ICE official reportedly unaware of domestic violence argument against Secure Communities

By
Wednesday, November 10, 2010 at 9:42 am

I have a story today on the ever-confusing opt-out process for Secure Communities, an immigration enforcement program that shares fingerprints collected by local police with federal immigration officials. David Venturella, the executive director of Secure Communities, met with county officials in Arlington, Va., San Francisco and Santa Clara, Calif., recently to report that their localities cannot abstain from sharing fingerprints with Immigration and Customs Enforcement — even though the counties claim that doing so violates their law enforcement policies of avoiding checks on immigration status.

The problem with the program, according to critics, is that it sometimes nets non-criminal illegal immigrants, including victims of domestic abuse. Police sometimes arrest (and fingerprint) both parties in instances of domestic violence, then later charge the person determined to be the likely perpetrator and release the other(s) without filing charges. In the three counties that wanted to be removed from Secure Communities, police said the program could deter undocumented immigrants from reporting crime and lessen overall public safety.

But when law enforcement officials in San Francisco mentioned this concern to Venturella, he was reportedly confused and said he hadn’t heard of such a concern, according to a lawyer who was briefed on the Tuesday meeting.

“David Venturella was confused by the domestic violence problem,” Angela Chan, a staff attorney with Asian Law Caucus who has been critical of Secure Communities, told TWI. “ICE didn’t have much of a response. I don’t know if they were being disingenuous and they hadn’t heard of it, but it’s a pretty common criticism of the program.”

ICE did not respond to multiple requests for comment.

In general, Chan said she was told community policing concerns were not addressed by ICE officials during the meeting in San Francisco on Tuesday. But such concerns have been a central tenet of why counties asked to be removed from the program in the first place — and have gotten a reasonable amount of media attention.

The Washington Post reported on Nov. 1 about a Hyattsville, Md., woman who called the police after a fight with her partner. The woman, who is in the country illegally, claims the call put her on the radar of a local police officer who later charged her with illegally selling phone cards, an allegation she denies. The charge was thrown out, but her fingerprints had already been shared with immigration authorities under Secure Communities, and she now faces deportation.

ICE officials told the Post the agency has the right to pursue deportation if it discovers someone is in the country illegally:

“ICE cannot and will not turn a blind eye to those who violate federal immigration law,” said Immigration and Customs Enforcement spokesman Brian Hale. “While ICE’s enforcement efforts prioritize convicted criminal aliens, ICE maintains the discretion to take action on any alien it encounters.”

In other situations, critics of the Secure Communities program say that police make two arrests and then determine who is the victim of abuse once at the station — but after fingerprints have begun to make their way into the hands of immigration authorities.

The immigration system has some protection for victims of domestic violence: As I mentioned yesterday, foreign-born spouses of Americans can petition for citizenship on their own — bypassing abusive spouses — if they can prove abuse. For undocumented immigrants, U visas are available to victims of certain crimes, including domestic violence. These visas grant victims the right to remain in the United States and work legally, but are granted based on the discretion of law enforcement agencies, which sometimes differ on what crimes merit the visas.

Follow Elise Foley on Twitter


Comments

20 Comments

Cheap Pressure Washers » Blog Archive » Domestic Appliance Spares on the Internet
Pingback posted November 10, 2010 @ 9:58 am

[...] ICE official reportedly unaware of domestic violence argument … [...]


Tweets that mention ICE official reportedly unaware of domestic violence argument against Secure Communities « The Washington Independent -- Topsy.com
Pingback posted November 10, 2010 @ 10:23 am

[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Aaron Wiener and Elise Foley, WashIndependent. WashIndependent said: ICE official reportedly unaware of domestic violence argument against Secure Communities http://bit.ly/buAuWf [...]


This Could Be Your Town » ICE official reportedly unaware of domestic violence argument against Secure … – The Washington Independent
Pingback posted November 10, 2010 @ 11:16 am

[...] More: ICE official reportedly unaware of domestic violence argument against Secure … – The Was… [...]


WWII bomb coming second e? has it? Warsaw airport | MATCH DATING ONLINE ON HERE
Pingback posted November 10, 2010 @ 12:42 pm

[...] ICE official reportedly unaware of domestic violence argument … [...]


ICE official reportedly unaware of domestic violence argument … Car body on me
Pingback posted November 10, 2010 @ 1:12 pm

[...] post:  ICE official reportedly unaware of domestic violence argument … By admin | category: criminal francisco lawyer san | tags: accident, both-parties, car, [...]


tj
Comment posted November 10, 2010 @ 2:54 pm

Just being in the country illegally makes them a criminal


Indonesian Official Alleges Handshake with Michelle Obama Was Non-Consensual | The News of World
Pingback posted November 10, 2010 @ 3:21 pm

[...] ICE official reportedly unknowingly of made at home assault evidence … [...]


magyart
Comment posted November 10, 2010 @ 11:53 pm

Local law enforcement agencies do what they have always done. They electronically submit electronic finger prints to the state and the FBI. With this Initiative local law enforcement also submits this identical information to ICE. It's now a seamless, single step process.

The federal govt. remains in firm control of the decision making process regarding one's immigration status. The federal govt. still makes the hold or release decision regarding illegal residents. Secure Communities has the support of sheriff offices all over the country. It's a proven method of improving our safety and security. I'm glad it's in my county.

“While ICE’s enforcement efforts prioritize convicted criminal aliens, it's under no obligation to turn a blind eye to low level criminals or residents having committed no crime, but are illegally here.

EVERYONE with an illegal status is subject to deportation.


The Media Consortium: Weekly Diaspora: ICE Deports Children, Disabled, and Domestic Violence Victims :: Natural Health
Pingback posted November 11, 2010 @ 11:56 am

[...] ICE official reportedly unaware of domestic violence argument … [...]


eurasian culture » Blog Archive » Is it possible for a Tai-Chi martial artist to best a Boxer?
Pingback posted November 11, 2010 @ 4:54 pm

[...] ICE official reportedly unaware of domestic violence argument … [...]


The Google Traffic Pump System » Blog Archive » The Media Consortium: Weekly Diaspora: ICE Deports Children, Disabled, and Domestic Violence Victims
Pingback posted November 11, 2010 @ 8:07 pm

[...] ICE central reportedly unknowingly of domestic violence evidence … [...]


Ban the Burqa? The Argument in Favor :: Natural Health
Pingback posted November 11, 2010 @ 8:50 pm

[...] ICE official reportedly unaware of domestic violence argument … [...]


An argument, rum shots – then a deadly crash | MATCH DATING ONLINE ON HERE
Pingback posted November 11, 2010 @ 10:23 pm

[...] ICE official reportedly unaware of domestic violence argument … [...]


Africans top credit card crime list: Dubai Police | online credit reports
Pingback posted November 11, 2010 @ 11:04 pm

[...] ICE official reportedly unaware of domestic violence argument … [...]


ICE official reportedly unaware of domestic violence argument … - UAE Blog
Pingback posted November 12, 2010 @ 1:50 am

[...] reading here: ICE official reportedly unaware of domestic violence argument … // ICE official reportedly unaware of domestic violence argument … stated [...]


Would you buy a sollar cell for your house energy if it was cheaper than electricity? « Solar Landscape Lighting
Pingback posted November 12, 2010 @ 7:06 pm

[...] ICE official reportedly unaware of domestic violence argument … [...]


Addiction | Addiction to Alcohol
Pingback posted November 13, 2010 @ 2:25 pm

[...] ICE official reportedly unaware &#959f domestic violence argument against Secure Communities «… [...]


Article Marketing | How To Write Your First Article About Your Niche Posted By: Monty Clarke | Moneysiteproducts Blog
Pingback posted November 14, 2010 @ 12:07 am

[...] ICE official reportedly unaware of domestic violence argument against Secure Communities « The… [...]


Second Life To Remove Need For Client, Having Removed Need For … | transformers 2 toys
Pingback posted November 17, 2010 @ 1:25 pm

[...] ICE official reportedly unaware of domestic violence argument … [...]


Catherine A. TraywickDHS Fails Again. » Catherine A. Traywick:
Pingback posted February 4, 2011 @ 9:26 pm

[...] The agency’s two largest enforce­ment pro­grams, 287(g) and Secure Com­mu­ni­ties, have been hotly crit­i­cized for net­ting large num­bers of non-criminal immigrants—among them, indi­vid­u­als guilty of mere traf­fic vio­la­tions. While the 287(g) pro­gram empow­ers local law enforce­ment to act as immi­gra­tion agents—provoking alle­ga­tions of racial pro­fil­ing—Secure Com­mu­ni­ties requires local jails to share fin­ger­prints with Immi­gra­tion and Cus­toms Enforce­ment (ICE)—leading, noto­ri­ously, to the deten­tion of undoc­u­mented domes­tic vio­lence vic­tims. [...]


RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.