news service.
Pingback posted December 19, 2009 @ 2:20 am

[...] final stages, Republicans are doing everything they can to slow the process down in order to “defeat” the Senate bill. In recent days, GOP senators have claimed they are working “in good [...]

adidas originals
Comment posted June 5, 2010 @ 1:21 am

Thanks for this interesting post,i like it.

Beauty Guide
Comment posted October 23, 2010 @ 12:38 pm

i am curious: is there any good thing resulting from such articles ? Where are the results ? Does anyone care about all this ?

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.