Palin and Folksiness

By
Friday, October 03, 2008 at 6:15 pm

Somewhere after Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin’s fourth “Gee” in last night’s vice-presidential debate, I lost it. In writing about the presidential campaign, I think I’ve been fair in calling people out when called for and praising people when they deserve to be praised.

But Palin’s performance last night was more than fodder for a “Saturday Night Live” skit. It was an embarrassment to those who come from small towns.

After the debate, many pundits declared that Palin’s style of speaking is authentic, a breath of fresh air, a cadence that plays well in middle America.

Well, gosh darn, golly gee, I come from middle America, went to school with the sons and daughters of farmers, knew people who struggled to go to college.  And there’s only one thing I felt about Palin’s “authenticity”–insulted.

Palin is not authentic. She instead is what people who live on the coasts believe to be middle America.

She insulted me in another way.

Palin’s debate performance was a slap in the face of some great people who have made great contributions to the betterment of this country during some of its darkest hours–but who didn’t happen to come from small-town America.

What, for example, would Palin say of Teddy Roosevelt–Sen. John McCain’s supposed hero–and his experience?

Born to great affluence, Roosevelt was a man who suffered great tragedy, disappeared into the Badlands only to emerge as the man who busted up the trusts.

And what would Palin say of Franklin Roosevelt and his wife, Eleanor, neither of whom suffered through the Great Depression but who inspired a nation to raise itself from the ashes of economic collapse by showing Americans how to reclaim their national spirit and self-worth?

And certainly Palin would have had a field day with Bobby Kennedy, who also came from great wealth but understood and cared for poor people as no politician has since his assassination in June 1968.  Would she have mocked his knowledge of the ancient Greek poets? Would she have ridiculed his large home, his father’s wealth?

The truth is, Palin represents something troubling in U.S. politics. In seeking to be the champion of the struggling middle class, she uses her folksiness to discredit and mock the possibility that someone who speaks with intelligence, grace and reason can know what it means to suffer.

I would search for a quotation here, but I suppose that would show my disconnect from the common folks.

Comments

10 Comments

bernadette
Comment posted October 3, 2008 @ 4:09 pm

excellent observation. Yes i too have read with bewilderment comments about her bring 'authentic'. I find her false, manipulative and insulting; mean, divisive and dangerous. How can she be for education when she belittles the educated. Is she trying to say that small town equals stupid, simple, as in simple-minded. I don't trust the woman. And the fake smile makes me ill.


sherry
Comment posted October 3, 2008 @ 4:35 pm

You state it exactly right. I find it hard to believe that people actually think she speaks for the middle class. I struggled to go to college as a single mom but did it and I find her insulting and not authentic at all. It's like she is talking down to people. I think someone running for the Vice President of the US should be more professional and try to address the public in such a way. Biden seemed more authentic than Palin in my opinion and I could relate to him more. It amazes me that anyone likes her “folkiness”.


C. Neiman
Comment posted October 3, 2008 @ 5:56 pm

I also felt that Palin's mannered folksiness was nothing like the way most regular folk speak and was insulting — condescending — to them.


ca Gullotta
Comment posted October 3, 2008 @ 6:20 pm

I'm sure she is not ridculing anyone. She comes from an area where that is common speech. I'm sure as and educated person she can adjust her speech to address who she is talking to. Since her debate appearance was aimed at a specific audience she was just fine. Maybe you are the one ridiculing ? Not every part of the country has the same speech patterns. Most times not even the same state has the same lingo. We are all Americans looking for a better way. Attack and question each other paths to get their not the people who are trying to make the difference.


Sammy
Comment posted October 3, 2008 @ 6:50 pm

According to someone I know who is from Alaska, Palin has a fake accent. She never talked this way before being selected to McCain and her accent has gotten more extreme since the.

I am from a small town and was the first in my family to atend college and i never spoke in this manner. Even those in my family who never attended college speaks this way.

She is an insult to women who have worked hard to advance themselves.


mike
Comment posted October 4, 2008 @ 10:07 pm

While watching McCain self destruct, and seeing some hints of frayed nerves on his part, Palin is suddenly less of a joke and more of a very frightening nightmare. There is more below the surface of this woman then the hockey mom persona. She could make the Cheney Vice Presidency seem like a walk in the park if God forbid she should ever end up behind the desk in the oval office, a possibility that is far more likely then not if they win in November.


jupitor
Comment posted October 5, 2008 @ 1:24 pm

I'm from middle america, Nebrask. I can tell you all I saw from palin was a lot of old fashion flirting and dodgeing the issues! We middle americans don't use the word gee much at all. Were all eduacated enough now to not use “Drill baby Drill' statements, even in jest. This gal darn sure ain't from any small town I know of, and I surrounded by farms, and farmers in this small community, and Palin made a laughing stock of herself. Reading off a coffee cup in calif, on a statment Mrs. Albright made almost inflamed middle america when he couldn't even read it right, and proclaim women would go to hell if they didn't support other women just about took the cake! This gal needs to travel some, to understand the american small town people before she tries to claim she is one!


Maine_Voter
Comment posted October 5, 2008 @ 9:20 pm

I wondered if the folksiness was totally put on and went looking for older youtube videos of Sarah, from back before she was named to the ticket.

Sure enough, I found an earlier interview with Charlie Rose, and some Alaska debates, and while she had that accent and dropped her g's, she didn't do the winks, and all the Joe Sixpack, hockey mom, middle class references.

She's obviously pandering now.


Virginia Doland
Comment posted October 6, 2008 @ 12:45 pm

Thank you. I also grew up in a small dairy farming town, went to school with the sons and daughters of farmers (my grandmother was a farmer), my parents struggled to send me to college, but I paid for my own Ph.D. I spent 40 years as a university professor whose specialty was literary theory and interpretation but you helped me to understand why I was so absolutely outraged about the Palin debate. Thank you! Virginia Doland


Virginia Doland
Comment posted October 6, 2008 @ 7:45 pm

Thank you. I also grew up in a small dairy farming town, went to school with the sons and daughters of farmers (my grandmother was a farmer), my parents struggled to send me to college, but I paid for my own Ph.D. I spent 40 years as a university professor whose specialty was literary theory and interpretation but you helped me to understand why I was so absolutely outraged about the Palin debate. Thank you! Virginia Doland


RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.