Former Interrogator Presses for McChrystal’s Stance on Abuse

By
Monday, June 01, 2009 at 6:04 pm
Lieut. Gen. Stanley McChrystal (defenselink.mil)

Army Lt. Gen. Stanley McChrystal (defenselink.mil)

A former military interrogator who contributed to the manhunt for a senior Iraqi terrorist has urged the Senate Armed Services Committee staff to press Lt. Gen. Stanley McChrystal, the Obama administration’s nominee to lead U.S. troops in the Afghanistan war, on what he knew about detainee abuse committed by troops in Iraq under his command when McChrystal goes before the panel Tuesday morning for his confirmation hearing.

“Gen. McChrystal, he was there in Iraq often, and he may have been separated from these things by couple layers [of subordinates] but it would’ve been his responsibility to know what was going on,” said Matthew Alexander, the pseudonym of a former Air Force interrogator whose non-coercive interrogations in 2006 helped identify and kill Abu Musab al-Zarqawi, then the leader of al-Qaeda in Iraq.

Illustration by: Matt Mahurin

Illustration by: Matt Mahurin

McChrystal helmed the Joint Special Operations Command from September 2003 until August 2008. From 2004 until 2006, an elite Special Operations-led task force, known eventually as Task Force 6-26, hunted Zarqawi and other high-valued terrorists in Iraq, and in the course of attempting to extract intelligence from detainees it acquired in that pursuit, some task force members were found to employ abusive interrogation techniques and even cruel treatment outside the interrogation chambers. In June 2004, the head of the Defense Intelligence Agency, Vice Adm. Lowell Jacoby, wrote to the top Pentagon intelligence official that Task Force 6-26 would send detainees to a temporary Baghdad holding facility “with burn marks on their backs,” and one of his interrogators “witnessed TF 6-26 officers punch a prisoner in the face to the point the individual needed medical attention.” According to a report by Human Rights Watch in 2006, McChrystal received Jacoby’s memo.

Additionally, at a Task Force facility known as Camp Nama, members of the task force were said to have “beat prisoners with rifle butts, yelled and spit in their faces and, in a nearby area, used detainees for target practice in a game of jailer paintball,” The New York Times reported. A pseudonymous former interrogator identified as “Jeff Perry” who was part of the Task Force in early 2004 told Human Rights Watch that “written authorizations were required for most abusive” interrogation techniques, “indicating that the use of these tactics was approved up the chain of command.” Perry further told the human rights organization that he saw McChrystal at Camp Nama “a couple of times. I know what he looks like.”

A few weeks ago, Alexander spoke with Mark Jacobson, a top Senate Armed Services Committee staffer, by phone for about half an hour, about McChrystal. While Alexander did not say that he worked with McChrystal while serving in Iraq as an interrogator — and he declined to specify in an interview that he was a member of the secretive Task Force 6-26 — he communicated that the Senate panel ought to clarify what knowledge McChrystal had of the abuse. “He needs to answer what happened in Iraq in 2006 [with] detainee treatment,” Alexander said. “I don’t know what he knew or didn’t know, but he needs to be asked.” He added that he gave the committee a list of questions to ask McChrystal.

Alexander, who wrote about his Iraq experiences in his 2008 memoir “How To Break a Terrorist” and who works with Human Rights First to oppose torture, recalled that several of his colleagues attempted to use coercive interrogation techniques in the Zarqawi hunt, despite Alexander’s concerns over their dubious efficacy. “When I would go up to my boss and say there’s a better way” to interrogate detainees without torturing them, “his answer would be ‘I’m sorry… because there’s something above me controlling the interrogators and those interrogators have carte blanche to interrogate how they want,” Alexander said. “I don’t know Gen. McChrystal’s involvement in that, [or that of] his staff or below him. But i do know that mentality was extremely counterproductive and almost cost us our chance at finding Zarqawi.”

He continued, “We found Zarqawi in spite of the way the task force did business.”

McChrystal’s confirmation hearing is scheduled for Tuesday morning, when he is slated to testify alongside two other senior military officers nominated for top-level commands. Dave Pollock, a spokesman for the Senate Armed Services Committee, declined to comment on committee staffers’ interactions with Alexander or any other officer or enlisted servicemember under McChrystal’s former command. As to why McChrystal was not testifying on his own — which raises questions as to whether senators will have sufficient time to explore McChrystal’s role in the task force’s abuse of detainees — Pollock said, “It has been [committee] practice to deal with as many military nominations as require a hearing and are ready at the same time because there is not time to have a separate hearing for each nomination.”

There are deep pockets of support within the counterinsurgency and broader military communities for McChrystal, who is considered one of the finest, smartest and most distinguished Army officers of his generation. A senior Army official who served with McChrystal in Iraq recently described him to TWI as “unflappable.” On the Small Wars Journal website, the online nexus of the counterinsurgency community, a pseudonymous former subordinate of McChrystal’s described him as “the Pope” and said, “America’s mission in Afghanistan couldn’t be in better hands.”

Marc Garlasco, a former Pentagon intelligence analyst who co-wrote Human Rights Watch’s report on Task Force 6-26, lent personal support to McChrystal’s nomination. While Garlasco said, “we really don’t understand what [McChrystal's] involvement at Camp Nama was,” he added, “That doesn’t say whether or not he’s the right man for the job in Afghanistan. Personally, I think he may be.” Garlasco noted out the volume of civilian casualties in Afghanistan caused by Special Operations Forces and said that “put[ting] someone in charge who knows Special Operations Forces may be a good thing” in terms of “reining in” such mistakes.

Alexander didn’t go that far, but said that even if McChrystal did bear responsibility for detainee abuse, he would hardly be the only senior officer placed in such a situation. “Are they going to find a general officer now that hasn’t had detainee abuse [occur] under theircommand?” he said. “The answer is no, but there aren’t general officers who stood up and said no. There are not senior officers who ever stood up and said ‘I refuse to use enhanced interrogation techniques because it’s cruelty and it’s unlawful.” (An exception is Central Command chief Gen. David Petraeus, who, as commander of U.S. forces in Iraq in 2007, instructed his troops not to abuse detainees.)

“We’re not going to find anybody who has a clean past,” Alexander said. “What I want to see now is someone who has reformed.”

Clarification: Alexander never used the word “torture” to describe any of the techniques he rejected using in Iraq. In the line  “’When I would go up to my boss and say there’s a better way” to interrogate detainees without torturing them,” the word torture is the author’s paraphrase, not Alexander’s quote.

Follow Spencer Ackerman on Twitter


Comments

8 Comments

Unsatisfactory Answers from General McChrystal « Dr Nasir Khan
Pingback posted June 3, 2009 @ 3:57 am

[...] the Air Force interrogator who led the successful effort to nail the head of Al Qaeda in Iraq, put it this way: “Gen. McChrystal, he was there in Iraq often, and he may have been separated from these things by [...]


The American Conservative » McChrystal Sails Through Flimsy Senate Questioning
Pingback posted February 6, 2010 @ 1:49 am

[...] to a report from Spencer Ackerman, writing on the Washington Independent’s blog Monday: A former military interrogator who contributed to the manhunt for a senior Iraqi terrorist [...]


The American Conservative » McChrystal Sails Through Flimsy Senate Questioning
Pingback posted February 6, 2010 @ 1:49 am

[...] to a report from Spencer Ackerman, writing on the Washington Independent’s blog Monday: A former military interrogator who contributed to the manhunt for a senior Iraqi terrorist [...]


christian louboutin shoes
Comment posted June 8, 2010 @ 2:00 pm

thanks for your shareing

Fashion legancy– we sell famous brand christian louboutin

100% Authentic, 50% discount cheap christian louboutin shoes.

christian louboutin shoes authentic hot sell online, welcome for retail and wholesale christian louboutin,
christian shoes, louboutin shoesorders.

24 hours/day customer service online, louboutin paypal accepted.

Hi, I like to lose weight!
thanks for your shareing
Recently so many people who want to lose weight choose this style shoes– mbt shoes!

we call it massaqi shoes, it is special design have lose weight function.

come to our website, and choose cheap mbt shoes online, 65% discount mbt shoes Cheap MBT Shoes sale online.

welcome for retail and wholesale mbt shoes orders.


ghd
Comment posted June 8, 2010 @ 2:05 pm

100% Authentic quality gurrantee,3 days free shipping.

World cup soccer jerseys is coming, hot sell

soccer jerseys

recently.

we are the wholesale jersey company from china, mainly selling

nfl jerseys

,

mlb jerseys

, and

cheap soccer jerseys

.

all our jerseys are made in embroidered. and top good quality. nowdays, we have so many customers doing

wholesale nfl jerseys

,

wholesale soccer jerseys

,

wholesale mlb jerseys

from us, especialy for the orders in usa, uk, australia, canada, and another euro

countries.

wecome for retail orders and wholesale orders of

cheap nfl jerseys

,

cheap mlb jerseys

, 2010 new nfl jerseys hot sell.

2010 new nfl jerseys

we believe we are your best choice.
http://www.jerseylink.com

hey, do u want to have a straightening hair style?

why are u hestitate!!

come to our website to buy

cheap ghd

,

ghd hair straighteners

online.

we are special ghd website for

ghd purple

,

ghd straighteners

.

welcome for

wholesale ghd

orders online. yours satisfied is our honor.

cheap ghd

cheap ghd hair straighteners

here, get much discount ghd.

surprise so much.

please chlick here to our website.

http://www.hghdoctor.com


That’s “Professor” McChristal to you, bud! « Hidden Cause, Visible Effects
Pingback posted September 14, 2010 @ 1:39 pm

[...] under his command. It might have looked like a major challenge because the accusations were leveled by a respected and successful military interrogator who opposed the ‘lil Patton pose of McChrystal. But when you are a practiced and successful [...]


cheap software
Comment posted May 27, 2011 @ 5:29 pm

lou xia de hao sha a Today I found a wonderful website,the site contained:
ルイヴィトン LouisVuitton
discount software

discount office software
cheap software

office 2010
Microsoft office 2010 professional 64 bit
Microsoft office 2011
microsoft office 2010

single office 2010

office 2007
office 2003 professional
office project standard 2010 32bit
office project standard 2010 64bit
office visio premium 2010 32bit
office visio premium 2010 64bit
office visio standard 2010 32bit
office powerpoint 2010 32bit
office outlook 2007

office access 2007
office access 2010 32bit
office access 2010 64bit
office powerpoint 2010 64bit
office project professional 2010 32bit
office project professional 2010 64bit
office visio professional 2010 32bit
office visio professional 2010 64bit
office 2010 professional plus 64bit
office 2010 professional 32bit

office excel 2010 32bit
office word 2010 32bit
office infopath 2010 32bit

office visio standard 2010 64bit
office infopath 2010 64bit
office word 2007
office visio professional 2007

office 2010 professional plus 32bit

office professional 2007
office excel 2007

office powerpoint 2007
office project professional 2007
office professional plus 2007
office 2010 standart 32bit
office 2010 standart 64bit
office 2011 for mac

office 2011 home business for mac

office outlook 2010 32bit

microsoft office outlook 2010 64bit

microsoft office onenote 2010 32bit

microsoft office onenote 2010 64bit

microsoft office 2010 professional 64bit

microsoft office word 2010 64bit
microsoft office home and student 2007

microsoft office 2007 standard
microsoft office 2007 ultimate

microsoft office 2007 enterprise

microsoft office excel 2010 64bit

microsoft office 2010 home and student 64bit
microsoft office 2010 home and business 32bit

microsoft office 2010 home and business 64bit

microsoft office 2010 home and student 32bit

ルイヴィトン LouisVuitton
バッグ
ルイヴィトン 2010-2011新着
ルイヴィトン その他
ルイヴィトン エピ
ルイヴィトン シマー
ルイヴィトン タイガ
ルイヴィトン ダミエ
ルイヴィトン ダミエ ジェア


ルイヴィトン

ダミエ?アズール
ルイヴィトン ダミエ?グラフィット
ルイヴィトン モノグラム
ルイヴィトン モノグラム?デニム
ルイヴィトン モノグ

ラム?マルチカラー
ルイヴィトン モノグラム?ミニ?ラン
ルイヴィトン ヴェルニ
uggルイヴィトンugg
ルイヴィトン


ルイヴィトン
ルイヴィトン

ルイヴィトン
ルイヴィトン
ルイヴィトン
ルイヴィトン


cheap software
cheap adobe
cheap

wedding dress
ルイヴィトン 小物
ルイヴィトン アクセサリー
ルイヴィトン エピ
ルイヴィトン シマー
ルイヴィトン ベルト
ルイヴィトン ヴェルニ
財布
ルイヴィトン 2011新着財布
ルイヴィトン その他
ルイヴィトン エピ
ルイヴィトン シマー
ルイヴィトン タイガ
ルイヴィトン ダミエ
ルイヴィトン ノグラム

?マルチカラー
ルイヴ

ィトン モノグラム
ルイ

ヴィトン ヴェルニ
ルイヴィトン

手帳
腕時


腕時計


腕時計

時計
腕時計
腕時計
腕時計
腕時計
Discount

software
Discount software
wholesale wedding dress
シャネル CHANEL
シャネル バッグ
シャネル その他
シャネル キャビア
シャネル レザー
シャネル レザー&装飾
シャネル 化粧ポーチ
シャネル 小物
シャネル 財布
グッチ GUCCI

グッチ バッグ
グッチ

小物
グッチ 財布

腕時計
オメガ(OMEGA)
コンステレーショ


ピードマスター
スペシャリティーズ
デビル
プラネットオーシャン

カルティエ CARTIER
その他
サントス

タンク

フランセーズ
バロンブルー
パシャC
ロードスター

コルムCORUM
シャネル CHANEL
ショパール CHOPARD
ゼニス(ZENITH)
パネライ(PANERAI)


フランクミュラー FRANCK MULLER
ブライトリングBREITLING
ブルガリ BVLGARI
その他
アショーマ


エルゴン


ソロテ

ンポ

ィアゴノ
ディアゴノ アルミニウム
ディアゴノ スクーバ
ディアゴノ

スポーツ
ディアゴノ ラバー
ディアゴノGMT
ブルガリブルガリ

ロレックス(ROLEX)
デイトナ
ボーイズ
メンズ
レディース

IWC


CHANELシャネル
JUICY
エドハーディー(Ed

Hardy)
オフ

ィシャルサイト D&G
クリスチャンルブタンCL
グッチ (Gucci)
スニーカー
女スリッパ
女長靴
女靴
男スリッパ
運動靴
革靴

コーチ(COACH)
ジミーチュウ(Jimmy Choo)
ディオール (Dior)

ボッテガ ヴェネタ

Bottega Veneta
バッグ
小物
財布

コーチ COACH
コーチバッグ
コーチ財布

プラダ PRADA

プラダ バッグ

ルメス Hermes
エル

メス バッグ
エル

メス 小物
エルメ

ス 財布
Wedding Dresswedding dresses with

color(2010)
wedding dresses(2010)
wedding dresses(2011)

Plus Size

Wedding DressPlus Size Wedding Dresses(2010)

Couture

Wedding DressCouture Wedding Dresses(2010)

Formal Wedding

DressInformal Wedding Dresses(2010)

Wedding Bridesmaid DressesWedding Bridesmaid Dresses

2010
Discount Bridesmaid Dress
Junior Bridesmaids DressesJunior bridesmaids dresses(2010)
Maternity Bridesmaid DressMaternity Bridesmaid dresses(2010)
Cocktail DressCocktail

Dresses(2010)
Prom &Evening DressProm

dresses(2010)

Sexy Evening Dress
Stardoll Dress
Quinceanera

DressQuinceanera

Dresses(2010)
Mother of the

Bride DressMother of the Bride Dresses(2010)
Flower Girl

DressFlower girl

dresses(2010)
Wedding AccessoriesJacket
Petticoat
Real ProductsReal Wedding dress
cheap adobe software

adobe creative suite 5 master collection
adobe creative suite 5 master collection for mac
cheap sony software

sony vegas pro 10 software
autodesk autocad 2011 software
autodesk maya 2011 32 bit software
autodesk maya 2011 for mac software
cheap intuit software

intuit quickbooks pro 2011
adobe photoshop cs5 extended software
adobe acrobat 9 professional software
Adobe Flash Builder 4 Premium


ルイヴィトン 財布
Comment posted May 29, 2011 @ 10:28 am

ルイヴィトン 2011新着財布


RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.