Judicial Partisanship Awards

By
Thursday, July 31, 2008 at 8:14 am
U.S. Supreme Court of the United States (WDCpix)

U.S. Supreme Court of the United States (WDCpix)

Who are the real activists on the U.S. Supreme Court? Do Republican appointees differ from Democratic appointees? How much? Are federal judges political?

I have been studying these issues with several colleagues, including Thomas Miles, an economist and lawyer at the University of Chicago Law School, for a number of years now. One big question: Do judges show a political bias? We also wanted to see what any bias might tell us about how judges might rule in the future – under, for example, an Obama or McCain administration.

Illustration by: Matt Mahurin

Illustration by: Matt Mahurin

We catalogued thousands of judicial decisions — well over 20,000– to analyze this. We looked for partisan bias by studying whether and when judges vote to uphold decisions of federal agencies, in areas including environmental protection, labor, telecommunications, discrimination and occupational safety.

We investigated which members of the Supreme Court are the most partisan — in that they are more likely to vote in favor of conservative agency decisions than liberal ones. (Because Chief Justice John Roberts and Justice Samuel Alito have been on the court only a short time, we did not include them because we had too little data.) We wanted to see if some justices are more political in their voting patterns than others – and also learn something about how future administrations are likely to fare in the Supreme Court.

We used a simple test to decide whether an agency’s decision should be counted as liberal or conservative. If a decision was challenged by a public-interest group, like the Sierra Club or Environmental Defense, we counted it as conservative. If it was challenged by a corporation, like Exxon or General Motors, we counted it as liberal.

We used this method because the relevant question is not whether an agency’s decision is liberal or conservative in the abstract — it is how and why that decision is challenged in its context. In addition, though we had many students working on this, we read every decision ourselves, making adjustments when our method led to errors.

We wanted to know: Is it true that liberal justices are more partisan than conservatives? Who is the most partisan member of the Supreme Court? Who the most neutral?

Our answers: Justice Clarence Thomas wins the Partisanship Award. Justice Anthony M. Kennedy wins the Neutrality Award.

Here are the results:

Table 1: Partisan Voting on the Supreme Court

Justice Gap between liberal and conservative agency decisions

( in percentage points)

Type of Agency Decision Favored
Clarence Thomas 46 Conservative
John Paul Stevens 40 Liberal
Antonin Scalia 27 Conservative
Stephen Breyer 26 Liberal
Ruth Bader Ginsburg 23 Liberal
William Rehnquist 21 Conservative
Sandra Day O’Connor 14 Conservative
David Souter 14 Liberal
Anthony Kennedy 1

This information does not tell us everything we need to know. Thomas shows the strongest partisan bias, but is he also an activist? Does he vote to strike down agency decisions at a high rate? To test for judicial activism and judicial restraint, we examined all the data to find which justices are most likely to strike down agency decisions.

It turns out that Breyer wins the award for Judicial Restraint. Surprisingly, the award for Judicial Activism goes to . . . Justice Scalia. Here are the results:

Table 2: Activism and on the Supreme Court

Justice Rate of upholding agency decisions (percentage points)
Breyer 82
Souter 77
Ginsburg 74
Stevens 71
O’Connor 68
Kennedy 67
Rehnquist 64
Thomas 54
Scalia 52


While the Supreme Court gets the most attention, the lower courts are also important in determining the meaning of national law and shaping national policy. To analyze their behavior, we decided to focus on how Republican and Democratic appointees approach the decisions of the Environmental Protection Agency and the National Labor Relations Board.

We asked whether Republican appointees are less likely to vote to uphold liberal decisions from those agencies, than conservative ones; and whether Democratic appointees show the opposite pattern. Here, too, we defined agency decisions as liberal or conservative depending on who challenged them. If a labor union or an environmental group made the challenge, for example, the decision was labeled conservative. If a company challenged a labor ruling or an environmental regulation, the decision was characterized as liberal. We again read all the decisions here to test our characterizations.

The answer: Partisan voting is pervasive on the lower federal courts.

When the agency’s decision is conservative, Republican appointees are far more likely to vote to uphold it than are Democratic appointees. Democratic appointees show the same bias: When the agency’s decision is liberal, Democratic appointees are much more likely to vote to uphold it than are Republican appointees.

Republican appointees vote to uphold liberal agency decisions at a significantly lower rate than conservative agency decisions. Democratic appointees vote to uphold liberal agency decisions at a significantly higher rate than conservative agency decisions.

This evidence offers three important lessons.

First, widespread conservative complaints about “liberal judicial activism” should be taken with many grains of salt. If we ask how often the justices vote to strike down agency decisions, Scalia and Thomas, the most conservative members of the Supreme Court, show the most activist voting patterns. By contrast, the justices commonly described as “liberal” are the least activist.

Of course, there are other measures of what makes a judge “activist,” and I do not claim that our method cannot be challenged, but it is useful to offer some statistical tests, which can ensure that critics are not building their conclusions into their definitions.

Second, partisan voting is a serious problem in the federal judiciary. If the EPA issues a regulation that is aggressive in cleaning the air, or if the National Labor Relations Board resolves a dispute in favor of a union, a panel that consists solely of Republican appointees is unusually inclined to strike it down. That’s indefensible. No one should approve of a situation in which the fate of an environmental regulation depends on whether a lower court panel consists of one, two or three Republican appointees.

Third and perhaps most important, federal agencies in an Obama or McCain administration are likely to make a number of decisions that are more liberal than those of the Bush administration. Many decisions will ultimately be challenged in federal court — and the Republican-appointed judges who dominate the federal bench could well prove to be a big obstacle. On the Supreme Court, for example, Scalia and Thomas might be joined, much of the time, by Roberts and Alito. On key occasions, Kennedy might probably join them as well.

The lower federal courts could prove an even more serious barrier. Those courts have been stocked with appointees of Presidents Ronald Reagan, George H.W. Bush and George W. Bush. The voting behavior of appointees has been clear: They show a distinctive tendency to strike down agency decisions that do not follow a conservative line.

Here, then, is a major warning for the next administration – and a potential problem for democracy itself.

Cass R. Sunstein is Felix Frankfurter Professor of Law at Harvard Law School, as of Aug. 1. He will be the Harry Kalven Visiting Professor at University of Chicago Law School in January 2009. His most recent book, which he co-wrote with Richard Thaler, is “Nudge: Improving Decisions about Health, Wealth, and Happiness.” His books include “Are Judges Political? An Empirical Analysis of the Federal Judiciary” and “The Second Bill of Rights: FDR’s Unfinished Revolution and Why We Need It More Than Ever.”

Categories & Tags:

Comments

69 Comments

moondancer
Comment posted August 2, 2008 @ 7:08 pm

While I am sure there is substance in you post, I can’t concentrate on it as I seethe at your call for turning a cheek to the criminal and in my mind treasonous behavior of the Bush regime. To do nothing is to put your imprimatur on their misdeeds.


calljohnpeterson
Comment posted August 2, 2008 @ 1:56 pm

Getting back to the article and point of the extensive research, I thought it was well done. No matter what your other views, the statistics appear overwhelming.


uncleernie
Comment posted August 2, 2008 @ 10:38 am

Funny how the well known fascists John (the enforcer) Roberts and Sammy (the coat-hanger) Alito both Smirky appointees were left off the list because they would skew the results toward a more honest article so I’m not surprised by the conclusion. I am surprised that Sunstein could get this nonsense published!


johnbo
Comment posted August 1, 2008 @ 9:52 pm

Sunstein’s cautious approach towards doing ANYTHING about the most criminal administration in modern American history is truly troubling and makes anything he publishes suspect. He, like the Democratic leadership in the House and Senate, seems prone to look the other way while the Imperial Presidency of George the Lessor ignores the laws and shreds the Constitution. We can be assured that the powers that run this country aren’t loosing any sleep worrying about an Obama Presidency with someone like Sunstein as a close advisor. Look forward to more of the same old sh*t. Their campaign slogan should be “Change we can just dream about”.


msaroff
Comment posted August 1, 2008 @ 1:09 pm

Dr. Sunstein, while I appreciate the work done here, I am more concerned about your other work, specifically that endorsing expansive views of surveillance and torture of detainees.

Additionally, I think that your comments which seem to suggest that lawbreaking by Bush administration officials should be swept under the rug to the maximum degree possible are very troubling.


msaroff
Comment posted August 1, 2008 @ 8:09 am

Dr. Sunstein, while I appreciate the work done here, I am more concerned about your other work, specifically that endorsing expansive views of surveillance and torture of detainees.

Additionally, I think that your comments which seem to suggest that lawbreaking by Bush administration officials should be swept under the rug to the maximum degree possible are very troubling.


johnbo
Comment posted August 1, 2008 @ 4:52 pm

Sunstein's cautious approach towards doing ANYTHING about the most criminal administration in modern American history is truly troubling and makes anything he publishes suspect. He, like the Democratic leadership in the House and Senate, seems prone to look the other way while the Imperial Presidency of George the Lessor ignores the laws and shreds the Constitution. We can be assured that the powers that run this country aren't loosing any sleep worrying about an Obama Presidency with someone like Sunstein as a close advisor. Look forward to more of the same old sh*t. Their campaign slogan should be “Change we can just dream about”.


uncleernie
Comment posted August 2, 2008 @ 5:38 am

Funny how the well known fascists John (the enforcer) Roberts and Sammy (the coat-hanger) Alito both Smirky appointees were left off the list because they would skew the results toward a more honest article so I'm not surprised by the conclusion. I am surprised that Sunstein could get this nonsense published!


calljohnpeterson
Comment posted August 2, 2008 @ 8:56 am

Getting back to the article and point of the extensive research, I thought it was well done. No matter what your other views, the statistics appear overwhelming.


moondancer
Comment posted August 2, 2008 @ 2:08 pm

While I am sure there is substance in you post, I can't concentrate on it as I seethe at your call for turning a cheek to the criminal and in my mind treasonous behavior of the Bush regime. To do nothing is to put your imprimatur on their misdeeds.


serf
Comment posted September 11, 2008 @ 6:58 pm

The WSJ posted a guest opinion arguing that (non-conservative) judges have been activists. I tried to point out that the opinion lacked a factual basis and cited this page, twice. It has not been posted by the moderators yet. WSJ reserves the right to not post links to web sites with “objectionable conduct.” Maybe that includes opposing views?

see http://online.wsj.com/article/SB122108996856421…


KYJurisDoctor
Comment posted May 5, 2009 @ 10:30 am

Interesting, indeed, but probably not surprising.


ds
Comment posted May 24, 2009 @ 7:07 pm

BULL CRAP


ds
Comment posted May 25, 2009 @ 2:07 am

BULL CRAP


discount Louis vuitton
Comment posted September 8, 2010 @ 1:44 am

It turns out that Breyer wins the award for Judicial Restraint. Surprisingly, the award for Judicial Activism goes to . . . Justice Scalia. Here are the results:


Dog bark collar
Comment posted February 21, 2011 @ 3:57 pm

Thanks for the post. This keeps me informed about the topic.


3709503
Comment posted September 5, 2011 @ 9:48 pm

3709503 beers on the wall. sck was here


Cheap Jordan shoes,Nike air max shoes,Supra Shoes,UGG Boots,CL pumps,Polo,Lacoste t-shirts,True Religion Jeans,LV,Coach handbags,brand name sunglasses,NFL,NHL,MLB,NBA Jerseys
Comment posted September 6, 2011 @ 1:36 am

Great post. I was checking continuously this blog and I’m impressed! Very useful information specially the last part I care for such information a lot. I was seeking this certain info for a long time. I will keep the attention of your blog. Thank you and best of luck.


Cheap Jordan shoes,Nike air max shoes,Supra Shoes,UGG Boots,CL pumps,Polo,Lacoste t-shirts,True Religion Jeans,LV,Coach handbags,brand name sunglasses,NFL,NHL,MLB,NBA Jerseys
Comment posted September 6, 2011 @ 2:15 am

Great post. I was checking constantly this blog and I am impressed! Very useful information specially the last part I care for such information much. I was seeking this particular information for a very long time. I will keep the attention of your blog. Thank you and have a good day.


Bo Gingrich
Comment posted September 6, 2011 @ 3:09 am

The Zune concentrates on being a Portable Media Player. Not a web browser. Not a game machine. Maybe in the future it’ll do even better in those areas, but for now it’s a fantastic way to organize and listen to your music and videos, and is without peer in that regard. The iPod’s strengths are its web browsing and apps. If those sound more compelling, perhaps it is your best choice.


Inter Birthday
Comment posted September 6, 2011 @ 4:14 am

You made some decent factors there. I looked on the web for the problem and located most people will associate with with your website.


stratford upon avon hotels
Comment posted September 6, 2011 @ 4:33 am

I precisely had to appreciate you once again. I do not know the things that I could possibly have accomplished in the absence of those information shared by you over such problem. It actually was an absolute fearsome matter in my view, but viewing this skilled mode you handled that made me to leap with gladness. I am grateful for your guidance and as well , sincerely hope you recognize what an amazing job your are providing instructing the others using your web page. Most probably you haven’t got to know all of us.


fermanagh motorcycle dealers
Comment posted September 6, 2011 @ 5:20 am

I intended to put you one little bit of remark to help give many thanks the moment again with the remarkable secrets you’ve shared in this article. This has been really surprisingly open-handed of you to give openly all a number of people might have supplied for an e book to help with making some profit for themselves, primarily given that you might have done it in the event you considered necessary. The tips as well acted to be a easy way to be certain that someone else have similar keenness like my very own to learn lots more related to this problem. I think there are several more pleasurable instances in the future for folks who browse through your blog.


opticians in berkshire
Comment posted September 6, 2011 @ 6:57 am

After I initially commented I clicked the -Notify me when new comments are added- checkbox and now each time a comment is added I get four emails with the identical comment. Is there any manner you’ll be able to remove me from that service? Thanks!


Ela Schuffert
Comment posted September 6, 2011 @ 7:41 am

This is exactly what I’ve been searching for all day. Do not stop updating your blog.


wells solicitors
Comment posted September 6, 2011 @ 9:38 am

I needed to create you this tiny observation to help thank you as before for all the lovely views you’ve featured above. It has been simply extremely open-handed of people like you giving easily all a number of us would have supplied for an e-book to get some cash for themselves, most notably considering the fact that you could possibly have tried it in the event you desired. These good ideas likewise served to become great way to be sure that someone else have the same fervor like mine to realize great deal more on the topic of this issue. I know there are millions of more fun opportunities up front for those who start reading your website.


XXX Movies
Comment posted September 6, 2011 @ 9:44 am

As a Newbie, I am permanently searching online for articles that can support me. Thank you


Paleo Diet Food List
Comment posted September 6, 2011 @ 10:45 am

Extremely informative and great complex body part of articles , now that’s user pleasant (:.


tinnitus cure
Comment posted September 6, 2011 @ 11:18 am

Hi! Do you know if they make any plugins to assist with SEO? I’m trying to get my blog to rank for some targeted keywords but I’m not seeing very good success. If you know of any please share. Appreciate it!


tinnitus remedies
Comment posted September 6, 2011 @ 11:45 am

Hmm it appears like your blog ate my first comment (it was extremely long) so I guess I’ll just sum it up what I submitted and say, I’m thoroughly enjoying your blog. I as well am an aspiring blog blogger but I’m still new to everything. Do you have any helpful hints for rookie blog writers? I’d really appreciate it.


pavlinas kidz place
Comment posted September 6, 2011 @ 11:46 am

Great write-up, I am normal visitor of one’s site, maintain up the excellent operate, and It is going to be a regular visitor for a lengthy time.


amateur porn tube
Comment posted September 6, 2011 @ 12:55 pm

a lot of thanks for telling!. “Truth is typically the top vindication against slander.” by Abraham Lincoln..


site hoster lookup
Comment posted September 6, 2011 @ 1:20 pm

Nice read, I just passed this onto a colleague who was doing some research on that. And he just bought me lunch since I found it for him smile Therefore let me rephrase that: Thank you for lunch! “We have two ears and only one tongue in order that we may hear more and speak less.” by Laertius Diogenes.


Replica Watches
Comment posted September 6, 2011 @ 2:30 pm

The crux of your writing whilst sounding agreeable originally, did not work perfectly with me personally after some time. Someplace within the sentences you were able to make me a believer but only for a very short while. I still have got a problem with your jumps in assumptions and you might do nicely to fill in those breaks. In the event that you actually can accomplish that, I will surely be impressed.


Eye glasses Colorado Springs
Comment posted September 6, 2011 @ 2:46 pm

Real superb information can be found on web blog.


Auto repair anaheim hills
Comment posted September 6, 2011 @ 2:58 pm

Its good as your other articles :D, appreciate it for posting.


mini repair fountain valley
Comment posted September 6, 2011 @ 3:17 pm

Thanks for every other wonderful post. The place else may anybody get that kind of info in such an ideal approach of writing? I have a presentation subsequent week, and I am on the look for such info.


Hcg Diet Review
Comment posted September 6, 2011 @ 3:23 pm

Gday,don`t forget to optimize your posts for the very best possible search engine ranking


leather camera bags
Comment posted September 6, 2011 @ 4:25 pm

I simply desired to say thanks once again. I am not sure the things that I could possibly have taken care of without these ideas discussed by you regarding my subject. It became a real traumatic concern in my position, but witnessing a expert mode you solved it made me to weep over fulfillment. I will be happy for your work as well as believe you are aware of a great job you are always accomplishing teaching people thru your web page. I’m certain you haven’t come across all of us.


web design
Comment posted September 6, 2011 @ 6:22 pm

hello there and thank you for your info – I’ve definitely picked up something new from right here. I did however expertise several technical points using this site, as I experienced to reload the site a lot of times previous to I could get it to load correctly. I had been wondering if your web hosting is OK? Not that I’m complaining, but sluggish loading instances times will often affect your placement in google and can damage your high quality score if ads and marketing with Adwords. Anyway I’m adding this RSS to my e-mail and can look out for a lot more of your respective exciting content. Ensure that you update this again very soon..


lavorare miami
Comment posted September 6, 2011 @ 6:33 pm

Hey! I know this is kinda off topic nevertheless I’d figured I’d ask. Would you be interested in trading links or maybe guest writing a blog post or vice-versa? My blog goes over a lot of the same topics as yours and I believe we could greatly benefit from each other. If you might be interested feel free to send me an e-mail. I look forward to hearing from you! Wonderful blog by the way!


compro oro
Comment posted September 6, 2011 @ 6:50 pm

Hello there! This is kind of off topic but I need some guidance from an established blog. Is it tough to set up your own blog? I’m not very techincal but I can figure things out pretty fast. I’m thinking about creating my own but I’m not sure where to begin. Do you have any ideas or suggestions? Cheers


Greg Obst
Comment posted September 6, 2011 @ 7:22 pm

Fantastic blog you have got here. You’ll discover me looking at your stuff often. Saved!


Tamara Buscher
Comment posted September 6, 2011 @ 7:32 pm

I’d have to check with you here. Which is not something I usually do! I enjoy reading a post that will make people think. Also, thanks for allowing me to comment!


Barbra Fountaine
Comment posted September 6, 2011 @ 7:36 pm

You made some decent points there. I looked on the internet for the issue and found most individuals will go along with with your website.


Kiyoko Dorsch
Comment posted September 6, 2011 @ 7:49 pm

I was very pleased to find this web-site.I wanted to thanks for your time for this wonderful read!! I definitely enjoying every little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you blog post.


Lavette Behnke
Comment posted September 6, 2011 @ 7:56 pm

Youre so cool! I dont suppose Ive read anything like this before. So nice to find somebody with some original thoughts on this subject. realy thank you for starting this up. this website is something that is needed on the web, someone with a little originality. useful job for bringing something new to the internet!


Rema Oppenheim
Comment posted September 6, 2011 @ 7:58 pm

There are some interesting points in time in this article but I don’t know if I see all of them center to heart. There is some validity but I will take hold opinion until I look into it further. Good article , thanks and we want more! Added to FeedBurner as well


World Famous Waste of Time
Comment posted September 6, 2011 @ 9:17 pm

I gotta favorite this web site it seems handy handy


Mickey Glud
Comment posted September 6, 2011 @ 10:24 pm

Hands down, Apple’s app store wins by a mile. It’s a huge selection of all sorts of apps vs a rather sad selection of a handful for Zune. Microsoft has plans, especially in the realm of games, but I’m not sure I’d want to bet on the future if this aspect is important to you. The iPod is a much better choice in that case.


PDF to ePub Reader
Comment posted September 6, 2011 @ 10:43 pm

Only a smiling visitant here to share the love (:, btw great design. “Better by far you should forget and smile than that you should remember and be sad.” by Christina Georgina Rossetti.


ceramic
Comment posted September 6, 2011 @ 11:38 pm

Good write-up, I’m regular visitor of one’s site, maintain up the nice operate, and It’s going to be a regular visitor for a long time.


haute hippie
Comment posted September 7, 2011 @ 1:06 am

I like this website very much, Its a really nice position to read and obtain information. “Some people are so afraid to die that they never begin to live.” by Henry Van Dyke.


android games
Comment posted September 7, 2011 @ 1:28 am

Only wanna comment on few general things, The website pattern is perfect, the content is very good. “The reason there are two senators for each state is so that one can be the designated driver.” by Jay Leno.


cheap mbt shoes
Comment posted September 7, 2011 @ 1:46 am

I simply wanted to write a quick note to be able to appreciate you for all of the amazing ideas you are posting at this site. My time-consuming internet investigation has at the end of the day been honored with brilliant knowledge to share with my company. I would say that most of us readers actually are definitely endowed to exist in a magnificent site with many lovely professionals with interesting things. I feel somewhat grateful to have discovered your entire site and look forward to some more enjoyable minutes reading here. Thanks again for all the details.


Discount Moncler Sweater
Comment posted September 7, 2011 @ 2:10 am

learn all regarding the powerful way you give insightful


MBT Sport shoes
Comment posted September 7, 2011 @ 3:50 am

The subsequent time I learn a blog, I hope that it doesnt disappoint me as much as this one. I imply, I do know it was my option to learn, but I really thought youd have one thing fascinating to say. All I hear is a bunch of whining about one thing that you could repair when you werent too busy searching for attention.


karpacz
Comment posted September 7, 2011 @ 6:37 am

This is amazing poste for a long time i ‘ve ever read. Can i have your contact please? I have somthing to communicate. Merci.


Gale Law
Comment posted September 7, 2011 @ 7:25 am

Right here is the sort of information I’ve long been looking for. Thanks for posting this information.


Vance
Comment posted September 7, 2011 @ 8:04 am

I’m not sure where you’re getting your information, but good topic. I needs to spend some time learning much more or understanding more. Thanks for wonderful information I was looking for this information for my mission.


karpacz
Comment posted September 7, 2011 @ 8:26 am

Im not going to say what everyone else has already said, but I do want to comment on your knowledge of the topic. Youre truly well-informed. I cant believe how much of this I just wasnt aware of. Thank you for bringing more information to this topic for me. Im truly grateful and really impressed.


caudalimetro
Comment posted September 7, 2011 @ 10:07 am

I do believe all the ideas you’ve introduced on your post. They’re very convincing and will certainly work. Nonetheless, the posts are too quick for starters. May you please lengthen them a little from next time? Thank you for the post.


unable to open connection to server
Comment posted September 7, 2011 @ 10:38 am

I truly appreciate this post. I have been looking all over for this! Thank goodness I found it on Bing. You have made my day! Thx again!


Seminole County Homes For Sale
Comment posted September 7, 2011 @ 11:21 am

wonderful submit, very informative. I ponder why the other specialists of this sector do not understand this. You must continue your writing. I am confident, you have a huge readers’ base already!


Mbt Shoes Clearance
Comment posted September 7, 2011 @ 12:17 pm

The following time I read a blog, I hope that it doesnt disappoint me as much as this one. I imply, I do know it was my option to read, but I really thought youd have one thing attention-grabbing to say. All I hear is a bunch of whining about something that you may repair in the event you werent too busy looking for attention.


Replica Watches
Comment posted September 7, 2011 @ 12:47 pm

Almost all of whatever you assert happens to be supprisingly accurate and it makes me ponder why I had not looked at this with this light previously. This particular article really did turn the light on for me as far as this subject matter goes. However at this time there is actually one point I am not too comfortable with and while I attempt to reconcile that with the central theme of your position, let me see just what all the rest of your readers have to point out.Well done.


Buy twitter followers
Comment posted September 7, 2011 @ 12:49 pm

I the efforts you have put in this, regards for all the great content.


Sex toys
Comment posted September 7, 2011 @ 12:53 pm

I’ve recently started a web site, the info you provide on this web site has helped me tremendously. Thank you for all of your time & work.


dresses online Australia
Comment posted September 7, 2011 @ 3:16 pm

Only wanna input that you have a very decent website , I enjoy the style and design it actually stands out.


RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.