Welfare drug-testing bill headed to Florida gov’s desk

By
Friday, May 06, 2011 at 12:03 pm

The Florida Senate approved Thursday a measure that will require all recipients of the state program Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) to pass a drug test before receiving benefits, reported Sunshine State News.

Proponents of the measure, sponsored by Sen. Steve Oelrich (R-Cross Creek), have said they want to prevent taxpayer dollars from going to drug use, while opponents have said the law is unjust and discriminatory. With overwhelming Republican support, the Senate approved the mandate for illegal-drug screening 26-11; Gov. Rick Scott is expected to sign the bill.

As The Florida Independent previously reported, Florida tried to drug-test welfare recipients 10 years ago, but a pilot program found it was a waste of money. This new proposal would requires TANF applicants to pay for the drug tests, but according to Sunshine State News, recipients who pass the drug test would be reimbursed for the cost of the test.

A February report (PDF) from the Center for Law and Social Policy found that legislative proposals to drug-test TANF recipients are based on stereotypes, not evidence.

From the CLASP report “Random Drug Testing of TANF Recipients is Costly, Ineffective and Hurts Families” (PDF):

Mandatory drug testing for parents applying for or receiving assistance from the Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) program has been proposed repeatedly over the past few years. Legislators in at least 27 states have proposed suspicionless drug testing with some even extending it to recipients of other public benefits as well, such as unemployment insurance, medical assistance and food assistance. At the federal level, Senator David Vitter (R?LA) has offered bills and amendments multiple times to impose mandatory drug testing on TANF recipients and deny them eligibility if they failed a second test after treatment. The most recent is The Drug Free Families Act of 2011 (S 83). Last summer, Senator Orrin Hatch (R-UT) proposed mandatory drug testing for TANF and unemployment insurance recipients.

Proposals for mandatory drug testing of TANF recipients are based on stereotypes and not evidence. Proponents often claim that drug testing will save money; however, this is based on a false assumption that many applicants will be denied benefits. Random testing is a costly, flawed and inefficient way of identifying recipients in need of treatment. Better alternatives exist and are already being implemented to address drug abuse among TANF beneficiaries and ultimately reduce their barriers to work. Moreover, universal random drug testing may well be unconstitutional.

Comments

7 Comments

Roy Rolling
Comment posted May 6, 2011 @ 4:38 pm

Why stop there? How about Florida disk jockeys who may get tax breaks be tested? Or hospital executives from companies guilty of Medicare fraud that get tax breaks for their businesses be tested, too. They receive government money, I’m sure “the taxpayers” want to be sure they are drug and alcohol free, too, before handing them the cash.


With small victories, Gov. Rick Scott calls session a success – Tampabay.com | news-trends.net
Pingback posted May 8, 2011 @ 8:06 pm

[...] Rick Scott got much of agenda passedOrlando SentinelPalm Beach Post -Naples Daily News -The Washington Independentall 197 news articles » Posted in Breaking News « 17 die in battle inside [...]


Anonymous
Comment posted May 11, 2011 @ 2:06 am

China’s defense ministry said on March 16, puts forward the navy hospital ship and medical teams to Japan rescue application, cheap mbt shoes and many times, asking for the direction of the ship of Chinese medical ship’s detailed materials, MBT Sport to 27 but has formally rejected, reason is port is broken, ships cannot dock. Japan’s kyodo news agency has reported on 26, Coach outlet store though Japan’s foreign ministry put forward that China medical ship aid is navy relations between the two countries improve good opportunity, Coach bags sale but was rebuffed defense ministry.


herry
Comment posted May 20, 2011 @ 9:21 am

There are many online stores having MBT shoes, i believe you gonna like it!    Yesterday, my friend bought a cheap MBT shoes on sale which is so beautiful, i am surprised by the design and style.Do you have a pair of  MBT shoes sale now? if not, go to online store and have one, it is so amazing!!!


herry
Comment posted May 20, 2011 @ 9:23 am

There are many online stores having MBT shoes, i believe you gonna like it!    Yesterday, my friend bought a cheap MBT shoes on sale which is so beautiful, i am surprised by the design and style.Do you have a pair of  MBT shoes sale now? if not, go to online store and have one, it is so amazing!!!


Tonys Joys
Comment posted May 20, 2011 @ 9:40 am

Well-known footwear designers are rising around Europe, mainly because of modern footwear in north america with the rapid development of mass manufacturing, individual nike shoes air max shoemaker unnecessary. Meng inside U. S. footwear via colonial New England, the place that the farmers produce in the kitchen on the winter home of your shoes. The complete family involved. Man lowering leather, affixed soles, women shoes, edge seam. Colonial shoemakers was used in the table is currently a collector’s item. Mastered the art on the shoe, some brave farmer who opened up a small shoe working area, three or four workers when using the local shoemaker material sewn footwear were assembled, on underneath, and then made footwear. 1750, Lyn Massachusetts made a shoe factory, the local shoe technological know-how has been further designed. There is no longer an impartial worker shoes, shoes made section of each trained by a man responsible. Line begins to make. At first, the footwear are still made, but a thing in the low season in order to empower workers to do, footwear do not start reserving Square boss shoes. These shoes these are known as sale shoes, placed within a local shop window. A pair of brothers, Harvey cart charged earlier is for sale made shoes, to a nearby place selling.
Shoes
In 1793, they opened up the first in Boston shoe store, shoe sale made every Wednesday and Sunday. Since mid-eighteenth century, inventors happen to be working on improvements in sewing machines. Until 1790, the air jordan online 1st special sewing machines to get leather processing was improved by an Englishman out and about. It is almost simply a straight up punch inside leather awl. Britain’s Make. Bulang Le He has been formerly the chief engineer of New York Harbor, he invented a media that can be utilized metal needles to sew way up upper and sole. For in great britain due diligence in the war versus Napoleon, in the disabled veterans with the help of Bu Langle produce six hundred pairs of air jordan sale shoes per day. After the war finished, the British footwear industry has go back to manual mode. Around 1810, the United States experienced a identical machine. Concurrently, the two wells Ge Bule and Yuelileer called the French in Paris to produce such machines. A Ming Jiaobu Lexi’s footwear Stuttgart, Germany, who tried to use screws to connect the upper and lone. Around 1829, Merrimack, Massachusetts, to take greater than a Austria, bringing the appliance to the final noise spikes. Around 1812, Thomas Sutton, Massachusetts, Blanchard has been, to a process of rifle used by the lathe wood into the shoe last appliance, footwear last is a shoe-shaped wood made mold made, shoes above it can be assembled. Thirties in your nineteenth century, or around nike air max 95 New England, your shoemaker began to cut by way of the mold upper, rather than relying on individual sawing skills. Nineteenth millennium, forties, rolling the necessary paperwork of compression in your leather, easy to rear upper molding and reinforcement. Britons continue in order to hand-shoe, until the later nineteenth century, before your needs of the overall economy forced into devices. Then they discovered that all of the patents belong to your Americans, the Americans they needed to rent the machine, and pay royalties. But England also retained a robust tradition of hand crafted shoes.
 


Deanna
Comment posted August 16, 2011 @ 2:27 am

http://www.commonblog.com/2011/08/12/florida%E2%80%99s-bad-tanf-policy/ why I think this law is bad government!


RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.