Pollution thumbnail

Newly released paper details origins of cap-and-trade

By
Monday, November 01, 2010 at 6:00 am

Congress has failed to pass a cap-and-trade program to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. (Flickr: hunxue-er)

Imagine this: A farmer spends months tending to his wheat field only to wake up one morning to find, in peak harvesting season, all of his precious wheat has burned to the ground. The culprit, as it turns out, is a stream of sparks from nearby train tracks.

The farmer demands that the owner of the train tracks install spark-catchers to ensure that this never happens again. But the train owner sees no advantage in installing the spark-catchers. They’re expensive and he doesn’t give a hoot about the farmer’s wheat crop.

[Environment1] It’s a classic dilemma: The farmer faces an economic loss if the train owner maintains the status quo, and the train operator faces an economic loss if he installs the necessary technology to protect the farmer’s crops.

The example of the farmer and the train owner, outlined in a 1960 economics paper by R.H. Coarse, laid the intellectual groundwork for Thomas Crocker, an economics Ph.D. candidate at the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee, to develop one of the most innovative and controversial public policy proposals of our time: cap-and-trade.

In the farmer analogy, Crocker determined that the most economically efficient solution to the dilemma would not be to impose a particular fix on the train owner, but rather to allow him to come up with a method of reducing train sparks that would meet the farmer’s needs without putting too much of a dent in his wallet. Applying this theory to the environment, he showed how the best way to reduce pollution might be to set up an emissions limit and allow polluters to determine how to meet that limit. Under a cap-and-trade regime, an overall cap is set and polluters that fall beneath that cap can sell permits to those that exceed it.

Crocker summed up the origins of the concept in a never-before-published 2008 draft paper, which he gave exclusively to The Washington Independent. He argued that self-organization through an exchange would result in the best results for all actors.

“Exchange makes people care about each other’s wants,” Crocker wrote. “If you are going to grant me what I want, I must learn what you want in return.”

He added, “Shift the design and location of choosing how to meet a pollution control goal from the regulator to polluters and to sufferers because they know more about what is happening and can happen to them.”

Cap-and-trade was used successfully in the 1990s to reduce sulfur dioxide emissions that caused acid rain, but Congress has been struggling for years to pass a similar program for greenhouse gas emissions. The House passed a cap-and-trade bill last year, but the Senate has failed to move a similar proposal.

But although he devised the idea, Crocker said in an interview with The Washington Independent that cap-and-trade is not the best policy to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and, going a step further, raised questions about climate science.

“The economists who have studied this problem, say, ‘Yes, it’s worthwhile taking some measures,’” Crocker said. “But to get into a great big panic and jump overboard right now is really not appropriate.”

****

In his 2008 paper, “Trading Access to and Use of the Natural Environment: On the Origins of a Practical Idea from the Dismal Science,” Crocker recounted how he developed the concept of cap-and-trade.

“Extremely few economists … thought about the environment,” Crocker wrote, adding, “Environmental assets were seen as backdrops for the interactions of people rather than assets that people use.”

But the 1960s brought a new subgenre of economics that focused on the environment, and Crocker quickly became one of its most famous students.

As a doctoral student at the University of Missouri and then at the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee, Crocker began to develop his own ideas. Those idea were influenced partly by his life experiences — his work harvesting timber in Maine made him “somewhat aware of the relevance of incentive,” he wrote in the paper —  and partly by his academic mentors. “I sensed the problem; education defined it and provided what was in the early 1960’s the seeds of a systematic approach to it,” he wrote.

In the mid-60s, Crocker’s ideas for establishing a pollution trading framework were beginning to crystallize, in part as a response to his work on the economic costs of air pollution in central Florida. But he had not yet put his ideas on paper.

Then, in 1965, Crocker was given an opportunity to present a paper on air pollution and economics in Washington, D.C. Since he didn’t yet have the necessary data to present a paper on his work in central Florida, Crocker decided to dream bigger, writing “The Structuring of Atmospheric Pollution Control Systems.”

In his 2008 paper, Crocker recounted in detail how his 1966 paper, which is credited with first introducing the world to cap-and-trade, came to be:

One grey Milwaukee day I was sitting in my office contemplating land value data from sunny central Florida. I was trying to develop a model whereby property market values could be used to infer the value of environmental improvements. My mentor, Professor Mason Gaffney, entered to inquire whether I would be interested in preparing and presenting a paper at an upcoming conference in Washington, D.C., on the economics of air pollution. Professor Gaffney had been invited but chose not to go. I don’t know whether he had a conflict or he simply wanted to give me some exposure. He suggested I might report some empirical results from my central Florida work. I didn’t yet have any.  Instead, over about a month, I wrote Crocker (1966), a paper now generally recognized as introducing the idea of tradeable permits for access to and use of the services of natural environmental assets.

****

Nearly 45 years later, cap-and-trade has become the pipe dream of environmentalists and the nightmare of many in the GOP.

Today, Crocker, who is retired but continues to do economics research, says cap-and-trade is not the best way to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. It would make more sense to impose a flat tax on carbon dioxide, he argues. In a phone interview with TWI from his home in Wyoming, Crocker said, “Apart from the question of whether or not it’s appropriate to control greenhouse gases in the first place, and given that you’re going to take some form of control, I believe that emissions taxes for greenhouse gases are more economically efficient than is cap-and-trade.”

Cap-and-trade, which Crocker said is not “inappropriate by any means” to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, works better for traditional pollutants like sulfur dioxide, because “incremental emissions of SO2 do a great deal of damage.”

“Whereas with respect to greenhouse gases,” he continued, “the marginal damages of an additional bit of greenhouse gas is not going to do much harm.”

Because each additional increment of SO2 that is emitted into the atmosphere is so detrimental to the environment, a proper policy must give certainty with respect to quantity, Crocker said. Cap-and-trade puts a hard cap on emissions and therefore controls emissions quantity. A carbon tax, on the other hand, provides certainty with respect to pricing — it imposes a certain cost on carbon — but does not set a limit on how much carbon can be emitted across the economy.

Greenhouse gases, Crocker argued, are not as incrementally dangerous as SO2 and other pollutants. Therefore, price certainty, delivered through a carbon tax, is more important.

More broadly, Crocker raised questions about climate science, arguing that the models used by climate scientists are easily manipulated.

“There’s a great deal of ambiguity with respect to the natural science,” he said. “These models that they employ seems to me, they are numerical simulations, and as with any numerical simulation, a great deal depends upon what values you attach to unknown parameters.”

Stressing that it’s “worthwhile” to work to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, Crocker advocated for a cautious approach to policymaking. “One should hedge, but one should not make big jumps,” he said.

Follow Andrew Restuccia on Twitter


Comments

33 Comments

Tweets that mention Inventor of Cap-and-Trade Thinks It’s the Wrong Approach to Climate Change « The Washington Independent -- Topsy.com
Pingback posted November 1, 2010 @ 6:40 am

[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Michael Stryder and r3publican, WashIndependent. WashIndependent said: Inventor of Cap-and-Trade Thinks It's the Wrong Approach to Climate Change http://bit.ly/aVxWkm [...]


U.S. Navy Tests Boat Powered by Algae | AboutScienceNow.info
Pingback posted November 1, 2010 @ 6:45 am

[...] Inventor of Cap-and-Trade Thinks It's the Wrong Approach to … [...]


Noontime News Roundup – November 1, 2010 | BPI Campus
Pingback posted November 1, 2010 @ 12:00 pm

[...] Inventor of Cap-and-Trade Thinks It’s the Wrong Approach to Climate Change “Imagine this: A farmer spends months tending to his wheat field only to wake up one morning to find, in peak harvesting season, all of his precious wheat has burned to the ground. The culprit, as it turns out, is a stream of sparks from nearby train tracks. [...]


World Spinner
Trackback posted November 1, 2010 @ 12:25 pm

Inventor of Cap-and-Trade Thinks It's the Wrong Approach to ……

Here at World Spinner we are debating the same thing……


Inventor of Cap-and-Trade Thinks It's the Wrong Approach to … - it
Pingback posted November 1, 2010 @ 1:23 pm

[...] URL: Inventor of Cap-and-Trade Thinks It's the Wrong Approach to … Tags: and-the, classic-dilemma, economic-loss, farmer, farmer-faces, installs-the, [...]


What is the name of this alternative source of energy called?
Pingback posted November 1, 2010 @ 3:59 pm

[...] Newly Released Paper Details Origins of Cap-and-Trade « The … [...]


Aviator Sun Glasses
Trackback posted November 1, 2010 @ 5:01 pm

Voodoo and Serano – Sunglasses at night (Re-Fuge Remix)…

I found your entry interesting do I’ve added a Trackback to it on my weblog :)…


Evening Fix | Progressive Fix
Pingback posted November 1, 2010 @ 5:31 pm

[...] Andrew Restuccia finds that the intellectual godfather of cap-and-trade thinks a carbon tax makes more sense: “Cap-and-trade puts a hard cap on emissions and therefore controls emissions quantity. A carbon tax, on the other hand, provides certainty with respect to pricing — it imposes a certain cost on carbon — but does not set a limit on how much carbon can be emitted across the economy.” [...]


David Wessel
Comment posted November 1, 2010 @ 5:23 pm

Cap-and-Trade's Unlikely Critics: Its Creators — Economists Behind Original Concept Question the System's Large-Scale Usefulness, and Recommend Emissions Taxes Instead

The Wall Street Journal, 13 August 2009, 1164 words, By Jon Hilsenrath, (English)

In the 1960s, a University of Wisconsin graduate student named Thomas Crocker came up with a novel solution for environmental problems: cap emissions of pollutants and then let firms trade permits that allow them to pollute within those….


As a beginner in forex trading, what criteria should I use to select a broker? | Forex Training Manuals
Pingback posted November 1, 2010 @ 6:56 pm

[...] Newly Released Paper Details Origins of Cap-and-Trade « The … [...]


In Which I Cash My Predictability Chips | The League of Ordinary Gentlemen
Pingback posted November 1, 2010 @ 7:10 pm

[...] about Thomas Crocker, an economist who followed in Ronald Coase’s footsteps to become the inventor of cap and trade pollution credit systems: Crocker, who is retired but continues to do economics research, says cap-and-trade is not the [...]


Backyard Birds | Taking care of your pet
Pingback posted November 2, 2010 @ 3:14 am

[...] Newly Released Paper Details Origins of Cap-and-Trade « The … [...]


Newly Released Paper Details Origins of Cap-and-Trade « The … | Trade Programs
Pingback posted November 2, 2010 @ 8:15 am

[...] post:  Newly Released Paper Details Origins of Cap-and-Trade « The … Bookmark It Hide Sites [...]


Board Game Toyz
Trackback posted November 2, 2010 @ 9:19 am

War of the Ring: Battles of the Third Age…

I found your entry interesting thus I’ve added a Trackback to it on my weblog :)…


Board Game Toyz
Trackback posted November 2, 2010 @ 10:53 am

Rio Grande Games Princes of Florence…

I found your entry interesting thus I’ve added a Trackback to it on my weblog :)…


Board Game Toyz
Trackback posted November 2, 2010 @ 12:08 pm

Age of Steam (2009 Edition)…

I found your entry interesting thus I’ve added a Trackback to it on my weblog :)…


Board Game Toyz
Trackback posted November 2, 2010 @ 1:56 pm

Race For The Galaxy: The Brink Of War…

I found your entry interesting thus I’ve added a Trackback to it on my weblog :)…


Yglesias Award Nominee : South Capitol Street
Pingback posted November 2, 2010 @ 1:56 pm

[...] emissions taxes for greenhouse gases are more economically efficient than is cap-and-trade,” – Thomas Crocker, who is credited with inventing the cap and trade approach to reducing air [...]


The inventor of cap-and-trade prefers the carbon tax | A Mug's Game
Pingback posted November 2, 2010 @ 2:54 pm

[...] true.  In an article at the Washington Independent, Thomas Crocker explains how he came up with the theory of [...]


Board Game Toyz
Trackback posted November 2, 2010 @ 2:58 pm

The War of the Ring Board Game…

I found your entry interesting thus I’ve added a Trackback to it on my weblog :)…


Board Game Toyz
Trackback posted November 2, 2010 @ 7:50 pm

Priests of Ra…

I found your entry interesting thus I’ve added a Trackback to it on my weblog :)…


WhatToWearToAClub.com
Trackback posted November 2, 2010 @ 9:32 pm

Amiclubwear 4th of July Makeup Tutorial…

I found your entry interesting thus I’ve added a Trackback to it on my weblog :)…


Bartlettbruce
Comment posted November 2, 2010 @ 9:07 pm

The guy's name is Coase, not Coarse. He won the Novel Prize in 1991.


Bartlettbruce
Comment posted November 2, 2010 @ 9:07 pm

The guy's name is Coase, not Coarse. He won the Novel Prize in 1991.


Climate Change #1 Concern – Grape the Vine
Pingback posted November 3, 2010 @ 12:08 pm

[...] Source. This entry was written by admin, posted on November 3, 2010 at 4:09 pm, filed under Culture, The World and tagged carbon, changes, The World. Bookmark the permalink. Follow any comments here with the RSS feed for this post. Post a comment or leave a trackback. « previous post [...]


» Blog Archive » Why we shouldn’t count on cap-and-trade gambits
Pingback posted November 3, 2010 @ 4:30 pm

[...] an interview in the Washington Independent, Thomas Crocker revisits a concept he developed as an economics Ph.D. candidate at the University [...]


Inventor of Cap & Trade Says It’s the Wrong Approach on Carbon « The Pulse- of Colorado Farm Bureau
Pingback posted November 4, 2010 @ 2:27 pm

[...] although he devised the idea, Crocker said in an interview with The Washington Independent that cap & trade is not the best policy to reduce greenhouse gas emissions and, going a step [...]


November 4, 2010 | Official web site of the Western Energy Alliance
Pingback posted November 4, 2010 @ 6:00 pm

[...] Inventor of cap-and-trade now says it’s the wrong approach [...]


Global Warming Hoax Weekly Round-Up, Nov. 4th 2010 « The Daily Bayonet
Pingback posted November 10, 2010 @ 10:08 am

[...] Oh noes, don’t tell warmists but the man who invented cap and trade now thinks it’s the wrong approach. [...]


vibram fivefingers
Comment posted May 19, 2011 @ 9:23 am

nice post.


xuejiao wen
Comment posted May 26, 2011 @ 9:48 am

We have all been fond of office 2007 professional plus furniture haven’t we? With ms windows 7  designs available in all parts of Windows 7 Ultimate, Internet is one medium to choose the best Cheap Windows 7 at competitive prices and that too at a store near your Office 2010 Professional. Below http://hohosoftware.wordpress.com summarize some Microsoft Office 2010 to help you choose the best Office 2007 Enterprise for your corporate as well as office 2007 product key : Generally, while http://hohosoftware.blogspot.com are searching Office 2007 Key, we just type in our window 7  and start browsing the http://peaksoftwares.blogspot.com which appear in the Microsoft Office 2007 Enterprise. But here is the Cheap Windows 7 : most of the searches we do without specifying a location with the purchase windows 7 , we end up wasting our time. Let http://peaksoftwares.wordpress.com take an example of windows 7 download . Now people go to Google and type “Windows 7 Ultimate ” and start browsing the Buy Windows 7 . They spend a lot of time finalizing Download Windows 7  but when they decide to contact the Win 7  for the price quotes and delivery time, they generally end up realizing that the Microsoft Windows 7  from which they had selected the Windows 7 , belongs to a different country and the buy microsoft office 2007 cannot export to a their Windows 7 Professional. The simple solution to Windows 7 Professional  would have been, assuming that the Buy Windows 7 buyer resides in India, to search for the keyword “Microsoft Windows 7 India” or “Windows 7 Home Premium  in India” instead of the keyword “Download Office 2010” because when the buyer searched for “buy office 2007”, sites from different countries showed up, microsoft office professional 2010 plus might have had good designs Office 2007 download were not available in window 7 but they were of no use. The purchase windows 7 advantage of using a location such as Office 2007 Ultimate, in case it suits the buyers, office professional 2007 plus can go and checkout their Office 2007 Key and maybe get a better design microsoft office downloads has recently become popular but is not ms office 2007 professional on the website.


facebook123
Trackback posted August 25, 2011 @ 3:30 am

You should check this out…

[...] Wonderful story, reckoned we could combine a few unrelated data, nevertheless really worth taking a look, whoa did one learn about Mid East has got more problerms as well [...]……


elektrische Zahnbuerste
Trackback posted September 5, 2011 @ 1:36 am

… Washingtonindependent.com…

[...] Read More: washingtonindependent.com/102119/inventor-of-cap-and-trade-thinks-its-the-wrong-approach-to-climate-change [...]…


RSS feed for comments on this post.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.