rssPrepaid ‘Cash Cards’ a Pricey Way to Swipe
Friday, March 27, 2009 at 6:00 am
- 63 Comments
readydebit.com
Americans are more conscious of debt than ever. Feeling burned by bank overdraft fees of $30 or more, or by credit-card interest rates that can top 25 percent, a growing number of consumers are turning to prepaid, reloadable “cash cards.” These cards have confidence-boosting names like “READYdebit” and “UPside.” They feature the logo of Visa, Mastercard or Discover and are issued by companies like Green Dot Corporation and NetSpend. These cards are sold at retail locations as well as check-cashing storefronts and money-wiring outlets.
For a large segment of users, primarily low- and moderate-income consumers, these cards function as ersatz bank accounts. These consumers are referred to as the “unbanked” in card-industry parlance. With a cash card, those with poor credit or too little money to meet banks’ minimum account balance requirements can participate in the retail transactions most people take for granted: ordering goods online, paying for items with a quick swipe, getting cash on demand from ATMs.
It’s a fast-growing niche; in 2007, $2.1 billion was placed on reloadable prepaid cards, according to Mercator Advisory Group, a market research company that specializes in the payment industry. By 2011, Mercator predicts that number will jump to $14 billion. Green Dot Corporation, one of the big players in the field, says they’ve seen a whopping 50 percent year over year growth rate in terms of dollars loaded onto their cards.
For those who lack the discipline or the know-how to manage their money, these cards can be a lifesaver in that they don’t let a user spend more than he or she has. It’s impossible to overdraw and accrue fines, or tap into a line of credit that could spiral into a nightmare of debt. But while these cards may be beneficial for consumers who want to avoid the temptation of spending beyond their means, they are no panacea. Reloadable prepaid cards have several key differences of which users might not be aware.
First, they’re expensive to use. “The basic situation with prepaid debit cards is that they tend to come with a multiplicity of fees, which make them relatively expensive to use,” said Jean Ann Fox, director of financial services for the Consumer Federation of America. With the exception of Wal-Mart’s $3 Moneycard, most cost $9 or $10 to acquire, and most charge maintenance fees of up to $10 per month after that. Since issuers like to advertise the fact that they don’t charge overdraft fees, it could be easy for a consumer to overlook the fact that everything from withdrawing cash at an ATM to calling customer service costs a couple of bucks. Adding more money to a card can also cost $5 or so if the transaction takes place at a retailer or Western Union location; the place doing the reloading takes a cut, too. Some issuers waive the reload fee if a user has their employer direct-deposit their earnings onto the card.
Want to cancel a prepaid card? Even that could cost $15 in fees. If a user has less than that left on a card, the cardholder can either spend what’s left without going over the amount, which would cause the card to be declined, reload it — for a fee— or just abandon the balance. As a rule, most card companies don’t charge for online account activity, but that might not be a viable option for lower-income unbanked consumers.
The unbanked also might not have the financial wherewithal or feel empowered enough to ask some hard questions about the security of their money after they make a deposit on the card, a prospect that worries consumer advocates and watchdog groups. “It’s an important question given the dollar volume flowing into these cards,” said Sarah Jane Hughes, a commercial law professor at Indiana University. “Whether or not there really is something standing behind those cards is very important.”
Americans with money in ordinary bank accounts are protected by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation. If the bank goes bankrupt, the government makes good on depositors’ money up to $250,000. Prepaid card users don’t necessarily have that assurance. It’s common for cash card issuers to pool all their customers’ funds into one account, which could easily go over the $250,000 maximum. What’s more, this kind of set-up would make the card issuer rather than their consumers the FDIC beneficiary if the bank failed.
At the request of advocacy group Consumers Union, the FDIC recently clarified that a provision called pass-through insurance would come into play with regard to prepaid cards. Essentially, this means that the cardholder rather than the card company would get paid. However, the FDIC also spelled out a series of steps card issuers have to take for pass-through insurance to be initiated — and there’s no law that says the card companies have to take those steps. According to Gail Hillebrand, senior attorney at Consumers Union, it’s up to issuers to do the right thing when it comes to protecting their users’ cash.
“The great victory is that these funds can be FDIC insured to the individual,” said Michelle Jun, staff attorney at Consumers Union. “The problem now is it’s unclear if all these cards are set up in this fashion, and it’s not entirely clear which ones are FDIC insured.” In other words, it’s buyer beware.
Lastly, although these cards carry the logo of brands like Visa, Mastercard or Discover, they are not credit cards. While this distinction may help users from getting — or staying — in debt, it also means that no matter how judiciously they use their card or manage their money, these efforts won’t go towards raising their credit score. In a marketplace where lenders are demanding high credit ratings, not building a positive credit history can be a real handicap. Relying exclusively on prepaid cards means the unbanked will have a tougher time breaking out of that categorization. As much as Americans want temptation-busting tools that protect them from the lure of expensive play-now-pay-later loans, opting out of the system via prepaid spending devices carries some hefty costs of its own.
Martha C. White is a freelance journalist in New York. She frequently writes on economics.
63 Comments
Comment posted March 27, 2009 @ 4:06 am
The banks have figured out another way to rip off consumers at the lowest end of the economic spectrum. I remember going to a bank in elementary school, in the 1970s to learn how they help people. Now it's a big money grab, milking every cent out of consumers that is possible.
Please, Obama, can we have bank and credit card reform that is sweeping and strict? The banks, and especially credit card companies, operate like mafia sharks.
Pingback posted March 27, 2009 @ 9:54 am
[...] Prepaid ‘Cash Cards’ Are a Pricey Way to Swipe – The Washington Independent.comAmericans are more conscious of debt than ever. Feeling burned by bank overdraft fees of $30 or more, or by credit-card interest rates that can top 25 percent, a growing number of consumers are turning to prepaid, reloadable “cash cards.” These [...]
Pingback posted March 27, 2009 @ 12:02 pm
[...] Prepaid ‘Cash Cards’ Are a Pricey Way to Swipe – The Washington Independent.comAmericans are more conscious of debt than ever. Feeling burned by bank overdraft fees of $30 or more, or by credit-card interest rates that can top 25 percent, a growing number of consumers are turning to prepaid, reloadable “cash cards.” These [...]
Pingback posted March 27, 2009 @ 4:14 pm
[...] Prepaid ‘Cash Cards’ Are a Pricey Way to Swipe – The Washington Independent.comAmericans are more conscious of debt than ever. Feeling burned by bank overdraft fees of $30 or more, or by credit-card interest rates that can top 25 percent, a growing number of consumers are turning to prepaid, reloadable “cash cards.” These [...]
Pingback posted March 27, 2009 @ 5:21 pm
[...] Prepaid ‘Cash Cards’ Are a Pricey Way to Swipe – The Washington Independent.comAmericans are more conscious of debt than ever. Feeling burned by bank overdraft fees of $30 or more, or by credit-card interest rates that can top 25 percent, a growing number of consumers are turning to prepaid, reloadable “cash cards.” These [...]
Pingback posted March 27, 2009 @ 7:02 pm
[...] Prepaid ‘Cash Cards’ Are a Pricey Way to Swipe – The Washington Independent.comAmericans are more conscious of debt than ever. Feeling burned by bank overdraft fees of $30 or more, or by credit-card interest rates that can top 25 percent, a growing number of consumers are turning to prepaid, reloadable “cash cards.” These [...]
Pingback posted March 27, 2009 @ 7:04 pm
[...] Prepaid ‘Cash Cards’ Are a Pricey Way to Swipe – The Washington Independent.comAmericans are more conscious of debt than ever. Feeling burned by bank overdraft fees of $30 or more, or by credit-card interest rates that can top 25 percent, a growing number of consumers are turning to prepaid, reloadable “cash cards.” These [...]
Pingback posted March 27, 2009 @ 7:27 pm
[...] Prepaid ‘Cash Cards’ a Pricey Way to Swipe – The Washington Independent.comAmericans are more conscious of debt than ever. Feeling burned by bank overdraft fees of $30 or more, or by credit-card interest rates that can top 25 percent, a growing number of consumers are turning to prepaid, reloadable “cash cards.” These [...]
Comment posted March 27, 2009 @ 7:01 pm
MoneyManager Card is less expensive than many bank accounts with a single fee of 50 cents to send a check by mail. Uses Allpoint Network's 37,000 nationwide atm's for completely free unlimited atm withdrawals. Allows transfers to high interest savings accounts via ach at no charge also. Since these cards are impossible to overdraw no $30 to $40 overdraft fees optimized from the top down by your friendly bank either.
http://www.moneymanagercard.com/pricing.php
Pingback posted March 27, 2009 @ 8:44 pm
[...] Prepaid ‘Cash Cards’ Are a Pricey Way to Swipe – The Washington Independent.comAmericans are more conscious of debt than ever. Feeling burned by bank overdraft fees of $30 or more, or by credit-card interest rates that can top 25 percent, a growing number of consumers are turning to prepaid, reloadable “cash cards.” These [...]
Pingback posted March 27, 2009 @ 9:24 pm
[...] Prepaid ‘Cash Cards’ Are a Pricey Way to Swipe – The Washington Independent.comAmericans are more conscious of debt than ever. Feeling burned by bank overdraft fees of $30 or more, or by credit-card interest rates that can top 25 percent, a growing number of consumers are turning to prepaid, reloadable “cash cards.” These [...]
Pingback posted March 28, 2009 @ 12:28 am
[...] Prepaid ‘Cash Cards’ a Pricey Way to Swipe – The Washington Independent.comAmericans are more conscious of debt than ever. Feeling burned by bank overdraft fees of $30 or more, or by credit-card interest rates that can top 25 percent, a growing number of consumers are turning to prepaid, reloadable “cash cards.” These [...]
Pingback posted March 28, 2009 @ 12:58 am
[...] Prepaid ‘Cash Cards’ a Pricey Way to Swipe – The Washington Independent.comAmericans are more conscious of debt than ever. Feeling burned by bank overdraft fees of $30 or more, or by credit-card interest rates that can top 25 percent, a growing number of consumers are turning to prepaid, reloadable “cash cards.” These [...]
Pingback posted March 28, 2009 @ 2:52 am
[...] Prepaid ‘Cash Cards’ a Pricey Way to Swipe – The Washington Independent.comAmericans are more conscious of debt than ever. Feeling burned by bank overdraft fees of $30 or more, or by credit-card interest rates that can top 25 percent, a growing number of consumers are turning to prepaid, reloadable “cash cards.” These [...]
Comment posted March 28, 2009 @ 6:27 am
I have been using a prepaid debit card called Pr1macard MasterCard since I was kicked out of my bank for too many overdrafts and bounced checks (I lost my job 9 months ago and fell on hard times). My bank was charging me a $25.00 per month cycle fee for not maintaining a balance of over $1,000, on top of the overdraft fee's at $15.00 a piece.
Though I agree prepaid debit cards do have a lot of small fee's associated with transactions, it is a lot cheaper then what I was paying in the above mentioned bank fees.
Pingback posted March 28, 2009 @ 11:38 am
[...] Prepaid ‘Cash Cards’ a Pricey Way to Swipe – The Washington Independent.comAmericans are more conscious of debt than ever. Feeling burned by bank overdraft fees of $30 or more, or by credit-card interest rates that can top 25 percent, a growing number of consumers are turning to prepaid, reloadable “cash cards.” These [...]
Pingback posted March 28, 2009 @ 10:02 pm
[...] Prepaid ‘Cash Cards’ a Pricey Way to Swipe – The Washington Independent.comAmericans are more conscious of debt than ever. Feeling burned by bank overdraft fees of $30 or more, or by credit-card interest rates that can top 25 percent, a growing number of consumers are turning to prepaid, reloadable “cash cards.” These [...]
Pingback posted March 29, 2009 @ 1:46 am
[...] Prepaid ‘Cash Cards’ a Pricey Way to Swipe – The Washington Independent.comAmericans are more conscious of debt than ever. Feeling burned by bank overdraft fees of $30 or more, or by credit-card interest rates that can top 25 percent, a growing number of consumers are turning to prepaid, reloadable “cash cards.” These [...]
Pingback posted March 29, 2009 @ 3:51 am
[...] Prepaid ‘Cash Cards’ a Pricey Way to Swipe – The Washington Independent.comAmericans are more conscious of debt than ever. Feeling burned by bank overdraft fees of $30 or more, or by credit-card interest rates that can top 25 percent, a growing number of consumers are turning to prepaid, reloadable “cash cards.” These [...]
Pingback posted March 29, 2009 @ 7:46 am
[...] Prepaid ‘Cash Cards’ a Pricey Way to Swipe – The Washington Independent.comAmericans are more conscious of debt than ever. Feeling burned by bank overdraft fees of $30 or more, or by credit-card interest rates that can top 25 percent, a growing number of consumers are turning to prepaid, reloadable “cash cards.” These [...]
Pingback posted March 29, 2009 @ 2:57 pm
[...] Prepaid ‘Cash Cards’ a Pricey Way to Swipe – The Washington Independent.comAmericans are more conscious of debt than ever. Feeling burned by bank overdraft fees of $30 or more, or by credit-card interest rates that can top 25 percent, a growing number of consumers are turning to prepaid, reloadable “cash cards.” These [...]
Pingback posted March 29, 2009 @ 3:51 pm
[...] Prepaid ‘Cash Cards’ a Pricey Way to Swipe – The Washington Independent.comAmericans are more conscious of debt than ever. Feeling burned by bank overdraft fees of $30 or more, or by credit-card interest rates that can top 25 percent, a growing number of consumers are turning to prepaid, reloadable “cash cards.” These [...]
Pingback posted March 29, 2009 @ 11:43 pm
[...] Prepaid ‘Cash Cards’ a Pricey Way to Swipe – The Washington Independent.comAmericans are more conscious of debt than ever. Feeling burned by bank overdraft fees of $30 or more, or by credit-card interest rates that can top 25 percent, a growing number of consumers are turning to prepaid, reloadable “cash cards.” These [...]
Pingback posted March 30, 2009 @ 5:20 am
[...] Prepaid ‘Cash Cards’ a Pricey Way to Swipe – The Washington Independent.comAmericans are more conscious of debt than ever. Feeling burned by bank overdraft fees of $30 or more, or by credit-card interest rates that can top 25 percent, a growing number of consumers are turning to prepaid, reloadable “cash cards.” These [...]
Pingback posted March 30, 2009 @ 6:16 pm
[...] Prepaid ‘Cash Cards’ a Pricey Way to Swipe – The Washington Independent.comAmericans are more conscious of debt than ever. Feeling burned by bank overdraft fees of $30 or more, or by credit-card interest rates that can top 25 percent, a growing number of consumers are turning to prepaid, reloadable “cash cards.” These [...]
Pingback posted March 30, 2009 @ 6:54 pm
[...] Prepaid ‘Cash Cards’ a Pricey Way to Swipe – The Washington Independent.comAmericans are more conscious of debt than ever. Feeling burned by bank overdraft fees of $30 or more, or by credit-card interest rates that can top 25 percent, a growing number of consumers are turning to prepaid, reloadable “cash cards.” These [...]
Pingback posted March 30, 2009 @ 6:54 pm
[...] Prepaid ‘Cash Cards’ a Pricey Way to Swipe – The Washington Independent.comAmericans are more conscious of debt than ever. Feeling burned by bank overdraft fees of $30 or more, or by credit-card interest rates that can top 25 percent, a growing number of consumers are turning to prepaid, reloadable “cash cards.” These [...]
Pingback posted March 31, 2009 @ 12:38 am
[...] Prepaid ‘Cash Cards’ Are a Pricey Way to Swipe – The Washington Independent.comAmericans are more conscious of debt than ever. Feeling burned by bank overdraft fees of $30 or more, or by credit-card interest rates that can top 25 percent, a growing number of consumers are turning to prepaid, reloadable “cash cards.” These [...]
Pingback posted March 31, 2009 @ 4:31 am
[...] Prepaid ‘Cash Cards’ a Pricey Way to Swipe – The Washington Independent.comAmericans are more conscious of debt than ever. Feeling burned by bank overdraft fees of $30 or more, or by credit-card interest rates that can top 25 percent, a growing number of consumers are turning to prepaid, reloadable “cash cards.” These [...]
Pingback posted March 31, 2009 @ 1:10 pm
[...] Prepaid ‘Cash Cards’ a Pricey Way to Swipe – The Washington Independent.comAmericans are more conscious of debt than ever. Feeling burned by bank overdraft fees of $30 or more, or by credit-card interest rates that can top 25 percent, a growing number of consumers are turning to prepaid, reloadable “cash cards.” These [...]
Pingback posted March 31, 2009 @ 5:40 pm
[...] Prepaid ‘Cash Cards’ Are a Pricey Way to Swipe – The Washington Independent.comAmericans are more conscious of debt than ever. Feeling burned by bank overdraft fees of $30 or more, or by credit-card interest rates that can top 25 percent, a growing number of consumers are turning to prepaid, reloadable “cash cards.” These [...]
Pingback posted March 31, 2009 @ 9:19 pm
[...] Prepaid ‘Cash Cards’ Are a Pricey Way to Swipe – The Washington Independent.comAmericans are more conscious of debt than ever. Feeling burned by bank overdraft fees of $30 or more, or by credit-card interest rates that can top 25 percent, a growing number of consumers are turning to prepaid, reloadable “cash cards.” These [...]
Pingback posted April 1, 2009 @ 1:43 am
[...] Prepaid ‘Cash Cards’ a Pricey Way to Swipe – The Washington Independent.comAmericans are more conscious of debt than ever. Feeling burned by bank overdraft fees of $30 or more, or by credit-card interest rates that can top 25 percent, a growing number of consumers are turning to prepaid, reloadable “cash cards.” These [...]
Pingback posted April 1, 2009 @ 3:37 pm
[...] Prepaid ‘Cash Cards’ Are a Pricey Way to Swipe – The Washington Independent.comAmericans are more conscious of debt than ever. Feeling burned by bank overdraft fees of $30 or more, or by credit-card interest rates that can top 25 percent, a growing number of consumers are turning to prepaid, reloadable “cash cards.” These [...]
Pingback posted April 1, 2009 @ 11:40 pm
[...] Prepaid ‘Cash Cards’ Are a Pricey Way to Swipe – The Washington Independent.comAmericans are more conscious of debt than ever. Feeling burned by bank overdraft fees of $30 or more, or by credit-card interest rates that can top 25 percent, a growing number of consumers are turning to prepaid, reloadable “cash cards.” These [...]
Pingback posted April 1, 2009 @ 11:40 pm
[...] Prepaid ‘Cash Cards’ Are a Pricey Way to Swipe – The Washington Independent.comAmericans are more conscious of debt than ever. Feeling burned by bank overdraft fees of $30 or more, or by credit-card interest rates that can top 25 percent, a growing number of consumers are turning to prepaid, reloadable “cash cards.” These [...]
Pingback posted April 2, 2009 @ 12:54 am
[...] Prepaid ‘Cash Cards’ Are a Pricey Way to Swipe – The Washington Independent.comAmericans are more conscious of debt than ever. Feeling burned by bank overdraft fees of $30 or more, or by credit-card interest rates that can top 25 percent, a growing number of consumers are turning to prepaid, reloadable “cash cards.” These [...]
Pingback posted April 2, 2009 @ 1:35 am
[...] Prepaid ‘Cash Cards’ a Pricey Way to Swipe – The Washington Independent.comAmericans are more conscious of debt than ever. Feeling burned by bank overdraft fees of $30 or more, or by credit-card interest rates that can top 25 percent, a growing number of consumers are turning to prepaid, reloadable “cash cards.” These [...]
Pingback posted April 2, 2009 @ 10:26 pm
[...] Prepaid ‘Cash Cards’ Are a Pricey Way to Swipe – The Washington Independent.comAmericans are more conscious of debt than ever. Feeling burned by bank overdraft fees of $30 or more, or by credit-card interest rates that can top 25 percent, a growing number of consumers are turning to prepaid, reloadable “cash cards.” These [...]
Pingback posted April 2, 2009 @ 11:20 pm
[...] Prepaid ‘Cash Cards’ Are a Pricey Way to Swipe – The Washington Independent.comAmericans are more conscious of debt than ever. Feeling burned by bank overdraft fees of $30 or more, or by credit-card interest rates that can top 25 percent, a growing number of consumers are turning to prepaid, reloadable “cash cards.” These [...]
Comment posted April 8, 2009 @ 8:11 am
Maybe I'm being naive. I have a checking account with a major national bank, there is no minimum balance, and they give me a free check card that withdraws money from my checking account. When I use the check card to buy something, I stick the receipt in my wallet and write it down in my checkbook later, because I basically live from paycheck to paycheck. If you don't want minimum balance fees, go to a bank that doesn't have them. If you don't want to overdraw your account, keep track of how much money is in there. Am I missing something here?
Comment posted May 10, 2009 @ 6:35 am
It's a sad state of affairs when you need a credit card for the sake of establishing a positive credit history so you can get more credit later. It means you're distilled to your FICO essence at an early age, and the banks have their hooks in you for life.
Comment posted May 10, 2009 @ 1:35 pm
It's a sad state of affairs when you need a credit card for the sake of establishing a positive credit history so you can get more credit later. It means you're distilled to your FICO essence at an early age, and the banks have their hooks in you for life.
Comment posted September 9, 2009 @ 1:17 pm
Great article. Actually, you are right. Most of us nowadays prefer prepaid credit card because it is more cheaper interest rates. But the problem w/ prepaid, everytime you swipe it you'll be paying a dollar. What if you swipe it 35x so you pay like $35.
Comment posted September 9, 2009 @ 2:04 pm
Credit card is the key to a persons shopping needs but too much spending and not paying your debt ruins your whole life. That's why the card company open a new door for paying, this one is a prepaid card. Sounds like a cellphone load. I like this because it is more cheaper compare to a regular credit card.
Comment posted September 30, 2009 @ 4:47 am
I follow Martha C. White.She is a great journalist…
Comment posted October 23, 2009 @ 4:15 am
I like this card because it easy to handle than a regular credit card. This a detailed post which I love to read because of the information that I get from the content on this post.
Comment posted November 10, 2009 @ 2:09 am
Hello!
I like your article Ms. Martha C. White :)
Thanks for sharing your thoughts…
Comment posted November 10, 2009 @ 7:09 am
Hello!
I like your article Ms. Martha C. White :)
Thanks for sharing your thoughts…
Comment posted April 29, 2010 @ 11:14 am
that card is really helpful to those people who earn money by a month, so if they don't have money they can use visa card to buy those miscellaneous things that we need in our every day life
Comment posted June 13, 2010 @ 11:52 am
I think cash cards are great. I personally hate having cash, especially change, but love having cards. I just think it’s so much easier. This is a great idea and I think would be especially nice for teenagers. Make em feel cool :p
Comment posted July 6, 2010 @ 6:58 am
I like this card because it easy to handle than a regular credit card. This a detailed post which I love to read because of the information that I get from the content on this post.
Comment posted July 31, 2010 @ 1:23 am
It's a sad state of affairs when you need a credit card for the sake of establishing a positive credit history so you can get more credit later. It means you're distilled to your FICO essence at an early age, and the banks have their hooks in you for life.
Comment posted July 31, 2010 @ 1:23 am
It's a sad state of affairs when you need a credit card for the sake of establishing a positive credit history so you can get more credit later. It means you're distilled to your FICO essence at an early age, and the banks have their hooks in you for life.
Comment posted August 4, 2010 @ 6:43 am
wondering who will use this kind of card!? we all do have credit cards, rite?
Comment posted August 5, 2010 @ 12:40 pm
make em feel robots. I like that i am out of that country and i afford living in a more realistic world, without guns, CC's , and other useless inventions ( if we take a moment and think ). Dont we just love to complicate things…
Pingback posted November 30, 2010 @ 10:57 am
[...] From the Washington Independent by Martha C. White [...]
Comment posted January 22, 2011 @ 12:51 pm
It became obvious that the hackers were after cash as European customers began reporting small purchases made with credit cards that had been used on Lush …
Comment posted February 24, 2011 @ 4:30 am
We do a lot of farmer’s markets, and we had no way to accept credit cards,” Fain said. “I had been researching different devices to take credit cards and they were so expensive. When Square came out, it felt like ‘We can’t lose. …
Comment posted July 11, 2011 @ 4:40 pm
In today’s competitive corporate race it is essential for any company or organization to design, develop and implement a custom corporate identity system…..
Logo Design Firms
Cheap Logo Design
RSS feed for comments on this post.
Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.
