Feds Fail to Prevent Police Abuse

Monday, March 09, 2009 at 1:00 pm
U.S. Border Patrol agent Gabriel Pacheco walks back to his vehicle along the border fence with its concertino wire topping it Monday Nov. 17, 2008 in San Diego. The government is planning to add concertino wire to additional fenced areas.The Border Patrol is completing installation of razor-sharp wires atop a 5-mile stretch of fence, a move that authorities credit for a sharp drop in attacks on agents by rock-, bottle- and brick-wielding assailants from Mexico. Critics say the prison-style fence is a menacing eyesore.  (AP Photo/Lenny Ignelzi)

U.S. Border Patrol agent Gabriel Pacheco walks back to his vehicle along the border fence with its concertino wire topping it Monday Nov. 17, 2008 in San Diego. The government is planning to add concertino wire to additional fenced areas. The Border Patrol is completing installation of razor-sharp wires atop a 5-mile stretch of fence, a move that authorities credit for a sharp drop in attacks on agents by rock-, bottle- and brick-wielding assailants from Mexico. Critics say the prison-style fence is a menacing eyesore. (AP Photo/Lenny Ignelzi)

When Maricopa County Sheriff Joe Arpaiao parades undocumented immigrants in pink underwear before news cameras, puts them to work on chain gangs and houses them in sweltering “tent cities” behind coils of barbed wire, it’s easy to dismiss him as a rogue public official who’s taken legitimate law enforcement a bit too far.

Illustration by: Matt Mahurin

Illustration by: Matt Mahurin

But Arpaio’s publicity-seeking stunts in Arizona are enabled by a federal policy that deputizes police officers to enforce U.S. immigration laws, with few rules and little supervision to prevent exploitation. Recent reports and testimony reveal that the program, known as 287(g) for the section of the law that created it, and intended to target terrorism and violent crimes, has encouraged officers to arrest and imprison people who look foreign for such minor infractions as driving with a broken tail-light, carrying an open alcoholic beverage container, or fishing without a license.

The result has been such gruesome treatment as forcing a pregnant woman arrested for an alleged traffic violation to endure labor in shackles; deporting a disabled U.S. citizen to Mexico where he was reduced to begging on the streets; and jailing an immigrant who’d called the police to save her sister from domestic violence.

Many more immigrants may have been deported under the program despite being lawful residents or having legitimate claims to remain in the United States. The citizenship of people with birth certificates from midwives in Texas, for example, is now being questioned by federal authorities.

Although the 287(g) program has existed for more than a decade, it’s only recently come under serious scrutiny. At least three separate studies plus Congressional testimony in just the last month have concluded that a lack of regulations or clear directions to local law enforcement and insufficient oversight by federal authorities has permitted the program’s widespread abuse.

Created in 1996, the 287(g) program expanded significantly starting in 2006, as local law enforcement embraced it in response to community complaints about undocumented immigrants and Congress’sl failure to pass comprehensive immigration reform. Between 2006 and 2008 it received $60 million, training more than 950 state and local law enforcement officers in 67 agencies across the country, resulting in the arrests of at least 43,000 immigrants, reports the General Accountability Office in a study released last week. More than half were ultimately ordered to leave the country.

Although Immigration and Customs Enforcement officials said the program was intended to address “serious crime . . . committed by removable aliens,” the GAO reported that, of 29 local agencies reviewed, four said they used their 287(g) authority to process for removal immigrants stopped for minor violations such as speeding, carrying an open container of alcohol and urinating in public, “contrary to the objective of the program.”

One sheriff told the GAO investigators that his understanding was that “287(g)-trained officers could go to people’s homes and question individuals regarding their immigration status even if the individual is not suspected of criminal activity” — which is not the purpose of the program.

Such actions by local police actually undermine law enforcement rather than helping it, said Thomas Manger, the police chief of Montgomery County, Maryland at a hearing of the House Committee on Homeland Security last Wednesday. Manger, who chairs an association representing the 56 largest police departments in the country, said that many police chiefs don’t participate in the program because it “undermines the trust and cooperation with immigrant communities that are essential elements of community policing,” while overwhelming local police departments and draining their resources that should be spent on arresting criminals, not enforcing the immigration laws.

The GAO also reported that many local sheriffs told GAO investigators that they believed the program had helped improve public safety. But the government had not required the kind of consistent and systematic reporting that would reveal whether that was actually true. The evidence therefore remains largely anecdotal.

Charles Jenkins, sheriff of Frederick County, Maryland, for example, testified last Wednesday that the program had helped him combat an increase in crime that he claimed “can be tied directly to the unchecked flow of illegal immigrants through our southern borders with Mexico.” He said the program “has allowed us to identify and place into removal proceedings nine members of . . . notoriously violent gangs” as well as “a Nicaraguan military-trained sniper and a Salvadorean guerrilla trained in knife fighting.”

What Jenkins failed to explain, however, is why he needed the immigration laws to make those arrests, since all of those are criminal offenses. What’s more, local law enforcement is already authorized to check the immigration status of anyone in jail for criminal activity and to report them to the immigration authorities.

“The role of state and local police is enforcing their criminal laws,” said Joan Friedland, immigration policy director at the National Immigration Law Center. “Once they take on the mantel of civil immigration enforcement, they really undercut the role that serves their communities. And they’re bound to do it through racial profiling because that’s the way they will identify people.”

Racial profiling is one of many problems addressed in a report released in February by Justice Strategies, a nonprofit research organization focusing on humane and cost-effective approaches to law enforcement. Based on a year-long analysis, the group found that “61 percent of jurisdictions that have entered into 287(g) agreements have crime rates that are lower than the national average. Census data show that 87 percent, however, are undergoing an increase in their Latino populations higher than the national average.” Rather than focusing on serious crime, Justice Strategies found, under 287(g), “police resources are spent targeting day-laborers, corn-vendors and people with broken tail-lights.”

Indeed, ethnic profiling and mistreatment of immigrants is now the subject of a class action lawsuit filed against the notorious Sheriff Joe Arpaio in Arizona, who in addition to calling himself “America’s Toughest Sheriff” now stars in a reality show called “Smile … You’re Under Arrest!,” on Fox. Among his victims bringing the lawsuit are Manuel Nieto, Jr., a U.S. citizen who was detained in front of his family’s auto repair shop after police heard him listening to music in Spanish.

“Joe Arpaio might be the most extreme and obnoxious version of 287(g) run amok, but he is not aberrational,” said Joanne Lin, legislative counsel for the ACLU, which represents the Arizona residents suing Arpaio. “We have examples all across the country of local law enforcement using their authority under the program to harass U.S. citizens and people who look foreign.”

Last summer, for example, Juana Villegas, an undocumented Mexican immigrant who was nine months pregnant, was pulled over while driving in a suburb of Nashville, Tennessee. She was arrested and jailed, and later shackled to a hospital bed with a guard watching over her even as she began to give birth. Her husband was forbidden from seeing her. After she was discharged from the hospital, she wasn’t allowed to see her nursing infant, or even to use a breast pump. She suffered an infection and her baby became jaundiced.

And in May 2007, Peter Guzman, a 30-year-old developmentally disabled American citizen living in Los Angeles, was deported to Mexico after being jailed for trespassing. His family searched for three months until they found him, homeless and begging in Tijuana.

Then just three weeks ago in Tavares, Florida, 23-year-old Rita Cote, a Honduran immigrant, called the police to save her sister, who was being severely beaten by her boyfriend. Instead of arresting the boyfriend, officers arrested Cote in front of her three small children and imprisoned her for being undocumented.

Not surprisingly, there’s growing concern that the program is deterring many immigrants from reporting crimes or sharing information about criminal activity with local law enforcement.

In February, the University of North Carolina law school and the ACLU, after an extensive investigation of the 287(g) program in North Carolina, released a report concluding that immigrants were afraid to contact police if they were victims or witnesses of crimes out of fear of being jailed or deported. “Local law enforcement has established immigration checkpoints in areas frequented by Latinos including churches, flea markets, and trailer parks,” said Rebecca Headen, staff attorney with the ACLU of North Carolina. “Latinos have been arrested for improper vehicle tags, driving without a license, and fishing without a license. State troopers and local sheriffs’ officers detained a bus with Latino passengers for hours for no reason other than the assertion they look foreign. Across North Carolina, Latinos now live under the constant threat that a trip to the grocery store or to Sunday worship could result in the deportation of their families.” Local sheriffs have denied the charges.

Meanwhile, the original mission, to target terrorists and violent criminals, in many communities has been abandoned. Muzzafar Chishti, Director of the Migration Policy Institute, testified at the House committee hearing last Wednesday that based on his organization’s studies, by 2006, some local law enforcement agencies were “seeking to apprehend as many unauthorized immigrants as possible. . . . The focus appears to have shifted from dangerousness of targeted immigrants to raw numbers.” Law enforcement officials have denied that they create quotas for arrests of undocumented immigrants.

Immigrants’ advocates worry that too little is known about the effectiveness and abuses of the program to allow it to continue without further study. The ACLU last week urged Congress to temporarily suspend the program and then study its impact across the country. Department of Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano, who’s been accused of being soft on the popular Sheriff Arpaio when she was governor of Arizona, has said she is reviewing her agency’s immigration enforcement efforts, including the possibility of expanding the 287(g) program.

“We don’t have the national data,” said Lin, of the ACLU. “If ICE headquarters actually built in meaningful controls so we know what the nature of these criminal arrests is, then we’ll know how it’s being implemented. Now it’s anecdotal or piecemeal information. And immigrants who complain about the program’s abuses are putting themselves at risk.”



Comment posted March 9, 2009 @ 11:33 am

“imprison people who look foreign for such minor infractions as driving with a broken tail-light, carrying an open alcoholic beverage container, or fishing without a license.”
First off, they are in the country ILLEGALLY! So as far as I am concerned, they are breaking the law and being arrested of any other infractions is 'moot'.
Don't come here illegally and you will NOT get arrested.

Comment posted March 9, 2009 @ 12:44 pm

Yes, I do agree there are wide abuse.

Abuse of the American Citizen by illegals and taking our jobs, destroying of our economy and filling our jails and the predatory business owners who are profit from both.

If the ACLU actually gave a dam they would be at every company to make sure only American citizens and legal visitors are the only human beings working on site.

Comment posted March 9, 2009 @ 12:53 pm

What I would like to know is the “real” total tax dollar cost per emigrant from the time they are picked up until no more tax dollars are spent on them.

Sure, the law is the law but what is the real coat to taxpayers? If border guards kick 5 illegals out of your little town at a cost of several hundred thousand dollars each, is that really money well spent?

Comment posted March 9, 2009 @ 1:31 pm

My God you are dumb! Large business CEO's, corrupt wall street bankers and greedy lawyers suing doctors have ruined this country.
Socially deprived hermits like you are falling victim to the right wing media propaganda. Undocumented workers are just an excuse to keep morons like you distracted. Part of the reason why Reagan revived the economy years ago was the fact that he granted amnesty to millions of hard working illegal immigrants.

ICE needs complete rebuilding « Later On
Pingback posted March 9, 2009 @ 4:17 pm

[...] in Daily life, Government at 12:17 pm by LeisureGuy Daphne Eviatar in the Washington Independent: When Maricopa County Sheriff Joe Arpaiao parades undocumented immigrants in pink underwear before [...]

true american patriot
Comment posted March 9, 2009 @ 3:52 pm

According to a Zogby poll released last week.The Zogby poll was commissioned by the Federation for American Immigration Reform, or FAIR, a Washington, D.C.-based nonprofit organization that seeks to reform immigration policies. 87 percent of Legal American citizens said they “favor legalization or amnesty for illegal immigrants”

Comment posted March 9, 2009 @ 4:25 pm

The title, “Feds Fail to Prevent Police Abuse” suggests a more important concern: “Feds Fail to Prevent Immigration Abuse.” Unless readers are comfortable with the notion of a U.S. with one billion people here by 2090 they should be very concerned with the latter.

As economist and ethicist Adam Smith said, “Mercy to the guilty is cruelty to the innocent.”

Everything you need to know about immigration and what to do about it humorously told.


(Roy Beck and NumbersUSA are the “gumaball” heroes)

Comment posted March 9, 2009 @ 5:38 pm

What BS. Post a link to the poll, pal.

Comment posted March 9, 2009 @ 7:36 pm




San Diego Border Patrol Sector Apprehensions—Length 66 miles long

El Centro Border Patrol Sector Apprehensions—Length 71 miles long

Yuma Sector began Operation Streamline on December 4, 2006 (FY2007)
Yuma Border Patrol Sector Apprehensions—Length 118 miles long

The Yuma Sector now has a total of 94 miles of fencing

Tucson Sector began Operation Streamline in Jan. 2008
Tucson Border Patrol Sector Apprehensions—Length 262 miles

El Paso Border Patrol Sector Apprehensions—Length 268 miles

01-29-09 In the El Paso sector, crews finished 79 miles of the planned 81 miles of “vehicle fencing,” usually concrete or metal barriers that were mostly installed in the flat New Mexico desert west of El Paso, Cordero said. The 15- to 18-foot tall metal “pedestrian fencing” needs about 11 miles to reach the planned 56 miles in the El Paso region.

Marfa Border Patrol Sector Apprehensions—Length 510 miles

The Del Rio Sector began Operation Streamline on December 5, 2005 (FY2006)
Del Rio Border Patrol Sector Apprehensions—Length 210 miles

The Laredo Sector began Operation Streamline on October 30, 2007 (FY2008)
Laredo Border Patrol Sector Apprehensions—Length 171 miles

Rio Grande Valley Border Patrol Sector Apprehensions——Length 316 miles




Comment posted March 9, 2009 @ 7:39 pm





#1. Make Illegal Entry a Felony Permanently Barring Citizenship
#2. Secure Our Borders with our National Guard!!!
#3. Mandate E-Verify for ALL Employees!!!
#4. Cut Off ALL Public Assistance to Illegals and Their Children!!!
#5. Stop the Underground Economy!!!
#6. End Birthright Citizenship for Illegals!!!
#7. End Chain Migration!!!
#8. Make English our Official Language!!!
#9. Cut Off Federal Funds to Sanctuary Cities!!


Matt Sircely
Comment posted March 10, 2009 @ 2:02 am

Checkpoints and internal patrols are also along the northern border. Here's our experience on the Olympic Peninsula in Washington State:


Comment posted March 10, 2009 @ 9:44 am

They can't “take our” jobs unless someone else offers. You can't blame them for seeking employment, as I'm sure your family once did.

Alison Mejia
Comment posted March 11, 2009 @ 8:18 am

That's what they should have done to your ancestors, clearly.

Alison Mejia
Comment posted March 11, 2009 @ 8:22 am

Adam Smith also wrote extensively about freedom, which you are so terribly willing to give up. How the hell are one billion immigrants coming to America? More are leaving because the economy is so bad. We should be glad they still want to come here, as hypocritical as we are. Free market, until they need money, then hand to gov't. That is the true threat to America. People so willing to givbe up freedom. I guess racial profiling is okay for you, as long as it's not your race. Itr's not okay for me because it chips away at FREEDOM!!!!!!!

Alison Mejia
Comment posted March 11, 2009 @ 8:24 am

That will be great once there is a way to actually come here legally. That's what immigration reform is about, don't ya know.

Alison Mejia
Comment posted March 11, 2009 @ 8:28 am

Actually, research has shown that immigrants contribute strongly to our socail security, because they receive nothing that they put in, especially those working with false documents. Also, the only people being affected by immigrants, both documented and undocumented, are high school drop outs. And that should put the focus on how to keep Americans in school. Outsourcing is taking jobs from high school and college grads, and those people are NOT immigrants. I do not have links because I have read this in newspapers, magazines, and college text books.

Comment posted March 13, 2009 @ 8:09 pm

The only residents of Arpaio's tent city are either serving out convictions or awaiting trail. The illegal aliens there are in criminal detention, which has absolutely nothing to do with the sheriff's federal immigration authority. He may be a jerk, and he may be segregating inmates (including Russians and Jamaicans) with immigration holds on them, but these actions have nothing to do with 287(g). Nothing.

Is it too much to ask to at least get past the nut graph without a major error in fact?

Comment posted March 16, 2009 @ 1:09 am

You are not a reporter. You are a mouth piece for the ACLU. Do you have an original thought?

Comment posted March 16, 2009 @ 8:09 am

You are not a reporter. You are a mouth piece for the ACLU. Do you have an original thought?

Comment posted June 21, 2009 @ 6:12 pm

I totally agree with you Jane! you are absolutely right!

Comment posted July 17, 2009 @ 8:53 pm

Joe Arpaio IS the best sheriff in America. He is probably the only Sheriff who will actually do what he was hired to do. Enforce the law and go after criminals. Of course, that is why the illegals and their advocates hate him. Illegal advocates cry over ANY type of enforcement. Every PD in America should have rights to check on any person they come across committing a crime.

Immigration Program Expands, Despite Abuse Record – Washington Independent « Shut Down ICE
Pingback posted July 26, 2009 @ 2:04 pm

[...] under Uncategorized ·Tagged 287(g), ICE, Local Law Enforcement “Sheriff Joe Arpaio has made a name for himself using controversial tactics targeting illegal immigrants in Arizona. The chief law enforcement [...]

La Frontera Times – Should We Ticket People for Not Speaking English?
Pingback posted October 27, 2009 @ 3:24 pm

[...] due to similar misunderstandings by local police officers, has at times led to the deportation of legal U.S. residents and even citizens, and prompted angry complaints from immigrants’ [...]

Progressive Nation » Blog Archive » Dallas PD will protect and serve… If you speak English
Pingback posted October 27, 2009 @ 3:48 pm

[...] mis­un­der­stand­ings by local police offi­cers, has at times led to the depor­ta­tion of legal U.S. res­i­dents and even cit­i­zens, and prompted angry com­plaints from immi­grants’ [...]

Departing LAPD Chief Warns Against Using Local Cops Against Illegal Immigrants « Yuvablog
Pingback posted October 27, 2009 @ 3:50 pm

[...] is one of many senior law enforcement officials around the country who’ve complained that the 287(g) program, which allows the federal government to enter into agreements that give local police authority to [...]

Discount Louis Vuitton
Comment posted August 20, 2010 @ 9:02 am

and he may be segregating inmates (including Russians and Jamaicans) with immigration holds on them, but these actions have nothing to do with 287(g). Nothing.

Band Saws For Sale
Comment posted September 29, 2010 @ 12:42 pm

What a great theme you get. How it referred to as?

low carb diet plan
Trackback posted October 4, 2010 @ 3:14 am

Thank you……

I Twittered re your fantastic giveaway….

buy toys
Trackback posted October 4, 2010 @ 9:36 pm

Thank you……

Appreciation so much pro this info! I’ll check it all impossible….

bad credit loans
Trackback posted October 5, 2010 @ 3:54 am

Thank you……

I love this post – totally kewl!!! Well done! I’m coming back to this one ……

home mortgage rate
Trackback posted October 16, 2010 @ 12:45 am

Best mortgage rate today…

I completely agree with the above comment, the internet is with a doubt growing into the most important medium of communication across the globe and its due to sites like this that ideas are spreading so quickly….

bad credit loans
Trackback posted October 16, 2010 @ 12:49 am

Best loan rate calculator and refinance…

I loved this article!!! Appreciation!…

list of low fat foods
Trackback posted October 18, 2010 @ 3:42 am

Healthy diet plan…

Thank you sharing those sites. It looks like very nice items….

diets for quick weight loss
Trackback posted October 18, 2010 @ 7:58 am

Rapid weight loss plan and diets…

Thank you for sharing your article I would always follow…

femmalia » ICE Doesn’t Know Where the Money Went:
Pingback posted October 29, 2010 @ 3:48 pm

[...] repeated “crime sweeps” and worksite raids that netted scores of non-criminal immigrants. The backlash proved so intense, in fact, that the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) restricted Arpaio’s [...]

financial planning
Trackback posted November 18, 2010 @ 8:32 am

Financial & Investment Management Advisors…

Good luck everybody! – I will come back again. Are you on facebook or twitter? Will like to follow you.Thanks…

vacation deals
Trackback posted November 20, 2010 @ 12:27 pm

Best Family Holiday Travel Vacation Plan…

I wanted to thank you for this great read!! I definitely enjoying every little bit of it I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you post…

travel tips
Trackback posted November 24, 2010 @ 9:09 am

Best Travel Tips, Tour Guide, Vacation Advice & Holiday Plan…

Impressive post! THANK YOU!…

Photography Lighting
Trackback posted November 28, 2010 @ 11:11 am

Great Photography Tutorials…

this is appreciable.!!!!!!i like it….

gun games
Trackback posted December 3, 2010 @ 10:50 am

Free Games Download – Free Games Online – Free PC Games…

Sunny publish, of use blog, thank you pro your handiwork, keep on, guys!…

recovery toolbox for access
Trackback posted December 4, 2010 @ 11:04 am

Latest Software Reviews, Software Recommendations & Software Comparison…

Your website is without a doubt full of superb details and also is actually rather interesting to scan through.Nicely done….

children toys
Trackback posted December 22, 2010 @ 10:09 am

Buy Soft Toys & Childrens Toy online now!…

This is a great post. Thanks so much for sharing, like always….

low carb recipes
Trackback posted December 25, 2010 @ 12:22 pm

Low Fat & Low Carb Recipes – Healthy Diet Recipes…

Hello! bbceeed interesting bbceeed site!…

pet stores
Trackback posted December 25, 2010 @ 12:54 pm

Pet Supplies, Pet Accessories, Pet Products, Pet food | Pet Shop Online…

To facilitate was a impressive place of duty. It is inspiring on behalf of all. Credit on behalf of sharing to facilitate slice….

fitness program
Trackback posted December 25, 2010 @ 1:56 pm

Online Fitness Program and Weight Loss Exercise Plan…

I now long-established my email subscription! Appreciation!…

women beauty tips
Trackback posted February 6, 2011 @ 9:23 am

Low Fat & Low Carb Recipes – Healthy Diet Recipes…

A very impressive article. Well prepared. Very motivating!! Set off on to way…

womens fitness
Trackback posted February 6, 2011 @ 11:04 am

Best Weight Loss and Health Fitness Exercise Tips…

I totally go along you! I have often felt that way but nobody really would like to take it as seriously as we do apparently. Excellent blog anyway, I am going to have to stop by more frequently….

fitness exercise
Trackback posted February 6, 2011 @ 11:59 am

Best Weight Loss and Health Fitness Exercise Tips…

I wanted to thank you for this great read!! I definitely enjoying every little bit of it I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you post…

Comment posted May 31, 2011 @ 1:35 am

 These simple designs are Rosetta Stone Spanishmasterpieces!! Like one said above, there Christian Louboutin Shoesis a lot of creativity that goes intoRosetta Stone French a simple yet beautiful design. I also enjoy the humor that some Christian Louboutin Sandalsof the designs show, it lets everyone know that Christian Louboutin Slingbackdesigns don’t always have to be serious.

RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.